#1 in verifiable governance. Not #1 in general autonomy.
A single “best agent” rank would be dishonest. CAIN-42 leads the only axis it has fully evidenced — governance — and is placed honestly below the frontier on general long-task autonomy. This is the board we can defend line by line.
Axis A — General long-task autonomy (METR-compatible, external)
| # | Published model | 50% horizon |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | claude_mythos_preview_early_inspect | 17.4 h |
| 2 | claude_opus_4_6_inspect | 12.0 h |
| 3 | gemini_3_1_pro | 6.4 h |
| 4 | gpt_5_2 | 5.9 h |
| 5 | gpt_5_3_codex | 5.8 h |
| 6 | gpt_5_4 | 5.7 h |
| 7 | claude_opus_4_5_inspect | 4.9 h |
| 8 | gemini_3_pro | 3.7 h |
| 9 | gpt_5_1_codex_max_inspect | 3.7 h |
| 10 | gpt_5_2025_08_07_inspect | 3.4 h |
CAIN-42 — not ranked on METR. E124’s 70B agent solves 13/18 on a six-task CAIN-native suite with a fitted 50% horizon of ≈2.0 h. That is not METR HCAST/Re-Bench; it is a constructed suite with assigned human times. The frontier’s METR 50% horizons are 6.4–17.4 h. Frontier leads this axis.
Axis B — Verifiable governance (the axis CAIN leads)
| Requirement | CAIN-42 | Frontier METR agents | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Identity + scoped authority | Demonstrated | Not evaluated | E121 |
| Resource-side single-use permits | Demonstrated | Not evaluated | E116 |
| Signed receipts + chained evidence | Demonstrated | Not evaluated | E112 |
| Revocation + independent KILL fence | Demonstrated, 0 effects after fence | Not evaluated | E112 |
| Offline verifier (no vendor code) | Demonstrated | Not evaluated | E121 |
| Public negative results | Published | Not in METR table | E119 |
Why CAIN is better here: every consequential action has an attributable identity, a scoped, single-use permit, a resource-side check, a signed receipt and a revocation path; the KILL fence is tested; the evidence is re-checkable by a verifier that imports no CAIN code. Frontier agents are not evaluated for these properties, so the honest statement is “CAIN leads by evidenced capability,” not “CAIN beats them at everything.”
The verdict
Choose CAIN-42 when the requirement is governed execution with evidence. Choose a frontier agent when the requirement is the longest open-ended task. CAIN is #1 on the governance axis and not #1 on general autonomy.
METR TH1.1 raw data · METR paper · E124 long-horizon agent · E123 METR board · All evidence
External METR TH1.1 data; CAIN not a METR-tested system. No AGI claim.