{
  "agreement": [
    {
      "all_certified": true,
      "f": 1,
      "final_state_root": "8ba75e38615f1bcf10a2263959b8900f16119127e017319f0e1578c4a1330374",
      "n": 5,
      "outcomes": {
        "alice executes after re-verification": "ALLOW",
        "alice executes again (contained)": "AGENT_CONTAINED",
        "alice executes on probation (refused)": "REVERIFICATION_REQUIRED",
        "bob via contained ancestor": "ANCESTOR_AUTHORITY_CONTAINED",
        "delegate alice->bob": "OK",
        "execute alice": "ALLOW",
        "execute bob (honest)": "ALLOW",
        "grant alice": "OK",
        "memory adopt": "OK",
        "memory adopt (conflict -> refused)": "MEMORY_CONFLICT",
        "memory observe": "OK",
        "memory supersede attacker record (quorum)": "OK",
        "memory verify": "MEMORY_CONFLICT_RECORDED",
        "memory write bob 'DE00 1234'": "OK",
        "memory write bob 'DE99 ATTACKER'": "OK",
        "observe alice: params mutated": "EFFECT_MISMATCH",
        "observe bob": "OBSERVED",
        "oracle raises alice trust (refused)": "TRUST_INCREASE_WHILE_CONTAINED",
        "oracle re-verifies alice": "OK",
        "release agent alice (quorum)": "OK",
        "release alice (1 governor, refused)": "GOVERNANCE_QUORUM_MISSING",
        "release authority (quorum)": "OK",
        "report bob (truthful)": "REPORTED"
      },
      "quorum": 4,
      "replicas_identical_state_root_history": true,
      "transitions": 36
    },
    {
      "all_certified": true,
      "f": 2,
      "final_state_root": "290581db78fe7cbb543680160a9dc9106c890434bab61f1bd77aab643ae1c162",
      "n": 7,
      "outcomes": {
        "alice executes after re-verification": "ALLOW",
        "alice executes again (contained)": "AGENT_CONTAINED",
        "alice executes on probation (refused)": "REVERIFICATION_REQUIRED",
        "bob via contained ancestor": "ANCESTOR_AUTHORITY_CONTAINED",
        "delegate alice->bob": "OK",
        "execute alice": "ALLOW",
        "execute bob (honest)": "ALLOW",
        "grant alice": "OK",
        "memory adopt": "OK",
        "memory adopt (conflict -> refused)": "MEMORY_CONFLICT",
        "memory observe": "OK",
        "memory supersede attacker record (quorum)": "OK",
        "memory verify": "MEMORY_CONFLICT_RECORDED",
        "memory write bob 'DE00 1234'": "OK",
        "memory write bob 'DE99 ATTACKER'": "OK",
        "observe alice: params mutated": "EFFECT_MISMATCH",
        "observe bob": "OBSERVED",
        "oracle raises alice trust (refused)": "TRUST_INCREASE_WHILE_CONTAINED",
        "oracle re-verifies alice": "OK",
        "release agent alice (quorum)": "OK",
        "release alice (1 governor, refused)": "GOVERNANCE_QUORUM_MISSING",
        "release authority (quorum)": "OK",
        "report bob (truthful)": "REPORTED"
      },
      "quorum": 5,
      "replicas_identical_state_root_history": true,
      "transitions": 36
    }
  ],
  "cleanroom_checks": 27,
  "cleanroom_verdict": {
    "certified": [
      {
        "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
        "reason": "EFFECT_MISMATCH",
        "seq": 18,
        "signers": [
          "n1",
          "n2",
          "n3",
          "n4"
        ],
        "state_root": "1f2adf29e654c16b7c01f24a40611393aab75df207235a407d3237c238bfb4fb",
        "transition_hash": "c1c311512098d7fdaa3bd0f14653d521e2b88878b98c2f27912652624651c112"
      },
      {
        "outcome": "REJECTED",
        "reason": "MEMORY_CONFLICT",
        "seq": 28,
        "signers": [
          "n1",
          "n2",
          "n3",
          "n4"
        ],
        "state_root": "8f1abc0629a68e413b348da18078f0ec7845f2a7d69d1ec4f4fc54cda7e0e90e",
        "transition_hash": "713847b923a0a750f1570645d679f7af393f5b7467ef2044b2cdcc56681fd2e0"
      },
      {
        "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
        "reason": "OK",
        "seq": 30,
        "signers": [
          "n1",
          "n2",
          "n3",
          "n4"
        ],
        "state_root": "b3788becced8e1124b42f18513c3b57053cf0c115c4b73554eefbfc41754993a",
        "transition_hash": "8b4f424d60940bbf3ca7a901eecf35aac3b68f0b4fc3aa82c7b2f4067c0410fc"
      },
      {
        "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
        "reason": "OK",
        "seq": 32,
        "signers": [
          "n1",
          "n2",
          "n3",
          "n4"
        ],
        "state_root": "2e867b2a29018b05207c783c4112f77c06a93c88476158d8910392880b64970e",
        "transition_hash": "80b622cd08d9511ac7eb8eeaebd66e0bf33826fda6b755b7a0d629ee8b9ecaaf"
      },
      {
        "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
        "reason": "ALLOW",
        "seq": 36,
        "signers": [
          "n1",
          "n2",
          "n3",
          "n4"
        ],
        "state_root": "b049097eadc6b5a9e05d84a0c2e0bd9a68cf8b9c69cc8d1e9179c5158a51ba9a",
        "transition_hash": "44f0749387c85f62c1b6e34afb08120eab8fe41bfb29939872a081995512ee73"
      }
    ],
    "exit": 0,
    "verdict": "VERIFIED"
  },
  "scenario_n4": [
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 1,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "2b42f62aeedb1a330e4d35349813eb5cdeb533fe32a44d80fd0f58e0eabbc861",
      "step": "bootstrap:REGISTER_PRINCIPAL"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 2,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "468701487f1a25c24af074557870e41fc183ede6f549b77350909cd73cc09f5f",
      "step": "bootstrap:REGISTER_PRINCIPAL"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 3,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "3f75ff4f42abc3d4ffba996c7ce24d2770095af4a4e62f989370f66f7051451c",
      "step": "bootstrap:REGISTER_AGENT"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 4,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "99a537e01932b33c3db1f6c83ea2cbd8ec80e1c00c9057ccfee91108a67fbc94",
      "step": "bootstrap:REGISTER_AGENT"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 5,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "8d204502ce95a1225a6347c22aedbd36d98966d113a883a88da824bbc7b87d98",
      "step": "bootstrap:REGISTER_AGENT"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 6,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "de005af768a35ec0d3ef17e8f24340989065ad58a5286109c07beb51c86fd007",
      "step": "bootstrap:TRUST"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 7,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "80b089fe52dfab2405621ac53f75b8036c0d768c85b2cfa4cabaa033d35bbed4",
      "step": "bootstrap:RISK"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 8,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "b23382bf4b5e27ef6597fa194e9b31a46dd546cc14c26ded65b18e4630d10e14",
      "step": "bootstrap:TRUST"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 9,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "36b82b0e03efb15af046008fe2b868c4328a99364a2c0c7289d9ef8afc45d2a1",
      "step": "bootstrap:RISK"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 10,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "a7c5066566764e8b82b7da9c82479cb22a21a8ffa5906c7d8c390727085fb3fa",
      "step": "bootstrap:TRUST"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 11,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "b2829eee400227c5e8d87bfb7ad531e8cd3aa24945df6fee09e5228f5fd3e8ac",
      "step": "bootstrap:RISK"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 12,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "4287ab25a97c520c6ba3ef0eb49c5aa2698c2ab47c2ca4c61b7e4f05ece02828",
      "step": "grant alice"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 13,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "2b9f9a3bae80103970c5c1108035a6e8023adaaceb844bcb09d8d4dba16da613",
      "step": "delegate alice->bob"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "ALLOW",
      "seq": 14,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "56592e66a7e436f082e160b61b596704b5c84794729aa6d7a4749c912c64c7bd",
      "step": "execute bob (honest)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OBSERVED",
      "seq": 15,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "f1ee9fce504039209ccce9e57b2d400f4c2aa45cf83a63acdcac89ed457a8d83",
      "step": "observe bob"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "REPORTED",
      "seq": 16,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "d36903c509778c0c20f0427ea5df288fcab0725eaefd966c6f88f58a35d94ff7",
      "step": "report bob (truthful)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "ALLOW",
      "seq": 17,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "4daa07c4f5a61f11c898ccd35c84e0fc610d37ff639fd657e3ee13ff796e257c",
      "step": "execute alice"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "EFFECT_MISMATCH",
      "seq": 18,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "1f2adf29e654c16b7c01f24a40611393aab75df207235a407d3237c238bfb4fb",
      "step": "observe alice: params mutated"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "REJECTED",
      "reason": "AGENT_CONTAINED",
      "seq": 19,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "565973800df726b2a7bcbab976e2edaace25e2c8ef2c0cca23f4d61819a5f3ed",
      "step": "alice executes again (contained)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "REJECTED",
      "reason": "ANCESTOR_AUTHORITY_CONTAINED",
      "seq": 20,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "64e7f5a6c98d7834f449526e4a575085d6bfc19302bc886348e34738e929f5da",
      "step": "bob via contained ancestor"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "REJECTED",
      "reason": "TRUST_INCREASE_WHILE_CONTAINED",
      "seq": 21,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "d02871d582a8584d967bb60d7cea5229c129a2bfaa7bbaffe52f2c26623e0b13",
      "step": "oracle raises alice trust (refused)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 22,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "71f47a67a53ef4ec68efaa97374bf65cb61aa6a7d9077f7d31974443258f8395",
      "step": "memory write bob 'DE00 1234'"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 23,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "545cfd1cc0169dddbdba0e36240a3db31332c6bc47973725d759e383d8988220",
      "step": "memory write bob 'DE99 ATTACKER'"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 24,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "67499cfb3cdd5f726578a075200194a4f57666330ad31c8d2bf53ab19db54bb0",
      "step": "memory observe"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 25,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "de88c82e41f4f7cb8b089706c827f66e146594e151a99fc6535aec266068d2bf",
      "step": "memory verify"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 26,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "2def3e6c1fb6849fcff46b49c17f1e80069cf66bf7d836be6f7aa09e54a298f6",
      "step": "memory observe"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "MEMORY_CONFLICT_RECORDED",
      "seq": 27,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "e3890e3e2ecdddad96a8a124f1f44585e3d4f68d0386f18e3deae7335ed2daad",
      "step": "memory verify"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "REJECTED",
      "reason": "MEMORY_CONFLICT",
      "seq": 28,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "8f1abc0629a68e413b348da18078f0ec7845f2a7d69d1ec4f4fc54cda7e0e90e",
      "step": "memory adopt (conflict -> refused)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 29,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "147e12c7f5d3884c5c9b0af2324bcdef053eb919801c8b1226468ccc7250a559",
      "step": "memory supersede attacker record (quorum)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 30,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "b3788becced8e1124b42f18513c3b57053cf0c115c4b73554eefbfc41754993a",
      "step": "memory adopt"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "REJECTED",
      "reason": "GOVERNANCE_QUORUM_MISSING",
      "seq": 31,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "a2ed557cff572ea844f9d1ebc24bf89dab81b4100cf855a96275ada0d6e23289",
      "step": "release alice (1 governor, refused)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 32,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "2e867b2a29018b05207c783c4112f77c06a93c88476158d8910392880b64970e",
      "step": "release agent alice (quorum)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 33,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "a93b95e30d4cd5768c05c86132a34942b0aab6d0ea3c600d0a3299bf6eb7af1f",
      "step": "release authority (quorum)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "REJECTED",
      "reason": "REVERIFICATION_REQUIRED",
      "seq": 34,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "ee7264f3351817b479f9c59e2649a1d3176eee6399f4544ac3c179e3c4efd901",
      "step": "alice executes on probation (refused)"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "OK",
      "seq": 35,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "2095b26ffa34cfa29c2d583d41f7bc50c2f794ce4832a443f8f6ec1285a67c28",
      "step": "oracle re-verifies alice"
    },
    {
      "certified": true,
      "outcome": "ACCEPTED",
      "reason": "ALLOW",
      "seq": 36,
      "signers": [
        "n1",
        "n2",
        "n3",
        "n4"
      ],
      "state_root": "b049097eadc6b5a9e05d84a0c2e0bd9a68cf8b9c69cc8d1e9179c5158a51ba9a",
      "step": "alice executes after re-verification"
    }
  ],
  "schema": "cain.acp.e03.results.v1",
  "scope": "real ACP + production PBFT engine code, one process, one host, in-process network",
  "tamper_all_pass": true,
  "tamper_suite": {
    "Byzantine replica equivocates (honest quorum remains): still VERIFIED, equivocator excluded": {
      "expected": "VERIFIED",
      "failed_checks": [],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "VERIFIED"
    },
    "dimension proof moved to another slot": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].dimension[risk]"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "dimension proof value altered (trust inflated)": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].snapshot_recomputes_root",
        "state[4].dimension[trust]"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "evidence log: historical state root swapped": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "evidence_log.head_chain_and_transition_binding",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_18",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_28",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_30",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_32"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "evidence log: transition body rewritten (hide the param mutation)": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "evidence_log.head_chain_and_transition_binding",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_18",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_28",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_30",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_32"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "f Byzantine replicas certify a forged next state": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[5].quorum"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "fork: same seq, different root (needs every key; detected as fork)": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[5].no_fork",
        "state[5].monotonic_seq",
        "evidence_log.contains_certified_seq_36"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "receipt signature corrupted below quorum": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].quorum"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "receipts dropped below quorum": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].quorum"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "rollback: older certified state presented after newer": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[1].monotonic_seq",
        "state[2].monotonic_seq",
        "state[3].monotonic_seq",
        "state[4].monotonic_seq"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "snapshot altered (contain flag removed)": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].snapshot_recomputes_root"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "snapshot gains an uncommitted field": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].snapshot_recomputes_root"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "unpinned replica key substituted": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "state[4].quorum"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    },
    "weakened quorum declared (q below intersection bound)": {
      "expected": "FAILED",
      "failed_checks": [
        "quorum_intersection"
      ],
      "pass": true,
      "verdict": "FAILED"
    }
  }
}