# CAIN-A75-057 Commerce Refusal Review

**Verdict:** VERIFIED

> Replays an agent's commerce decision log against its mandate and checks every refusal: look-alike merchant, over-limit amount, velocity, budget, currency, agent and revocation must be DENY with the right reason, and no refused payment may settle.

| # | Verdict | Requests | Allowed | Denied | Spent (minor units) | Budget left | Denial reasons | Failed checks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | SOUND | 10 | 3 | 7 | 35000 | 15000 | over_budget 1, over_per_transaction_limit 1, revoked 1, unknown_merchant 1, velocity_exceeded 1, wrong_agent 1, wrong_currency 1 |  |

## What this proves and what it does not
- Proves: the mandate names a human principal and one agent with consistent limits; every decision cites the mandate's digest; each recorded decision and denial reason equals the one recomputed in time order against merchant set, per-payment ceiling, velocity, budget, lifetime and revocation; only allowed payments settled; and the published totals match.
- Does not prove: that the log lists every payment the agent attempted, that the merchant names were verified by a payment network, or that money moved as recorded. It is a decision-log replay.
- Verify offline: `python3 verify_offline.py run.json --pinned-key 2CHOFuo5wcqrHMvIQHTsHuzduhtU7GnEeT4T7Kis1So=`
