# How to independently verify the CAIN 41 Universal Agent Proof

This bundle contains one real, signed `UniversalAgentProof`
(`universal-proof-b0f6e2a6`) composing two evidence references from two
DIFFERENT, independently-chained subsystems: a fresh, live economic
decision minted this session (CAIN 38's economic evidence chain, extended
to 2 entries) and an existing CollectiveDecisionProof from CAIN 40's
organization lifecycle (published in a prior session, unmodified).

## 1. Verify each referenced chain's own cryptographic integrity first

```
python3 cain_37_independent_verifier.py verify-chain cain38_economic_evidence_chain.jsonl
python3 cain_37_independent_verifier.py verify-chain cain40_organization_chain.jsonl
```
Expect `"verdict": "VALID"` both times.

## 2. Verify the composition itself

```python
import json
from cain_41_independent_verifier import verify_universal_proof

proof = json.load(open("cain41_universal_proofs.jsonl"))
chains = {
    "cain38_economic_evidence_chain.jsonl": [json.loads(l) for l in open("cain38_economic_evidence_chain.jsonl")],
    "cain40_organization_chain.jsonl": [json.loads(l) for l in open("cain40_organization_chain.jsonl")],
}
result = verify_universal_proof(proof, chains)
print(result["overall_verdict"])          # VALID
print(result["sub_proofs"])               # both sub-proofs VALID, independently
```

## 3. Negative control -- tamper ONE referenced subsystem, prove the other is unaffected

```python
import copy
tampered = copy.deepcopy(chains)
tampered["cain38_economic_evidence_chain.jsonl"][1]["evidence"]["decision"] = "TAMPERED"
result2 = verify_universal_proof(proof, tampered)
print(result2["overall_verdict"])                                    # INVALID
print([sp["verdict"] for sp in result2["sub_proofs"]])                # ['INVALID', 'VALID'] -- the untouched ORGANIZATION_DECISION sub-proof still verifies
```
This is the mission's own central claim, demonstrated rather than asserted:
**one compromised proof subsystem does not silently invalidate the meaning
of another.**

## What this does and does not prove

- Proves: this exact composition of two real, independent pieces of
  evidence is genuinely signed, and the verifier correctly isolates a
  tamper in one referenced subsystem from another.
- Does NOT prove: that the underlying economic settlement moved real money
  (it did not -- simulated, as in every prior CAIN 38-40 bundle), or that
  this composition pattern has been used for anything beyond this one
  illustrative proof.
