# CAIN CAUSALITY — Architecture

**CAUSALITY = Autonomous Causal Accountability & Responsibility Fabric.**

> NO VERIFIED CAUSALITY → NO VERIFIED ACCOUNTABILITY.
> CORRELATION ≠ CAUSATION; TEMPORAL PRECEDENCE ≠ CAUSALITY; AUTHORITY ≠ CAUSAL RESPONSIBILITY.

CAUSALITY answers WHY a consequential outcome happened and WHO/WHAT contributed — from evidence and distributed
causality, never from wall-clock order or an agent's claim. It adds no new moat and builds no second CAIN.

## Position

```
AGENT → IDENTITY → MISSION → AUTHORITY → HERMES → ORACLE → ARGUS → VIGIL → CRUCIBLE → CAIN DECISION → MCPGATE →
IRONCLAD → REAL EXTERNAL SYSTEM → REALITY → CAUSAL EVENT GRAPH → CAUSAL ATTRIBUTION → COUNTERFACTUAL →
RESPONSIBILITY GRAPH → EPICENTER → CAUSAL ACCOUNTABILITY CERTIFICATE → CLEAN-ROOM VERIFICATION → EVIDENCE
```

## Six responsibility categories (never auto-collapsed)
CAUSAL (who contributed) · AUTHORITY (who held authority) · OPERATIONAL (who operated) · CONTROL (who controlled
policy/runtime) · OBSERVATIONAL (who could observe) · REMEDIATION (who can correct).

## Collision matrix (reused, not duplicated)

| Existing | Where | CAUSALITY difference |
|---|---|---|
| IRONCLAD CausalEffectGraph | `cain/ironclad/causal.py` | single-effect WHY/WHO stage chain; CAUSALITY is a multi-event multi-actor typed graph |
| REALITY CausalEffectReconciliationEngine | `cain/reality/causal.py` | one transition; CAUSALITY adds distributed vector-clock ordering + contribution |
| ORACLE evidence independence | `cain/oracle/independence.py` | CAUSALITY composes it for causal evidence (consensus ≠ independence) |
| govmission / EPICENTER | `cain/govmission`, `cain/epicenter` | they answer WHETHER; CAUSALITY answers WHY and WHO |
| ATLAS / DYNASTY | various | CAUSALITY adds collusion/laundering attribution and responsibility categories |

## Modules (`cain/causality/`)
`objects` · `graph` · `order` · `contribution` · `counterfactual` · `multiagent` · `responsibility` · `evidence` ·
`certificate` · `adapters` · `chaos` · `lab` · `properties15` · `hosted_stages`. Clean-room verifier:
`cain-causality-verify`. Real adapters: `NTFY_TOPIC` (ntfy.sh), `PASTE_RS` (paste.rs).

## Status
See `CAUSALITY_PUBLIC_TRUTH.md`. Real two-system experiment executed; same-project tests only; responsibility is
descriptive, not legal; no third-party validation.
