{
 "certificate": {
  "body": {
   "actor_set": [
    "agent:ops-1",
    "human:root"
   ],
   "authority_digest": "auth-1",
   "causal_contributors": [
    "eA",
    "eB"
   ],
   "causal_graph_digest": "db38282e964e520912eaf5bee8d653f48b9917e85b120d88b242abc9834ad4ec",
   "causality_state": "VERIFIED_CAUSALITY",
   "certificate_id": "caus-5636e0a6",
   "certificate_version": "1",
   "confidence_state": "SUPPORTED",
   "contradiction_set": [],
   "counterfactual_digest": "3781404230a9a3447dd28a5a19e36ed99ca5e7de01c302da5f274250e5c698e4",
   "effect_digest": "k8s:cain-causality:cc-25b8bfebf775",
   "evidence_fresh": true,
   "evidence_manifest_digest": "18f2375284bc6225aaa3467c2ce0bbd13c2aae1eea1846a9ab23ed2b42884bd0",
   "excluded_contributors": [
    "eX"
   ],
   "independent_contributors": [
    "observer-a",
    "observer-b"
   ],
   "mission_id": "causality-mission-1",
   "nonce": "caus-f3fdd47d",
   "observer_digest": "c340c32a0e33e607e31c29cc1afd0b4b2a41ca1fe74c5566992d28e1e9e2cd26",
   "responsibility_graph_digest": "433e9062c292e2e452a45fb7ed16530b7692d9a60920a7e3a0941db44b55913a",
   "timestamp": 1791479085.5351927,
   "unresolved_causes": [],
   "valid_until": 1791482685.5351808
  },
  "digest": "c6f709b9c6e72b68731f1fd5b49fcb230beb87048c2cd1a97fb739379f2cb7db",
  "signature": "o0jgkKxGXZrVpFRQ2fuVNKqvxedOF6fWqF3r3hJZlAKreENjzY6owHOVc3ESbs5BRzIrZCeqza4HU3QGwsnDCw==",
  "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
  "version": 1
 },
 "events": [
  {
   "body": {
    "action": "effect_A",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "agent:ops-1",
     "agent_lineage": "ops-1",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "model-x",
     "model_version": "1",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "human:root",
     "runtime_identity": "runtime-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "POSTGRESQL",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "auth-1",
    "causal_parents": [],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "postgres:cain-ctok-cd733636ca7d4ddbbc6676eb9c876370",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eA",
    "event_type": "EFFECT",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "postgresql"
    ],
    "external_system": "postgresql:16",
    "lamport": 1,
    "node_id": "cain",
    "nonce": "eA-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5326533,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   "digest": "5b07831438b78df9372b1cd8582cefa355e51ca1ef9d872f1eb8ae02502ea677",
   "signature": "A1Cekc4RgOF1KeatK15XTSXafppeHgTbDgfVlduBo1n5AH8k46nJ4ts+w08aDWG7wcM9y10bySqfoQGc6dYaCw==",
   "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
   "version": 1
  },
  {
   "body": {
    "action": "effect_B",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "agent:ops-1",
     "agent_lineage": "ops-1",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "model-x",
     "model_version": "1",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "human:root",
     "runtime_identity": "runtime-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "POSTGRESQL",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "auth-1",
    "causal_parents": [
     "eA"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "k8s:cain-causality:cc-25b8bfebf775",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eB",
    "event_type": "EFFECT",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "kubernetes"
    ],
    "external_system": "kubernetes:k3s",
    "lamport": 2,
    "node_id": "cain",
    "nonce": "eB-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5326798,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      2
     ]
    ]
   },
   "digest": "5dda4692e961485e2c963f5eee0f9c8d1cb9d05154aad621d5fe9ca7c6fb6b3d",
   "signature": "bpbLrXWfl3LTCbus1dxfHfPg2fFA1IhW/tm9Sxnmdiy0runTqm8Zr/mP7TeAHN9X8WX24JEVCAJ30CWfrt6QDQ==",
   "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
   "version": 1
  },
  {
   "body": {
    "action": "observe_A",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "observer-a",
     "agent_lineage": "",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "",
     "model_version": "",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "",
     "runtime_identity": "obs-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [
     "eA"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "obs:True",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eC",
    "event_type": "OBSERVATION",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "postgresql"
    ],
    "external_system": "postgresql:16",
    "lamport": 1,
    "node_id": "observer-a",
    "nonce": "eC-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "R3_INDEPENDENTLY_QUERIED_EXTERNAL_STATE",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.532696,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      1
     ],
     [
      "observer-a",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   "digest": "5ca5f1a2e6d74777f16bdb66688fcba52978df845e6218cd8213ea2e844d7c42",
   "signature": "eqI5MHdxS19accNOrx5eq7C/o/c101lY3N8xbTsNji4jTUlbMTtIzV8G0xX77HtIIpuUwcFTuutNxB2lNXSpBQ==",
   "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
   "version": 1
  },
  {
   "body": {
    "action": "observe_B",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "observer-b",
     "agent_lineage": "",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "",
     "model_version": "",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "",
     "runtime_identity": "obs-2",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [
     "eB"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "obs:True",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eD",
    "event_type": "OBSERVATION",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "kubernetes"
    ],
    "external_system": "kubernetes:k3s",
    "lamport": 2,
    "node_id": "observer-b",
    "nonce": "eD-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "R3_INDEPENDENTLY_QUERIED_EXTERNAL_STATE",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5327034,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      2
     ],
     [
      "observer-b",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   "digest": "d5518254e6356c46c44d255fad4f9f1ab828f5741677d28e1f708cd12bce1f5e",
   "signature": "HXQ7rRKDBbDme68V2bTpKilUChwjx5vFFEKPNbDU4Qdy038yCbN4IObPWJUaDBlGSLywmMQeEfLldB26Ob8PAg==",
   "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
   "version": 1
  },
  {
   "body": {
    "action": "unrelated_publish",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "agent:ops-1",
     "agent_lineage": "ops-1",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "model-x",
     "model_version": "1",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "human:root",
     "runtime_identity": "runtime-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "POSTGRESQL",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "unrelated",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eX",
    "event_type": "EXECUTION",
    "evidence_roots": [],
    "external_system": "postgresql:16",
    "lamport": 5,
    "node_id": "cain",
    "nonce": "eX-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5327172,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      5
     ]
    ]
   },
   "digest": "9a8da61315d72dc259681d22e3cce0ed1b00107b9a9dacd3e3bb760f9f940ff0",
   "signature": "ox73m7BWOsJ7Scme3wWUe3cUYIacm/NEb8Rn7kn4TFuE2Zz0NfXPmIr4gE2EWtn8S/Ai3YBqHom0aM8YbycoBg==",
   "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
   "version": 1
  },
  {
   "body": {
    "action": "other",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "other-node",
     "agent_lineage": "",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "",
     "model_version": "",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "",
     "runtime_identity": "",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "other",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eY",
    "event_type": "EXECUTION",
    "evidence_roots": [],
    "external_system": "other",
    "lamport": 1,
    "node_id": "other-node",
    "nonce": "eY-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5327258,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "other-node",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   "digest": "b27cd3b1e53d7130bdaf02154ab9a3b6b82efcff574bd2e2ceda86e22af2cb60",
   "signature": "5iYUn0puvWPfKTC12tTllVVN2n9pRq75xHcDnvByr2pNy3AUeQ8zbDqw/6yJVJqxpGdlL9crk87fnZdDRPXdCQ==",
   "signer_pub": "7laEqeJLw6cs0bWtrB3SzrOmxVw7+scQvF8T+vwjI+4=",
   "version": 1
  }
 ],
 "graph": {
  "edges": [
   [
    "eA",
    "eB",
    "effect"
   ],
   [
    "eA",
    "eC",
    "observation"
   ],
   [
    "eB",
    "eD",
    "observation"
   ]
  ],
  "nodes": [
   {
    "action": "effect_A",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "agent:ops-1",
     "agent_lineage": "ops-1",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "model-x",
     "model_version": "1",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "human:root",
     "runtime_identity": "runtime-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "POSTGRESQL",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "auth-1",
    "causal_parents": [],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "postgres:cain-ctok-cd733636ca7d4ddbbc6676eb9c876370",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eA",
    "event_type": "EFFECT",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "postgresql"
    ],
    "external_system": "postgresql:16",
    "lamport": 1,
    "node_id": "cain",
    "nonce": "eA-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5326533,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   {
    "action": "effect_B",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "agent:ops-1",
     "agent_lineage": "ops-1",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "model-x",
     "model_version": "1",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "human:root",
     "runtime_identity": "runtime-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "POSTGRESQL",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "auth-1",
    "causal_parents": [
     "eA"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "k8s:cain-causality:cc-25b8bfebf775",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eB",
    "event_type": "EFFECT",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "kubernetes"
    ],
    "external_system": "kubernetes:k3s",
    "lamport": 2,
    "node_id": "cain",
    "nonce": "eB-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5326798,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      2
     ]
    ]
   },
   {
    "action": "observe_A",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "observer-a",
     "agent_lineage": "",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "",
     "model_version": "",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "",
     "runtime_identity": "obs-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [
     "eA"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "obs:True",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eC",
    "event_type": "OBSERVATION",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "postgresql"
    ],
    "external_system": "postgresql:16",
    "lamport": 1,
    "node_id": "observer-a",
    "nonce": "eC-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "R3_INDEPENDENTLY_QUERIED_EXTERNAL_STATE",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.532696,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      1
     ],
     [
      "observer-a",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   {
    "action": "observe_B",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "observer-b",
     "agent_lineage": "",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "",
     "model_version": "",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "",
     "runtime_identity": "obs-2",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [
     "eB"
    ],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "obs:True",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eD",
    "event_type": "OBSERVATION",
    "evidence_roots": [
     "kubernetes"
    ],
    "external_system": "kubernetes:k3s",
    "lamport": 2,
    "node_id": "observer-b",
    "nonce": "eD-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "R3_INDEPENDENTLY_QUERIED_EXTERNAL_STATE",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5327034,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      2
     ],
     [
      "observer-b",
      1
     ]
    ]
   },
   {
    "action": "unrelated_publish",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "agent:ops-1",
     "agent_lineage": "ops-1",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "model-x",
     "model_version": "1",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "human:root",
     "runtime_identity": "runtime-1",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "POSTGRESQL",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "unrelated",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eX",
    "event_type": "EXECUTION",
    "evidence_roots": [],
    "external_system": "postgresql:16",
    "lamport": 5,
    "node_id": "cain",
    "nonce": "eX-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5327172,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "cain",
      5
     ]
    ]
   },
   {
    "action": "other",
    "actor": {
     "agent_identity": "other-node",
     "agent_lineage": "",
     "human_operator": "",
     "memory_version": "",
     "model_identity": "",
     "model_version": "",
     "organization": "",
     "principal": "",
     "runtime_identity": "",
     "skill_identity": "",
     "tool_identity": "",
     "world_model_version": ""
    },
    "authority_version": "",
    "causal_parents": [],
    "confidence": 0.5,
    "effect_fingerprint": "other",
    "environment_identity": "",
    "event_id": "eY",
    "event_type": "EXECUTION",
    "evidence_roots": [],
    "external_system": "other",
    "lamport": 1,
    "node_id": "other-node",
    "nonce": "eY-1",
    "policy_version": "",
    "source_trust": "UNKNOWN",
    "timestamp": 1791479085.5327258,
    "vector_clock": [
     [
      "other-node",
      1
     ]
    ]
   }
  ],
  "schema": "CAIN42/CAUSALITY-CAUSAL-GRAPH/v1"
 },
 "responsibility": {
  "by_category": {
   "AUTHORITY": [
    "human:root"
   ],
   "CAUSAL": [
    "agent:ops-1",
    "action:A",
    "action:B"
   ],
   "CONTROL": [
    "cain-operator"
   ],
   "OBSERVATIONAL": [
    "observer-a",
    "observer-b"
   ],
   "OPERATIONAL": [
    "agent:ops-1"
   ],
   "REMEDIATION": [
    "cain-operator"
   ]
  },
  "categories_collapsed": false,
  "entries": [
   {
    "actor": "agent:ops-1",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "analysis",
    "category": "CAUSAL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "action:A",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "analysis",
    "category": "CAUSAL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "action:B",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "analysis",
    "category": "CAUSAL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "human:root",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "authority_state",
    "category": "AUTHORITY",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "agent:ops-1",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "execution",
    "category": "OPERATIONAL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "cain-operator",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "policy_runtime",
    "category": "CONTROL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "observer-a",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "observer",
    "category": "OBSERVATIONAL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "observer-b",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "observer",
    "category": "OBSERVATIONAL",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   },
   {
    "actor": "cain-operator",
    "authority_version": "",
    "basis": "remediation_authority",
    "category": "REMEDIATION",
    "independent_evidence": 0
   }
  ],
  "schema": "CAIN42/CAUSALITY-RESPONSIBILITY-GRAPH/v1"
 }
}