# CAIN CAUSALITY — IP Register

> Each entry is a **potential invention-disclosure candidate**, not a legal conclusion. No patent filed; no prior-art
> search performed. Overlaps with IRONCLAD, REALITY, EPICENTER, ORACLE, ARGUS/VIGIL/HERMES/CRUCIBLE, ATLAS/DYNASTY and
> CONTINUUM are excluded to avoid double counting.

| ID | Mechanism | Tier | Code | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-01 | DistributedCausalOrderEngine: vector-clock causality with typed declared edges (CAUSES requires evidence, not a timestamp) | NOVEL | `order.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-02 | CausalContributionEngine: evidence-backed contribution classes without arbitrary percentages | NOVEL | `contribution.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-03 | CounterfactualCausalityEngine with real negative controls; COUNTERFACTUAL_UNKNOWN never TRUE | NOVEL | `counterfactual.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-04 | ResponsibilityGraph: six non-collapsing responsibility categories | NOVEL | `responsibility.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-05 | MultiAgentCausalAttributionEngine: collusion/authority/responsibility/delegation laundering detection | NOVEL | `multiagent.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-06 | CausalAccountabilityCertificate + clean-room recomputation (NO VERIFIED CAUSALITY → NO VERIFIED ACCOUNTABILITY) | NOVEL | `certificate.py`, `cain-causality-verify/` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-07 | CausalEvent 32-dimension actor/authority/model/runtime binding | UNUSUAL | `objects.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-08 | CausalGraph typed edges + cycle detection | UNUSUAL | `graph.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-09 | CausalEvidenceIndependenceGraph (consensus ≠ independence) | UNUSUAL | `evidence.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-10 | Causal Adapter SDK with two REAL adapters (ntfy.sh, paste.rs) | UNUSUAL | `adapters.py` | `artifacts/causality/CAUSALITY_EXPERIMENT.json` |
| CA-11 | Deterministic causality-state policy (CORRELATED_ONLY never promoted) | UNUSUAL | `certificate.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-12 | CAUSALITY live enforcement: 3 restriction-only stages installed by default (`default_stages_v22`) | INTEGRATION | `hosted_stages.py`, `cain/continuum/hosted_pipeline.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-13 | REAL two-system causal experiment (caused vs before vs correlated + negative control + clean-room) | INTEGRATION | `scripts/cain42_evolution/causality_experiment.py` | `artifacts/causality/CAUSALITY_EXPERIMENT.json` |
| CA-14 | CAUSALITY lab: 32 categories + 26 mutations + P271–P300 (false-verified-causality = 0) | ENGINEERING | `lab.py`, `properties15.py` | `tests/test_causality.py` |
| CA-15 | Causality chaos (21 faults) + per-op benchmark + hashed manifest | ENGINEERING | `chaos.py`, `bench_causality.py` | `artifacts/causality/` |

## Value contribution
See `artifacts/valuation/CAIN_CAUSALITY_IP_VALUE_RECALC.md` and `scripts/ip/recalculate_ip_value_v23.py`.

**Internal analytical scenario, NOT an appraisal.** No patent; two real external systems demonstrated; responsibility
is descriptive, not legal; physical SIMULATED; no third-party validation.
