# CAIN CAUSALITY — Production Readiness

| Capability | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Causal event model + graph | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `objects.py`, `graph.py` |
| Distributed causal ordering | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `order.py` |
| Contribution + counterfactual engines | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `contribution.py`, `counterfactual.py` |
| Multi-agent attribution + laundering detection | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `multiagent.py` |
| Responsibility graph (6 categories) | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `responsibility.py` |
| Causal evidence independence | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `evidence.py` |
| Causal Accountability Certificate | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `certificate.py` |
| Causal Adapter SDK (2 real adapters) | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `adapters.py` |
| 3 hosted stages | **LIVE (RESTRICTION_ONLY)** — installed by default via `default_stages_v22` | `hosted_stages.py` |
| Clean-room verifier | IMPLEMENTED, TESTED | `cain-causality-verify/verify.py` |
| **Real two-system causal experiment** | **EXECUTED (ntfy.sh + paste.rs)** | `artifacts/causality/CAUSALITY_EXPERIMENT.json` |
| Legal/insurance liability determination | **NOT IMPLEMENTED (out of scope)** | none |
| Third-party validation | **NOT IMPLEMENTED** | none |

## Known limitations / blockers
1. Two real external systems demonstrated; no DB/K8s/cloud causal adapter wired to live production yet.
2. Responsibility categories are descriptive, not legal.
3. Hosted causality stages are restriction-only and read caller-supplied certificate/state payloads.
4. No third-party audit; same-project tests only.

## Enforcement gate (derived)
Promotion to ENFORCED requires: `REAL_EXTERNAL_TWO_SYSTEM_EXPERIMENT + CLEAN_ROOM_VERIFICATION +
FALSE_VERIFIED_CAUSALITY==0 + NO_UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION + VALID_AUTHORITY + VALID_EFFECT + REPRODUCIBLE_ARTIFACTS +
PRODUCTION_SOAK + THIRD_PARTY_REVIEW`. Current: see `artifacts/causality/ENFORCEMENT_READINESS.json` — **NOT PROMOTED**
(RESTRICTION_ONLY).

## Deployment stages
OFF → OBSERVE → SHADOW → RESTRICTION_ONLY (current, installed by default) → ENFORCED. Selected by
`CAIN_HOSTED_PIPELINE_VERSION` (default `22`); 17–21 remain for rollback. No silent enforcement.
