{
  "bundle_sha256": "78a2966f4ed70060a3a49470c305326c0dc2dac3d11d337e14ab680ae9f91bca",
  "finished_at": "2026-09-21T18:10:35Z",
  "meta": {
    "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
    "cluster_started": true,
    "disposable": true,
    "image": "cain-cluster-node:cain35-digest-fix-20260917",
    "image_ids": [
      "sha256:701bdf10cfbc3322f7799f9636e2268a6c14e25174b80383401b1686a176046b"
    ],
    "independence_measured": {
      "distinct_hosts": 1,
      "distinct_images": 1,
      "host": "vultr",
      "verdict": "NOT independent failure domains: one image, one host, one Docker daemon"
    },
    "teardown_containers_left": []
  },
  "not_claimed": [
    "independent failure domains (one host, one image, one Docker daemon)",
    "network partitions",
    "a malicious (equivocating) validator on the live wire",
    "long-duration behaviour",
    "the LIVE local test cluster was not fault-injected (only a disposable twin was)",
    "the older remote cluster-cain-001 (quorum 2, no PBFT endpoints) is NOT covered and does not meet the 2f+1 rule",
    "no third party has reviewed this"
  ],
  "schema": "cain42.cluster_fault_test_bundle.v1",
  "started_at": "2026-09-21T18:05:48Z",
  "status": "PRE-PRODUCTION",
  "steps": [
    {
      "distinct_keys": 4,
      "name": "S0 baseline: 4/4 up",
      "pinned_keys": {
        "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
        "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
        "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
        "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
      },
      "state_proofs": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 0,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.098113+00:00",
          "sequence": 0,
          "signature_b64": "F077p8xYkP6NV+wUQK4OjAfdymRdiwFashzWTRkxaGms8uyd606gT4IIliMn4P4QXSFu89YHWVRd4PKgRbJGAQ==",
          "state_root": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 0,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.120501+00:00",
          "sequence": 0,
          "signature_b64": "clXaB6y/BOCIsSttIim/+KjzWPC3j6Urfj9d/Qz+DSpteCXvNHqG3r2xkgpDPgwo9Q7vzD9TQr90f4PGalJzAQ==",
          "state_root": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 0,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-3",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.143468+00:00",
          "sequence": 0,
          "signature_b64": "D9Relxvvi61ACHwktUzGuK7L54QOK81pV6qaGZtnWRp2sb/4/5LMKBY0wtcQHNiuuZoGiQu2I4X7O7ivx+8dBQ==",
          "state_root": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 0,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-4",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.164941+00:00",
          "sequence": 0,
          "signature_b64": "26C9lSFo6xalpXrkyRbeC18U1XmVdwH0pApUnyQo1kzbMrBRx80W1z9OXGX98dwYjH4cy3nVnELaCcKvWPfcDA==",
          "state_root": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d",
          "view": 0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "S1 commit with all 4 nodes",
      "quorum_certificates": [
        {
          "claimed_accepted_signers": 4,
          "pinned_keys": {
            "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
            "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
            "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
            "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
          },
          "qc": {
            "accepted_signers": [
              "cain-evid-node-1",
              "cain-evid-node-2",
              "cain-evid-node-3",
              "cain-evid-node-4"
            ],
            "authority_epoch": 1,
            "certificate_digest": "7e97fdd76b74ff9f164b5f585dbd2a4d7b3aad7a996d44ea17cf5979326fb832",
            "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
            "created_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.719169+00:00",
            "expires_at": "2026-09-21T18:07:29.719169+00:00",
            "membership_config": {
              "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
              "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
              "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
              "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
            },
            "rejected_signers": [],
            "request_digest": "52cd1566745b45b8f2c1da576c44a616c2869c31fc79f0477b363c3c0246ef54",
            "request_id": "evid-r1",
            "sequence": 1,
            "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
            "view": 0,
            "votes": {
              "cain-evid-node-1": "TNW2T1qqKL1k9I6p6TbXonBH9ev4idFfyU9glGMUI2RtPTV2MDE7xwRh5CYMA/SrqdXJTH/o9KQShpmuD6A2Bw==",
              "cain-evid-node-2": "u+tiX7eiRd0em7J8u75LWyYVMxLSjZuekoecXaLpzKfv/kZ1RXJPFEJ2bIEd0+7FUjYO1EAAj47wJ8FhA6oLCA==",
              "cain-evid-node-3": "om46SVh/vlXuJHsv1P+phKRmoGkhb2Qh0MYrb8uUS+ADZzjoRgWnz3D5nRABRNf58RWC8LZdq4Oy9152L3mYBQ==",
              "cain-evid-node-4": "njzQPQ5/yAJ3VZ9okxqJcmXyIkkR1tG9IrGIlAgKPcc/cuBXPlMDjwlsRLRlwYIfTJ6RK383eYLY3eyMt/KiBQ=="
            }
          },
          "required_quorum": 3
        }
      ],
      "response": {
        "application_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
        "authorization_id": "auth-6d9566edccfd4846",
        "authorization_proof_digest": "8da0ec6867df56f874a0737248b8755b6d86a55ff98e3882d7f7be32375efbc0",
        "cluster_size": 4,
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "enforcement": "PERMIT",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "quorum_certificate_accepted_signers": 4,
        "quorum_certificate_digest": "7e97fdd76b74ff9f164b5f585dbd2a4d7b3aad7a996d44ea17cf5979326fb832",
        "quorum_certificate_status": "VALID",
        "quorum_size": 3,
        "sequence": 1,
        "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
        "status": "COMMITTED",
        "view": 0
      },
      "state_proofs": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 1,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.819266+00:00",
          "sequence": 1,
          "signature_b64": "/GIIoFD9fzM2TLXK4cF/yi5Q0i+EKVhkHrbog1WtzQXV7ptPBzW3wRVPd25h1pnNdJnd1JnKUkMjboWjqbH0DA==",
          "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 1,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.836329+00:00",
          "sequence": 1,
          "signature_b64": "PTas0WmuDK56LxEgfyiMcFYljpe6D2PozJuxlOKgSnHZvZrrDWaavWkXzV+zxhPNC6htT9S5Dp2rbyyw/tlGCg==",
          "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 1,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-3",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.851578+00:00",
          "sequence": 1,
          "signature_b64": "8zJhIR5NmixqUtYyV+8Wa/22LgR3v9WTw/mt3zafHwtiJxKLGBK2QjbcXPUW5Ti7mR2JYxmqyyGbslN6ZhZzAw==",
          "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 1,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-4",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:29.874110+00:00",
          "sequence": 1,
          "signature_b64": "CZktGeKwtr3Hft1SLaefDd2cycOHgZRiMVRKL3w/xQh7zRAltZVUM9zR/9aWGJ7X82dnAm+gbxF3PvNpWD5aBA==",
          "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
          "view": 0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "crashed": [
        "cain-evid-node-4"
      ],
      "name": "S2 CRASH node-4; commit with 3 of 4 (f=1)",
      "quorum_certificates": [
        {
          "claimed_accepted_signers": 3,
          "pinned_keys": {
            "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
            "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
            "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
            "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
          },
          "qc": {
            "accepted_signers": [
              "cain-evid-node-1",
              "cain-evid-node-2",
              "cain-evid-node-3"
            ],
            "authority_epoch": 1,
            "certificate_digest": "31db0f31fd587c3263a7f058369eead0f85c0f88b03ddd7667640c8e6f42dac5",
            "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
            "created_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:31.982376+00:00",
            "expires_at": "2026-09-21T18:07:31.982376+00:00",
            "membership_config": {
              "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
              "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
              "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
              "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
            },
            "rejected_signers": [],
            "request_digest": "5b9bbe5d2537526a4766c26bbfb1a80b97c63dc681f00e3ca5fbd809ae363c9d",
            "request_id": "evid-r2",
            "sequence": 2,
            "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
            "view": 0,
            "votes": {
              "cain-evid-node-1": "QBs7KS3M2czfhgIDopiQKRKL2zPYV7IJIffbOd7EEP5fOOTD6K8ZdMAyoLDscKYeUyqso7tvLRWEx9qfKYljDQ==",
              "cain-evid-node-2": "jZSRwwyq2Uyi7rB3BirJjNp/BldyIEu2zCDCV2lk3VTzpomX2+zLfz14ZPg/Y5lv5kLoitPUE8o/r/T3HzK3DA==",
              "cain-evid-node-3": "+4k8lrAMoLvODrXlA3yXCzG6BIRhM5zl1R22Oi2o9y2h3SBnGFv+GGe8iksSt6PfgYMysbg9V4POrK7Oq7DfAg=="
            }
          },
          "required_quorum": 3
        }
      ],
      "response": {
        "application_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
        "authorization_id": "auth-bc23f259fb704b4c",
        "authorization_proof_digest": "9ac33e24a5ad10b5092e745432a54d98faf762d7f4c1ed77bc3e8ae4df31f386",
        "cluster_size": 4,
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "enforcement": "PERMIT",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "quorum_certificate_accepted_signers": 3,
        "quorum_certificate_digest": "31db0f31fd587c3263a7f058369eead0f85c0f88b03ddd7667640c8e6f42dac5",
        "quorum_certificate_status": "VALID",
        "quorum_size": 3,
        "sequence": 2,
        "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
        "status": "COMMITTED",
        "view": 0
      },
      "state_proofs": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:32.212962+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "fb/Zts/nC76RDo+be/BN9MTmIQ8qTMpATJmcl5kc6Ky2dxmtaSHxY+PaI28PsE2NaNavTc21B10fRylNmziyAA==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:32.245821+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "knelOeD0n62ZOZHZXsawI8/FhRkyUNSEE00UlB5Q+Vg8xwdGuqwcNpNM6sfD/EV43u5CoUO8eb/+zDl7/1+5CQ==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-3",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:06:32.269790+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "EewyRqQ3oqt7scV+VnWzbuilNXzFgapByuVjPNNWGT1tcnp6Mz4PkKdoUah2IO4XclrjHMFKKc7Pr6aq0nTcCA==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "converged": false,
      "name": "S3 RESTART node-4; poll up to 120s for convergence (recorded as observed, not asserted)",
      "restarted_reachable": true,
      "seconds_polled_or_to_converge": 121.4,
      "sequences": {
        "cain-evid-node-1": 2,
        "cain-evid-node-2": 2,
        "cain-evid-node-3": 2,
        "cain-evid-node-4": 1
      },
      "state_proofs": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:41.780034+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "bFQ6JTirJVJ5ZkF4sBFMLWoCIWNP4y0+NrCg/3ZMe5O1O/Kp+ZylFQd6+xGmCF9XTlgnczd+ftkfnemfozgsCg==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:41.797520+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "Vu0TvhZPsMz/ilLKp+q7Cy+/eCxy1NBJ0lR/UrXsWXHu3kjd9J5gLPthKDfkqt0aTtfii0q/IRGp06GxHsKeCA==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-3",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:41.825312+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "A0Ql9uwcW6i6uDf1ClRenAGI9B/7WWQtDxRCf/6bhad1d/Q0M2xdq0FkmmIcYy8bUjbX8xzcZykJ/whye5hbCQ==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 1,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-4",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:41.842663+00:00",
          "sequence": 1,
          "signature_b64": "zZ+liAWDqAL9yU84fJxGZnHGC+6Ev1FZ5Qd2k19SKJiBF56rLDbxdN5MdU1ImjCUQisMw1WrGB9a9NFTzGy4CA==",
          "state_root": "0d4bc66be0c671f2557fd810e7a4dbd0940893a7cb30a510e26cf0da3014c511",
          "view": 0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "committed": false,
      "crashed": [
        "cain-evid-node-3",
        "cain-evid-node-4"
      ],
      "name": "S4 CRASH 2 nodes (beyond f=1); a commit must not succeed",
      "response": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "enforcement": "BLOCK",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "sequence": 3,
        "status": "CONSENSUS_TIMEOUT",
        "view": 0
      },
      "sequence_advanced": true,
      "state_proofs": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:50.725723+00:00",
          "sequence": 3,
          "signature_b64": "a0PSPN37dDqZkrutoF70lXhLkvWp0KkTY7A8pDiX8Hs51xX9a4C66u6OzfRK8zeXgq3P6Dbo9RpZ1er5gtrwBQ==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:50.739076+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "x6tWm/tsxW2b2J2ASrb8dj05Yn1hmRXmu7IunnF5TZ7RLMemiIDSkhYGbRNN4Ev4b09uNxo6kGbI/Jl51JuNCA==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        }
      ],
      "state_proofs_before": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:46.938976+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "xv8RKXrz15+v/vlkiJRomiM+3/HFZcOpgOPrsX4RGgeXfi1fl7kVq/zzSC+R/QkIATCvBeluKSTZRAyabOpKBg==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 2,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:08:46.958416+00:00",
          "sequence": 2,
          "signature_b64": "XnhhqTu0QXNgyDHWD5SMnJeXFrCXj0VwGgStcMXJC4cKrECpgMx/AWDGG9WG1N49jLfcQNnBQxv/rUFFkSd2BQ==",
          "state_root": "d06c58c28701831c5e38f8b89157c3200fd815ec038b02e8ba00178742ebc932",
          "view": 0
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "converged_after_commit": true,
      "converged_before_commit": false,
      "name": "S5 RESTART both; poll convergence, commit again, poll again",
      "quorum_certificates": [
        {
          "claimed_accepted_signers": 4,
          "pinned_keys": {
            "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
            "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
            "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
            "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
          },
          "qc": {
            "accepted_signers": [
              "cain-evid-node-1",
              "cain-evid-node-2",
              "cain-evid-node-3",
              "cain-evid-node-4"
            ],
            "authority_epoch": 1,
            "certificate_digest": "2b469cd9614e7a692784a05e300ba2cf613ebbbcdf2760544bbdef0b103b7de9",
            "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
            "created_at": "2026-09-21T18:10:33.821027+00:00",
            "expires_at": "2026-09-21T18:11:33.821027+00:00",
            "membership_config": {
              "cain-evid-node-1": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
              "cain-evid-node-2": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
              "cain-evid-node-3": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
              "cain-evid-node-4": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0="
            },
            "rejected_signers": [],
            "request_digest": "0b95391cdb0131094241908c06bfe6d7f577e45d7ef9c55e37ea04491c15e6d3",
            "request_id": "evid-r4",
            "sequence": 4,
            "state_root": "e18c57d99ac7f80f13c735bff97d80969751ed38882698acd57ed8f6bc3d1d9a",
            "view": 0,
            "votes": {
              "cain-evid-node-1": "VA7O38SYcrA+4kXTFyGe8NWVWfJruWUDZmwolFXV4LMHVv356novpBrO3q+NWmtGCOAcZ/fSMQ5Xiy0Dl7EBAA==",
              "cain-evid-node-2": "Ipbeu4AxvblVG4btlJwUVsqHCJe0ybngolpAgPNIjocxLoCNd2/AfO6kAtlrjh4vqQ+RDJADtlOUWDNwOYbzDA==",
              "cain-evid-node-3": "ugdsMZJctR8UuZpdZIbAxcNktABznzpqoWfbdsXb2wEqmdHg9PaacfBKxgs1oA9LHW6/1vtyeYV20thXAijDAA==",
              "cain-evid-node-4": "J1q2jr0E+76xmK2RyaM04eGogS/pt3MZq1nuVf27cl+ZsKXVi4A9invj58t/MuMGpA/+yKulD2T81vO9/ZZfBQ=="
            }
          },
          "required_quorum": 3
        }
      ],
      "reachable": true,
      "response_after_recovery": {
        "application_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
        "authorization_id": "auth-47c374cbf5d046ef",
        "authorization_proof_digest": "c0dd4e435b38b983a5cce9c9766d27a7a416da958883d216badacc0716a5d18c",
        "cluster_size": 4,
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "enforcement": "PERMIT",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "quorum_certificate_accepted_signers": 4,
        "quorum_certificate_digest": "2b469cd9614e7a692784a05e300ba2cf613ebbbcdf2760544bbdef0b103b7de9",
        "quorum_certificate_status": "VALID",
        "quorum_size": 3,
        "sequence": 4,
        "state_root": "e18c57d99ac7f80f13c735bff97d80969751ed38882698acd57ed8f6bc3d1d9a",
        "status": "COMMITTED",
        "view": 0
      },
      "seconds_after_commit": 0.1,
      "sequences_after_commit": {
        "cain-evid-node-1": 4,
        "cain-evid-node-2": 4,
        "cain-evid-node-3": 4,
        "cain-evid-node-4": 4
      },
      "sequences_before_commit": {
        "cain-evid-node-1": 3,
        "cain-evid-node-2": 2,
        "cain-evid-node-3": 2,
        "cain-evid-node-4": 1
      },
      "state_proofs": [
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 4,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-1",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "i4YLSh/hvXSMHj5p2u9SreDmD4ch52ib5E27t141eds=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:10:34.103092+00:00",
          "sequence": 4,
          "signature_b64": "2dXNGi1r/FdKT4eWIo+oDXW/fcJsc09k89Wv9JzeGnf88k2C2FW8YQf1iVMEUA/NWBCvuSBzdMpJZHhirsLvBg==",
          "state_root": "e18c57d99ac7f80f13c735bff97d80969751ed38882698acd57ed8f6bc3d1d9a",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 4,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-2",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "J75twxDC22JarVg6k9ZWcPzdOC9pdhq6OiRgQkmhZCA=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:10:34.119202+00:00",
          "sequence": 4,
          "signature_b64": "bx50zcyBjNWolq2/CjID68zufDpYelaU3hgKCaZSVbkCTvrXcmco7dlHX9skj7NyL0jSxv52zkUldNSnX5VPCA==",
          "state_root": "e18c57d99ac7f80f13c735bff97d80969751ed38882698acd57ed8f6bc3d1d9a",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 4,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-3",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "M6B8FVMFVCt2zXIxjjoDYjBvePGzPjzNl/DADNqF5VE=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:10:34.135922+00:00",
          "sequence": 4,
          "signature_b64": "TBeqniqvVkIRlqqOLjczsgIS5n5bdCJYYGdhUYqO4vT5/AmfIEucDkuY+dtNkwRUBbS3L59Ccy47LLWwnhFOAw==",
          "state_root": "e18c57d99ac7f80f13c735bff97d80969751ed38882698acd57ed8f6bc3d1d9a",
          "view": 0
        },
        {
          "application_state_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "cluster_id": "cain-evid-6f7e9c",
          "cluster_size": 4,
          "commit_index": 4,
          "node_id": "cain-evid-node-4",
          "pbft_engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
          "public_key_b64": "iK1GUsswLwaE+BgZ8vTE6RIzq7iJ+iYgqedsk72cMa0=",
          "quorum_size": 3,
          "sealed_at": "2026-09-21T18:10:34.153958+00:00",
          "sequence": 4,
          "signature_b64": "CCNAXZifuUxrovdaVnfeLp3/SlJsn1UggOkMMWOMEkVdtUdCENbj3nJb24Vk1A/B6bw0PEEEMy6vgX+RlltBDg==",
          "state_root": "e18c57d99ac7f80f13c735bff97d80969751ed38882698acd57ed8f6bc3d1d9a",
          "view": 0
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}