{
 "cycles": [
  {
   "accepted": false,
   "adversarial_veto": true,
   "baseline": 0.0,
   "cycle": 0,
   "paradigm": "unseen_rule",
   "preregistration": {
    "H1": "single primitive explains the data",
    "H2": "a composition is required",
    "prediction": {
     "H1": 1.0,
     "H2": 1.0
    }
   },
   "rejected": true,
   "reproduced": null,
   "reusable_on": "hidden_precondition",
   "roles": [
    "ResearchDirector",
    "HypothesisGenerator",
    "LiteratureAnalyst",
    "ExperimentDesigner",
    "StatisticalAnalyst",
    "ImplementationScientist",
    "AdversarialReviewer",
    "ReproducibilityAuditor",
    "GovernanceOfficer"
   ],
   "winner": null,
   "winner_holdout": null,
   "with_capability": 0.0
  },
  {
   "accepted": true,
   "adversarial_veto": false,
   "baseline": 0.0,
   "cycle": 1,
   "paradigm": "unseen_combination",
   "preregistration": {
    "H1": "single primitive explains the data",
    "H2": "a composition is required",
    "prediction": {
     "H1": 0.0,
     "H2": 1.0
    }
   },
   "rejected": false,
   "reproduced": 1.0,
   "reusable_on": "delayed_effect",
   "roles": [
    "ResearchDirector",
    "HypothesisGenerator",
    "LiteratureAnalyst",
    "ExperimentDesigner",
    "StatisticalAnalyst",
    "ImplementationScientist",
    "AdversarialReviewer",
    "ReproducibilityAuditor",
    "GovernanceOfficer"
   ],
   "winner": "H2",
   "winner_holdout": 1.0,
   "with_capability": 1.0
  },
  {
   "accepted": false,
   "adversarial_veto": true,
   "baseline": 0.0,
   "cycle": 2,
   "paradigm": "hidden_precondition",
   "preregistration": {
    "H1": "single primitive explains the data",
    "H2": "a composition is required",
    "prediction": {
     "H1": 1.0,
     "H2": 1.0
    }
   },
   "rejected": true,
   "reproduced": null,
   "reusable_on": "partial_observability",
   "roles": [
    "ResearchDirector",
    "HypothesisGenerator",
    "LiteratureAnalyst",
    "ExperimentDesigner",
    "StatisticalAnalyst",
    "ImplementationScientist",
    "AdversarialReviewer",
    "ReproducibilityAuditor",
    "GovernanceOfficer"
   ],
   "winner": null,
   "winner_holdout": null,
   "with_capability": 0.0
  },
  {
   "accepted": true,
   "adversarial_veto": false,
   "baseline": 1.0,
   "cycle": 3,
   "paradigm": "delayed_effect",
   "preregistration": {
    "H1": "single primitive explains the data",
    "H2": "a composition is required",
    "prediction": {
     "H1": 0.0,
     "H2": 1.0
    }
   },
   "rejected": false,
   "reproduced": 1.0,
   "reusable_on": "conflicting_observations",
   "roles": [
    "ResearchDirector",
    "HypothesisGenerator",
    "LiteratureAnalyst",
    "ExperimentDesigner",
    "StatisticalAnalyst",
    "ImplementationScientist",
    "AdversarialReviewer",
    "ReproducibilityAuditor",
    "GovernanceOfficer"
   ],
   "winner": "H2",
   "winner_holdout": 1.0,
   "with_capability": 1.0
  },
  {
   "accepted": false,
   "adversarial_veto": true,
   "baseline": 0.0,
   "cycle": 4,
   "paradigm": "conflicting_observations",
   "preregistration": {
    "H1": "single primitive explains the data",
    "H2": "a composition is required",
    "prediction": {
     "H1": 1.0,
     "H2": 1.0
    }
   },
   "rejected": true,
   "reproduced": null,
   "reusable_on": "changing_environment",
   "roles": [
    "ResearchDirector",
    "HypothesisGenerator",
    "LiteratureAnalyst",
    "ExperimentDesigner",
    "StatisticalAnalyst",
    "ImplementationScientist",
    "AdversarialReviewer",
    "ReproducibilityAuditor",
    "GovernanceOfficer"
   ],
   "winner": null,
   "winner_holdout": null,
   "with_capability": 0.0
  }
 ],
 "director_overruled_reviewer": false,
 "g10_passed": true,
 "limits": [
  "constructed paradigms",
  "roles are deterministic functions",
  "reproduction is a fresh-seed rerun, not an independent lab"
 ],
 "n_accepted": 2,
 "n_cycles": 5,
 "n_rejected_hypotheses": 3,
 "reusable_capability_improved": true,
 "reusable_lift": [
  0.0,
  1.0,
  0.0,
  0.0,
  0.0
 ],
 "roles": [
  "ResearchDirector",
  "HypothesisGenerator",
  "LiteratureAnalyst",
  "ExperimentDesigner",
  "StatisticalAnalyst",
  "ImplementationScientist",
  "AdversarialReviewer",
  "ReproducibilityAuditor",
  "GovernanceOfficer"
 ],
 "schema": "cain.e124.discovery.v2"
}
