# E126 Limitations

- **Constructed environments.** The 20-family, 100-instance challenge is not a field study or an
  external benchmark. The hypothesis grammar contains the rule classes used by the generator.
- **Same team.** Environment, agent, controls, oracle and verifier were written by the same
  three-person team. There is **no external reviewer**.
- **Seed 127 invalidation.** Seed 127 was run once but the environment code changed after the
  first commitment; it is preserved as an invalidated pilot. Confirmatory results use seed 128.
- **Novel-environment threshold.** Full 87.0% vs retrieval 78.0% is p=0.0636, missing the
  preregistered p<0.05. The E125-engine comparison is strong; the retrieval comparison is not.
- **Continual learning.** The persistent pool hurt overall accuracy (69.6% vs 83.3% no-memory).
  The result is a failure, not a demonstration of retention.
- **Causal model.** Linear structural equation, binary treatment, discrete hidden confounder.
  Active selection did not beat random. Counterfactuals are scored against a simulator, not
  real-world outcomes.
- **Transfer.** Constructed integer programs and affine surface changes; not six real industries.
  The gate rejected 20/40 positive pathways, so the system is conservative.
- **Adaptation.** One 135M CPU model, one lexicon task, one seed. Replay is eight short factual
  prompts, not a pretraining corpus. No safety-alignment evaluation.
- **Collective.** Rule-based agents, not LLMs. Verification uses two ground-truth probes and is a
  strong oracle; it banned 22 agents, including some honest ones.
- **Mission.** The run is approximately 15 minutes, not six hours. One host. Process restarts, not
  host reboot.
- **Governance.** Loopback on one host, three processes and two keys; not three machines or three
  administrators.
- **Public surfaces.** The three local homepages are updated, but the Hugging Face and
  mcpgate.online deployments were not exercised; live fetch/hash verification is partial.
- **No claims.** No AGI, VAGI, superintelligence, certification, SOC 2, hardware attestation,
  production readiness, customer revenue, patent, or official leaderboard position.
