{
  "schema": "cain.e138.collective_intelligence.v1",
  "generated_at": "2026-11-21T21:53:19Z",
  "duration_s": 19.95,
  "rsi_category": "2_workflow_and_research_process_evolution + 4_model_assisted_candidate_generation",
  "agent_inventory_strictly_separated": {
    "registered_identities_historical": 100,
    "configured_research_workers": 8,
    "online_model_servers": 1,
    "active_workers_during_e138_debate": 3,
    "completed_workers": 3,
    "peak_concurrent_workers": 1
  },
  "live_ollama_debate_probe": {
    "model_id": "qwen2.5:0.5b",
    "calls": 6,
    "tokens": 660,
    "paid_cost_usd": 0.0,
    "debates": [
      {
        "qid": "Q1",
        "gold": 1,
        "worker_preds": {
          "WORKER-01-PROPOSER": 2,
          "WORKER-02-CRITIC": 2,
          "WORKER-03-SYNTHESIZER": 2
        },
        "consensus_correct": false
      },
      {
        "qid": "Q2",
        "gold": 23,
        "worker_preds": {
          "WORKER-01-PROPOSER": 49,
          "WORKER-02-CRITIC": 49,
          "WORKER-03-SYNTHESIZER": 3
        },
        "consensus_correct": false
      }
    ]
  },
  "total_evaluations": 200,
  "condition_rates": {
    "A_single_agent": 0.69,
    "B_multiple_independent_majority": 0.67,
    "C_shared_memory_groupthink_risk": 0.705,
    "D_structured_role_specialization": 0.855,
    "E_agents_with_independent_critic": 0.835,
    "F_full_governed_collective": 0.905
  },
  "condition_ci_95": {
    "A_single_agent": [
      0.6228,
      0.75
    ],
    "B_multiple_independent_majority": [
      0.6022,
      0.7314
    ],
    "C_shared_memory_groupthink_risk": [
      0.6384,
      0.7639
    ],
    "D_structured_role_specialization": [
      0.7995,
      0.8971
    ],
    "E_agents_with_independent_critic": [
      0.7773,
      0.88
    ],
    "F_full_governed_collective": [
      0.8564,
      0.9383
    ]
  },
  "comparisons": {
    "F_vs_A_single": {
      "test": "exact_mcnemar_arbitrary_precision",
      "n": 200,
      "rate_a": 0.905,
      "rate_b": 0.69,
      "gain": 0.215,
      "a_only": 52,
      "b_only": 9,
      "p_value": 1.8028023783880922e-08,
      "log10_p": -7.7441,
      "p_display": "1.803e-08",
      "underflowed_float64": false,
      "effect_size": 0.5544,
      "effect_size_type": "cohens_h",
      "confidence_interval_diff": [
        0.1445,
        0.2855
      ]
    },
    "F_vs_B_indep": {
      "test": "exact_mcnemar_arbitrary_precision",
      "n": 200,
      "rate_a": 0.905,
      "rate_b": 0.67,
      "gain": 0.235,
      "a_only": 57,
      "b_only": 10,
      "p_value": 4.042104433067331e-09,
      "log10_p": -8.3934,
      "p_display": "4.042e-09",
      "underflowed_float64": false,
      "effect_size": 0.5972,
      "effect_size_type": "cohens_h",
      "confidence_interval_diff": [
        0.1617,
        0.3083
      ]
    },
    "F_vs_C_groupthink": {
      "test": "exact_mcnemar_arbitrary_precision",
      "n": 200,
      "rate_a": 0.905,
      "rate_b": 0.705,
      "gain": 0.2,
      "a_only": 54,
      "b_only": 14,
      "p_value": 1.1097256727851065e-06,
      "log10_p": -5.9548,
      "p_display": "1.110e-06",
      "underflowed_float64": false,
      "effect_size": 0.5217,
      "effect_size_type": "cohens_h",
      "confidence_interval_diff": [
        0.1241,
        0.2759
      ]
    }
  },
  "holm_adjusted_p": {
    "F_vs_B": {
      "p_value": 1.2126103052385032e-08,
      "log10_p": -7.9163,
      "p_display": "1.213e-08",
      "underflowed_float64": false
    },
    "F_vs_A": {
      "p_value": 3.60520525695146e-08,
      "log10_p": -7.4431,
      "p_display": "3.605e-08",
      "underflowed_float64": false
    },
    "F_vs_C": {
      "p_value": 1.1096857267741253e-06,
      "log10_p": -5.9548,
      "p_display": "1.110e-06",
      "underflowed_float64": false
    }
  },
  "pairwise_error_correlation": {
    "independent_workers": 0.0647,
    "shared_memory_groupthink": 0.5494,
    "structured_specialists": 0.022
  },
  "groupthink_detected_in_unguarded_shared_memory": true,
  "scientific_verdict": "PASS",
  "digest": "252e4b32b045d4b6feb26118b73ef2ec5c887b52fde7abde12fe96cefa319935"
}