{
  "schema": "cain.e138.research_loop.v1",
  "generated_at": "2026-11-21T21:56:38Z",
  "rsi_category": "2_workflow_and_research_process_evolution",
  "cycles_completed": 3,
  "critic_overrides_of_internal_pass": 2,
  "mean_design_quality_before_critique": 0.6167,
  "mean_design_quality_after_critique": 0.91,
  "design_improvement_from_critique": 0.2933,
  "rejected_hypotheses_preserved": 3,
  "cycles": [
    {
      "cycle_id": "LOOP-01",
      "question": "Does E137 Bayesian mixture causal policy survive continuous Gaussian confounders?",
      "competing_hypotheses": [
        "H1a: Binary mixture degrades smoothly under continuous U ~ N(0,1)",
        "H1b: Binary mixture suffers sharp misspecification bias; Student-t/Huber estimator required"
      ],
      "initial_design_score": 0.62,
      "internal_evaluator_verdict": "PASS",
      "adversarial_critic_verdict": "REJECT_INITIAL_DESIGN",
      "critic_objection": "Initial experiment omitted estimator-matched continuous control and rounded p=0.0; cannot claim robustness without Student-t/Huber baseline and log10(p).",
      "revision_applied": "Added continuous-confounder stress regime, Huber M-estimator, and arbitrary-precision log10(p) reporting.",
      "revised_design_score": 0.91,
      "replicated": true,
      "final_status": "REVISED_AND_CONFIRMED"
    },
    {
      "cycle_id": "LOOP-02",
      "question": "Does G6-G10 macro inheritance continue compounding beyond G5 without overfitting?",
      "competing_hypotheses": [
        "H2a: G10 strictly beats G5 on unseen tasks",
        "H2b: Gains saturate around G3-G5 on bounded 4-tier DSL; uncontrolled growth risks overfitting"
      ],
      "initial_design_score": 0.58,
      "internal_evaluator_verdict": "PASS",
      "adversarial_critic_verdict": "REJECT_UNCHECKED_PROMOTION",
      "critic_objection": "Internal dev solve rate rose to 1.0 while unseen solve rate plateaued; critic blocked promotion of size-bloated candidate and forced non-regression + size cap.",
      "revision_applied": "Added sealed non-regression gate, 130-macro size cap, and dual unseen holdout splits (48 tasks).",
      "revised_design_score": 0.89,
      "replicated": true,
      "final_status": "HYPOTHESIS_H2A_REFUTED_H2B_CONFIRMED"
    },
    {
      "cycle_id": "LOOP-03",
      "question": "Can raw 0.5B/1.5B CPU LLM alone break the 0.625 Code-RSI ceiling without verified memory?",
      "competing_hypotheses": [
        "H3a: Prompt reflection alone lifts 0.5B LLM >= 0.625",
        "H3b: Small CPU LLM alone stays below 0.625; verified pattern memory + AST sandbox is required"
      ],
      "initial_design_score": 0.65,
      "internal_evaluator_verdict": "PARTIAL",
      "adversarial_critic_verdict": "REQUIRE_DISAGGREGATION",
      "critic_objection": "Combining pure-LLM and memory-backed Code-RSI into one headline would overstate neural capability; critic forced separate disclosure of live LLM probe vs governed hybrid.",
      "revision_applied": "Disaggregated live local LLM probe from 40-task governed AST+memory suite and tagged RSI category 4+1 (zero weight updates).",
      "revised_design_score": 0.93,
      "replicated": true,
      "final_status": "H3A_REJECTED_PRESERVED_H3B_CONFIRMED"
    }
  ],
  "verdict": "PASS"
}