# CAIN-42 E21 — Final Maturity Report

## What existed before E21
E20 governed autonomous intelligence substrate (state, temporal authorization, capability,
delegation, evidence, invariants I13–I26) and the live Frontier-20 fleet.

## What E21 implemented
A governed state transition as a verifiable object: transition schema, 14-root hierarchy, 14-stage
validation pipeline, witness, state diff, quorum certificate committing to content, lifecycle
machine, deterministic replay, divergence detection, invariants I27–I50, Byzantine state lab,
composition machine, and an independent clean-room verifier.

## What E21 tested
1,000-step deterministic replay; 1,000 replay scenarios / 4 replicas agree; 24/24 invariants;
16/16 Byzantine state attacks; 47/47 E21 tests; 20/20 products reachable; clean-room proof VERIFIED.

## What E21 deployed
Nothing to the live request path. The evidence bundle is published (HTTP 200) to cainstudio.online,
mcpgate.online and clawx.click. E21 code is not yet wired into the gateway authorization path.

## What E21 verified
In-process deterministic validation/replay/certificate/witness/invariants and independent
recomputation of the state proof.

## What remains unverified / simulated / not done
- Multi-host Byzantine consensus and transport — NOT_MEASURED.
- Performance and chaos — NOT_MEASURED.
- Frontier-20 composition execution — NOT_EXECUTED.
- Invariants are runtime checks, not machine proofs.
- No independent third-party verification; no certification.

## Honest release status
E21 mandatory gates PASS; non-mandatory gates (`compositions`, `performance`) are NOT_MEASURED. This
is an evidence-bound incremental advance, not a claim that CAIN-42 is complete.

## Recovered answers to the directive's questions
For an E21 transition the system can answer who/what/knowledge/policy/authority/capabilities/
delegation/risk/consequence/invariants/replicas/quorum/state-change/evidence, and an independent
verifier can reproduce it — **for the in-process scope**. It cannot yet answer them across a real
multi-host deployment. That gap is stated, not invented.
