# CAIN-42 E21 — Implementation Report

## What E21 actually implemented

| Component | File | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Governed state transition | `cain/e21/transitions.py` | 34-field canonical transition; immutable; transition hash |
| State-root hierarchy | `cain/e21/roots.py` | 14 domain-separated roots + global Merkle root |
| Validation pipeline | `cain/e21/validation.py` | 14 deterministic stages; machine-readable rejection codes |
| Transition witness | `cain/e21/witness.py` | binds prior/proposed state + governance commitments; verifier |
| State diff | `cain/e21/diff.py` | ADDED/REMOVED/MODIFIED/UNCHANGED + unchanged-proof |
| Quorum certificate | `cain/e21/certificates.py` | binds transition + roots + epoch/view/seq + witness; validator |
| Governance state machine | `cain/e21/machine.py` | PROPOSED…EXECUTED + failure states; no invalid→EXECUTABLE |
| Deterministic replay | `cain/e21/replay.py` | recompute root from diff; differential across replicas |
| Divergence detector | `cain/e21/divergence.py` | earliest divergent transition |
| Invariants I27–I50 | `cain/e21/invariants.py` | 24 executable runtime checks |
| Byzantine state lab | `cain/e21/byzantine.py` | 16 state attacks |
| Composition machine | `cain/e21/composition.py` | chained multi-product composition record |
| Clean-room verifier | `verification/e21/cleanroom/state_verifier.py` | independent recomputation, zero CAIN imports |
| Contract CLI | `tools/e21/e21_contract.py` | gates + evidence generation |

## Measured results

- State: 1,000-step replay, deterministic, final root stable.
- Transitions: 14-stage pipeline; invalid inputs rejected at the correct stage.
- Certificates: threshold + commit-to-transition + tamper detection PASS.
- Witnesses: bind + tamper detection PASS.
- Invariants: 24/24 I27–I50 PASS.
- Replay: 1,000 scenarios; 4 replicas agree on one final root.
- Divergence: earliest index detected.
- Byzantine: 16/16 state attacks caught.
- Products: 20/20 Frontier products reachable on the live cluster.
- Tests: 47 passed / 0 failed (`tests/e21`); E20 suite still 42/42; pre-existing E18/19/20: 209.
- Clean-room: independent verifier reproduces and accepts the state proof; rejects tampering.

## What was NOT done

- Performance benchmarks — NOT_MEASURED.
- Chaos / distributed soak — NOT_MEASURED.
- Multi-host Byzantine transport validation — NOT_MEASURED.
- Frontier-20 composition execution — NOT_EXECUTED (machinery + structural self-test only).
- E21 not yet wired into the live gateway authorization path.

## Central deliverable

Governed state transitions are now verifiable objects: each can carry identity, authority, policy,
temporal/epistemic context, risk, consequence, invariants, state root, witness and a quorum
certificate that commits to the transition — verifiable by a party that does not trust the runtime.
