# CAIN-42 E21 — Public Truth Report

Every claim maps to evidence. Categories are never upgraded. See `artifacts/e21/`.

| Claim | Status | Evidence | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Invalid state transitions are rejected deterministically | TESTED | `E21_GATE_RESULTS.json` | runtime checks |
| Quorum certificate commits to the exact transition it signs | TESTED | `E21_GATE_RESULTS.json` | in-process keys |
| Deterministic distributed replay | TESTED | `E21_REPLAY_RESULTS.json` | single process / 4 logical replicas |
| Divergence detected at earliest index | TESTED | `E21_DIVERGENCE_RESULTS.json` | synthetic histories |
| Byzantine state attacks caught (16/16) | TESTED | `E21_BYZANTINE_RESULTS.json` | in-process adversary model |
| Invariants I27–I50 hold | TESTED | `E21_INVARIANTS.json` | runtime checks, not proofs |
| Independent clean-room verification of the state proof | TESTED | `E21_STATE_PROOF.json` | same algorithms re-implemented |
| Frontier-20 reachable (20/20) | OBSERVED | `E21_GATE_RESULTS.json` | reachability only |
| Frontier-20 composition executes end-to-end | NOT_EXECUTED | — | machinery only |
| Multi-host Byzantine consensus | UNKNOWN | — | not exercised |
| Performance SLOs | UNKNOWN | — | NOT_MEASURED |
| Hardware-rooted enforcement | UNKNOWN | — | no physical silicon |

## Explicit non-claims
No independent third-party verification; no formal machine proof; no certification; no claim that
passing checks guarantee universal safety.
