# CAIN-42 E21 — Technical Moat Report

Scored only from what was measured. The moat is coherent, verified behaviour — not line count.

| Factor | Strength | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| State dimensions | HIGH | 14 named roots, per-dimension change tracking |
| Transition semantics | HIGH | 34 bound fields → one transition hash |
| Validation depth | MEDIUM-HIGH | 14-stage deterministic pipeline |
| Cryptographic bindings | MEDIUM | Merkle roots, Ed25519 certs committing to content |
| Distributed replay | MEDIUM | deterministic + differential (in-process) |
| Invariant corpus | MEDIUM | 24 executable checks (I27–I50) |
| Byzantine state coverage | MEDIUM | 16 state attacks (in-process) |
| Clean-room verification | MEDIUM | independent recomputation, zero CAIN imports |
| Multi-host / chaos / performance | LOW | NOT_MEASURED |
| Composition execution | LOW | machinery only |
| Independent third-party verification | LOW | none |

Reproduction complexity comes from the interaction of validation, roots, witness, certificate,
replay and invariants — all of which must agree. No monetary valuation is derived.
