# CAIN-42 E22 — Master Report

**E22 = Byzantine Governed Execution Intelligence Fabric.** E21 made governed state transitions
verifiable; E22 makes them enforceable at execution time and proves it end-to-end.

## 1. E21 baseline (unchanged)
1,000-step deterministic replay; 24/24 invariants I27–I50; 16/16 Byzantine state attacks; clean-room
state proof verified; 47/47 E21 tests.

## 2. What E22 implemented
`cain/e22/`: single-use `GovernedExecutionPermit`; `AuthorizationStateBinding` (state↔authorization);
`GovernedExecutionTransaction` (BEGIN→PREPARE→VALIDATE→AUTHORIZE→EXECUTE→COMMIT / ABORT→ROLLBACK) with
prepare/commit staleness abort; execution + composition certificates; composition engine; **real
RIG→OpenShell product executors**; replica quarantine; checkpoint recovery + Byzantine recovery lab;
multi-process transport harness; forensics; feature-flagged live gate (OFF/SHADOW/ENFORCING/
EMERGENCY_DISABLED); invariants I51–I72; zero-CAIN-import clean-room verifier.

## 3. Measured this session
- **Gates:** all 13 E22 gates PASS (`artifacts/e22/E22_GATE_RESULTS.json`).
- **First real composition executed:** RIG registered an agent → minted a single-use proof-of-possession
  token → consumed it → OpenShell registered a policy and ran a real kernel-sandboxed command
  (`echo`, exit 0, sandboxed=true). `E22_COMPOSITION_RESULTS.json`.
- **Execution:** permit consumed once; replay refused; stale-state-at-commit aborts. `E22_GATE_RESULTS.json`.
- **Invariants:** I51–I72 22/22 PASS (`E22_SECURITY_RESULTS.json`).
- **Byzantine transport:** multi-process replicas; `none` consistent, drop/reorder/duplicate/forged all
  detected (`E22_BYZANTINE_RESULTS.json`).
- **Recovery:** 7/7 Byzantine recovery attacks caught (`E22_RECOVERY_RESULTS.json`).
- **Chaos:** 6/6 in-process fault scenarios contained (`E22_CHAOS_RESULTS.json`).
- **Performance (control plane, in-process):** binding verify p50 0.011 ms / p99 0.110 ms; permit
  consume p50 0.0015 ms; cert sign p50 0.099 ms; cert sign+verify p50 0.321 ms; full invariant suite
  p50 4.66 ms. `E22_PERFORMANCE_RESULTS.json`.
- **Tests:** 39/39 E22; 47 E21; 42 E20; 209 prior.
- **Clean-room:** `E22 EXECUTION PROOF VERIFIED (independent recomputation)`.

## 4. What E22 did NOT do (never claim otherwise)
- **Not deployed to the live authorization path.** The feature flag exists; the gateway still runs the
  E8 path without E22 enforcement. `E22 SHADOW/ENFORCING = NOT_ENABLED`.
- **Multi-host** Byzantine transport: `NOT_MEASURED` (multi-process, same host).
- **Consensus/data-plane performance:** `NOT_MEASURED` (control plane only).
- **Distributed soak:** `NOT_MEASURED`.
- **Canonical multi-product composition** (RIG→OpenShell→MemVault→VIGIL→SCITT): `NOT_EXECUTED`.
- Real composition replay is `NONDETERMINISTIC_EXTERNAL` (random token/exec IDs); deterministic replay
  is proven only on synthetic compositions. Recorded, not hidden.
- Invariants are runtime checks, not machine proofs. No independent third-party verification.

## 5. Remaining blockers
1. Enable E22 in SHADOW on the live gateway, then ENFORCING behind an operator flag, and measure.
2. Build the canonical 5-product composition with MemVault/VIGIL/SCITT real APIs.
3. Multi-host transport + soak.
4. Consensus/data-plane benchmarks separate from the control plane.

## 6. Bottom line
E22 closes the state→execution gap **in-process and evidence-bound**: a real RIG→OpenShell governed
composition ran, produced execution + composition certificates, and an independent verifier
reproduced the proof. It is not yet on the live enforcement path, and that gap is stated.
