# CAIN-42 E23 — Final Forensic Report

## 1. Executive summary
E23 closed the E22 gaps it could honestly close: E22 is now **live in SHADOW** on the real
`/frontier/authorize` authorization path (observation only, never blocks), the **real five-product
composition** RIG→OpenShell→MemVault→VIGIL→SCITT executes with all products performing their real
roles, authority is conserved, governance lineage is validated, a **real TCP** same-host Byzantine
transport (N=4, Q=3) detects drop/partition/forged/Byzantine/reorder/duplicate faults, chaos is
contained with zero unauthorized executions, and a zero-CAIN-import clean-room verifier reproduces the
Frontier proof. It is **not** promoted to ENFORCING, and multi-host + distributed soak remain
unmeasured.

## 2. Architecture delta from E22
Added `cain/e23/`: authority conservation, governance lineage graph, real five-product composition,
shadow divergence engine + live integration, five-phase transaction lifecycle, replay envelope, real
TCP Byzantine transport, chaos campaign, invariants I73–I96, clean-room frontier verifier.

## 3. E22 gaps closed
- Live integration (SHADOW) — **closed**.
- Five-product composition — **closed** (real).
- Real networked (TCP) Byzantine transport — **closed, same-host**.
- Replay determinism framing — **partially closed** (logical determinism; external nondeterminism
  recorded).
- Chaos — **closed (in-process + same-host)**.

## 4. E22/E23 gaps remaining (NOT closed)
- Multi-host with independent failure domains — **NOT_MEASURED**.
- ENFORCING promotion — **NOT_DEPLOYED** (gate D/E unmet).
- Distributed soak 1h/6h/24h/72h — **NOT_MEASURED** (only a bounded in-process soak is available).
- Full 10- and 20-product composition matrix — **NOT_EXECUTED**.
- Consensus-plane performance — **NOT_MEASURED**.

## 5. Live enforcement status
`GET /frontier/e23/shadow` → `mode=SHADOW`, `enforced=false`. A real authorize call produced a shadow
record classified `MATCH_DENY` (E8 denies; E22 would also deny). **E22 on the live path = LIVE_SHADOW,
not enforcement.**

## 6. Shadow results
The live request carries no E21 state root / policy hash / permit, so E22 records those bindings as
missing (e.g. `POLICY_MISMATCH`). This is the honest gap quantification SHADOW exists for; it never
changes the E8 decision.

## 7. Five-product composition results
`RIG` (register + single-use proof-of-possession token consumed) → `OpenShell` (kernel-sandboxed
`echo`, exit 0) → `MemVault` (write ALLOW) → `VIGIL` (PROCEED, prm 0.95) → `SCITT` (receipt verified).
Authority conserved across all steps; lineage valid; final root produced.
Evidence: `artifacts/e23/E23_COMPOSITION_RESULTS.json`.

## 8. Distributed (Byzantine) results
TCP loopback, 4 replica processes, quorum 3, HMAC-authenticated messages. `none` → consistent (4/4,
one root). `drop`/`partition`/`forged`/`reorder`/`duplicate` → 3 agreeing + divergence detected.
`byzantine` → 2 distinct roots, quorum **not** reached. **Same-host only; multi_host = NOT_MEASURED.**

## 9. Chaos results
14/14 scenarios contained, 0 unauthorized protected executions. Includes quorum loss (2/4 → no
authority), replica restart, certificate corruption, authorization revocation / policy drift / tenant
drift between prepare and commit (all abort), product failure during composition (VIGIL refuses),
evidence-store check.

## 10. Recovery results
7/7 Byzantine recovery attacks caught (corrupted/stale/malicious/replayed checkpoint, revoked-state
restoration, incomplete transfer); valid checkpoint accepted.

## 11. Soak
Bounded in-process soak available via `e23_contract.py soak <seconds>`; no 1h+/distributed soak run.
**NOT_MEASURED** for the required durations.

## 12. Performance (control plane, in-process)
Five-product composition, authority conservation, and lineage validation timings recorded in
`E23_PERFORMANCE_RESULTS.json`. Consensus/data plane **NOT_MEASURED**.

## 13. Replay
Logical determinism reproducible; external nondeterminism (RIG token ids, OpenShell exec ids,
timestamps) explicitly recorded, never deleted. Evidence: `E23_FRONTIER_PROOF.json`.

## 14. Tenant isolation
Two tenants composed concurrently (ThreadPool) → distinct final roots, each tenant-consistent. PASS.

## 15. Invariants
I73–I96 **24/24 PASS** (`E23_INVARIANTS.json`). Runtime checks, not machine proofs.

## 16. Clean-room verification
`E23 FRONTIER PROOF VERIFIED (independent recomputation)` — authority conservation, lineage
integrity, replay logical hash, signed execution certificate. Verifier imports no CAIN code.

## 17. Evidence integrity
Bundle published with per-file manifest hashes and an offline verifier; see the published bundle.

## 18. Security findings
No critical authorization bypass, permit replay, cross-tenant escape, state-binding bypass or fail-open
path found **within the tested (in-process + same-host TCP) scope**. Untested scopes are labelled.

## 19. Public-truth classification
See `E23_PUBLIC_TRUTH.md`. Notably: E22 = LIVE_SHADOW (not enforcing); TCP transport = TESTED
(same-host); multi-host = NOT_MEASURED; clean-room = self-authored independent recomputation (not
third-party).

## 20. Remaining blockers
1. Multi-host deployment with independent failure domains (GATE D).
2. Distributed soak (GATE E).
3. ENFORCING promotion (GATE G).
4. 10/20-product composition matrix.

## 21. Exact E24 priorities
Turn the Frontier-20 into one governed substrate: forensic inventory + registry, common substrate
contracts, composition graph with machine validation, universal authority-conservation engine,
cross-product state fabric, execution envelope, policy composition, risk fusion, conformance engine,
and published evidence — without over-claiming multi-host or enforcement.
