{
  "authority_deltas": [
    {
      "answers": {
        "attenuated": true,
        "capability_authorized": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "capability_used": "exec",
        "checks": {
          "conserved": true
        },
        "consumer": "RIG",
        "evidence": "1737a31741eb091d2a355db46a564fd1a50f479131863f3e675193db2b45da0b",
        "expanded": [],
        "remaining_authority": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "which_state_authorized": "056b15a642ac9adeddb8670a230e2ccc91eb70377e62aedbb8c796337378d851",
        "who_authorized": "auth-e23"
      },
      "attenuated": true,
      "authority_in": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "MemVault",
          "OpenShell",
          "RIG",
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authority_out": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "MemVault",
          "OpenShell",
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authorized_by": "auth-e23",
      "conserved": true,
      "evidence_hash": "1737a31741eb091d2a355db46a564fd1a50f479131863f3e675193db2b45da0b",
      "expanded_dimensions": [],
      "from_product": "AUTHORIZATION",
      "state_root": "056b15a642ac9adeddb8670a230e2ccc91eb70377e62aedbb8c796337378d851",
      "to_product": "RIG"
    },
    {
      "answers": {
        "attenuated": true,
        "capability_authorized": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "capability_used": "exec",
        "checks": {
          "conserved": true
        },
        "consumer": "OpenShell",
        "evidence": "25c0731c37b948e1bd8c9609c9dc2a8aa6c385e629267ffab10c29f86d5fba92",
        "expanded": [],
        "remaining_authority": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "which_state_authorized": "1737a31741eb091d2a355db46a564fd1a50f479131863f3e675193db2b45da0b",
        "who_authorized": "auth-e23"
      },
      "attenuated": true,
      "authority_in": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "MemVault",
          "OpenShell",
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authority_out": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "MemVault",
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authorized_by": "auth-e23",
      "conserved": true,
      "evidence_hash": "25c0731c37b948e1bd8c9609c9dc2a8aa6c385e629267ffab10c29f86d5fba92",
      "expanded_dimensions": [],
      "from_product": "RIG",
      "state_root": "1737a31741eb091d2a355db46a564fd1a50f479131863f3e675193db2b45da0b",
      "to_product": "OpenShell"
    },
    {
      "answers": {
        "attenuated": true,
        "capability_authorized": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "capability_used": "write_memory",
        "checks": {
          "conserved": true
        },
        "consumer": "MemVault",
        "evidence": "f9b2c3ee4cb4f64c831b17f8f61898c4654fa83df2fcc3eaec04b20af06f53ee",
        "expanded": [],
        "remaining_authority": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "which_state_authorized": "25c0731c37b948e1bd8c9609c9dc2a8aa6c385e629267ffab10c29f86d5fba92",
        "who_authorized": "auth-e23"
      },
      "attenuated": true,
      "authority_in": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "MemVault",
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authority_out": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authorized_by": "auth-e23",
      "conserved": true,
      "evidence_hash": "f9b2c3ee4cb4f64c831b17f8f61898c4654fa83df2fcc3eaec04b20af06f53ee",
      "expanded_dimensions": [],
      "from_product": "OpenShell",
      "state_root": "25c0731c37b948e1bd8c9609c9dc2a8aa6c385e629267ffab10c29f86d5fba92",
      "to_product": "MemVault"
    },
    {
      "answers": {
        "attenuated": true,
        "capability_authorized": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "capability_used": "list_dir",
        "checks": {
          "conserved": true
        },
        "consumer": "VIGIL",
        "evidence": "76ed7c59a91db6cace3285dcdd4b421d5a90e42101ec79648122bff103e3b80b",
        "expanded": [],
        "remaining_authority": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "which_state_authorized": "f9b2c3ee4cb4f64c831b17f8f61898c4654fa83df2fcc3eaec04b20af06f53ee",
        "who_authorized": "auth-e23"
      },
      "attenuated": true,
      "authority_in": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "SCITT",
          "VIGIL"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authority_out": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "SCITT"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authorized_by": "auth-e23",
      "conserved": true,
      "evidence_hash": "76ed7c59a91db6cace3285dcdd4b421d5a90e42101ec79648122bff103e3b80b",
      "expanded_dimensions": [],
      "from_product": "MemVault",
      "state_root": "f9b2c3ee4cb4f64c831b17f8f61898c4654fa83df2fcc3eaec04b20af06f53ee",
      "to_product": "VIGIL"
    },
    {
      "answers": {
        "attenuated": true,
        "capability_authorized": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "capability_used": "register_evidence",
        "checks": {
          "conserved": true
        },
        "consumer": "SCITT",
        "evidence": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
        "expanded": [],
        "remaining_authority": [],
        "which_state_authorized": "76ed7c59a91db6cace3285dcdd4b421d5a90e42101ec79648122bff103e3b80b",
        "who_authorized": "auth-e23"
      },
      "attenuated": true,
      "authority_in": {
        "autonomy_level": 1,
        "capabilities": [
          "exec"
        ],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [
          "SCITT"
        ],
        "resources": [
          "/tmp"
        ],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authority_out": {
        "autonomy_level": 0,
        "capabilities": [],
        "principal": "human-1",
        "products": [],
        "resources": [],
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      "authorized_by": "auth-e23",
      "conserved": true,
      "evidence_hash": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
      "expanded_dimensions": [],
      "from_product": "VIGIL",
      "state_root": "76ed7c59a91db6cace3285dcdd4b421d5a90e42101ec79648122bff103e3b80b",
      "to_product": "SCITT"
    }
  ],
  "execution_certificate": {
    "certificate": {
      "authorization": "auth-e23",
      "composition_id": "",
      "environment": "in-process",
      "evidence_root": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
      "execution_id": "e23-exec",
      "operation": "compose",
      "permit_id": "pm-e23",
      "result_hash": "62ade4bd9980a1a99afc693b9dcaed31c73733226baae281641052956b8186f4",
      "software_revision": "rev1",
      "state_root": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
      "status": "COMMITTED",
      "target": "/tmp",
      "tenant": "t1",
      "timestamp": 0.0,
      "transition_id": "tx-e23"
    },
    "payload_hash": "46de2d4b33f92f42faf972eff9fe8b194989e4fb2c4f9d3a4033d9f87dd10b85",
    "public_key_b64": "WoBd03EfUofsknVLKaRHBo1x20bnBVtg95JBEKFIcV4=",
    "signature_b64": "CYzM+GbIwGcvsUxrSqLXlQsC3Hq9YFuVgzfvGUGUw36uUExBU34qCEzVOcOPbnQ7OADqfTC4Tpqp/8XMAHhFBA=="
  },
  "final_root": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
  "lineage": {
    "head": "359e513c27a454f93541259dbb9535d2ab7978dffd3c585dab19c4b55ebeadee",
    "kinds": [
      "AGENT",
      "AUTHORIZATION",
      "CERTIFICATE",
      "COMMIT",
      "EVIDENCE",
      "EXECUTION",
      "IDENTITY",
      "INTENT",
      "PERMIT",
      "POLICY",
      "PREPARE",
      "PRODUCT",
      "STATE",
      "STATE_UPDATE"
    ],
    "nodes": [
      {
        "kind": "AGENT",
        "node_id": "n-agent",
        "parent_id": null,
        "ref": "e23-proof",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "IDENTITY",
        "node_id": "n-ident",
        "parent_id": "n-agent",
        "ref": "rig:e23-proof",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "INTENT",
        "node_id": "n-intent",
        "parent_id": "n-ident",
        "ref": "compose:rig\u2192openshell\u2192memvault\u2192vigil\u2192scitt",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "STATE",
        "node_id": "n-state",
        "parent_id": "n-intent",
        "ref": "root-initial",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "POLICY",
        "node_id": "n-policy",
        "parent_id": "n-state",
        "ref": "pol-e23",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "AUTHORIZATION",
        "node_id": "n-auth",
        "parent_id": "n-policy",
        "ref": "auth-e23",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PERMIT",
        "node_id": "n-permit",
        "parent_id": "n-auth",
        "ref": "pm-e23",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PREPARE",
        "node_id": "n-prepare",
        "parent_id": "n-permit",
        "ref": "prepare-e23",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PRODUCT",
        "node_id": "n-rig",
        "parent_id": "n-prepare",
        "ref": "RIG:1737a31741eb",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PRODUCT",
        "node_id": "n-openshell",
        "parent_id": "n-rig",
        "ref": "OpenShell:25c0731c37b9",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PRODUCT",
        "node_id": "n-memvault",
        "parent_id": "n-openshell",
        "ref": "MemVault:f9b2c3ee4cb4",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PRODUCT",
        "node_id": "n-vigil",
        "parent_id": "n-memvault",
        "ref": "VIGIL:76ed7c59a91d",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "PRODUCT",
        "node_id": "n-scitt",
        "parent_id": "n-vigil",
        "ref": "SCITT:3e6c7e36137f",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "COMMIT",
        "node_id": "n-commit",
        "parent_id": "n-scitt",
        "ref": "commit:3e6c7e36137f",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "EXECUTION",
        "node_id": "n-exec",
        "parent_id": "n-commit",
        "ref": "exec",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "CERTIFICATE",
        "node_id": "n-cert",
        "parent_id": "n-exec",
        "ref": "cert:3e6c7e36137f",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "EVIDENCE",
        "node_id": "n-evid",
        "parent_id": "n-cert",
        "ref": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      },
      {
        "kind": "STATE_UPDATE",
        "node_id": "n-update",
        "parent_id": "n-evid",
        "ref": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df",
        "revoked": false,
        "stale": false,
        "tenant": "t1"
      }
    ],
    "ok": true,
    "problems": []
  },
  "products": [
    "RIG",
    "OpenShell",
    "MemVault",
    "VIGIL",
    "SCITT"
  ],
  "replay_envelope": {
    "certificate_hash": "46de2d4b33f92f42faf972eff9fe8b194989e4fb2c4f9d3a4033d9f87dd10b85",
    "configuration_digest": "cfg",
    "deterministic_seed": "seed-proof",
    "evidence_refs": [],
    "execution_result": "",
    "identity": "e23-proof",
    "logical_hash": "4b8e7a8e79e51a33ad82b7bf71da4c51348c0adb843f4b7c09e7010690670f1f",
    "logical_request": {
      "products": [
        "RIG",
        "OpenShell",
        "MemVault",
        "VIGIL",
        "SCITT"
      ]
    },
    "nondeterministic_values": {
      "openshell_exec_id": "random",
      "rig_token_id": "random"
    },
    "permitted_external_inputs": {},
    "policy": "pol-e23",
    "software_revision": "rev1",
    "state_root": "3e6c7e36137f48d55513523214711c739afd8f53e12a566d02b8fc0c57f576df"
  },
  "schema": "cain.e23.frontier_proof.v1"
}