# CAIN-42 E23 — Public Truth

Categories are never collapsed. Distinguish same-host from multi-host; clean-room from third-party.

| Capability | Classification | Evidence | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| E23 SHADOW on live `/frontier/authorize` | LIVE_SHADOW | `E23_SHADOW_LIVE.json` + live endpoint | observation only; never blocks |
| E22 enforcement | NOT_DEPLOYED | — | promotion gates D/E unmet |
| Five-product composition (RIG→OpenShell→MemVault→VIGIL→SCITT) | TESTED | `E23_COMPOSITION_RESULTS.json` | in-process against temp DBs |
| Authority conservation | TESTED | `E23_FRONTIER_PROOF.json` | in-process |
| Governance lineage | TESTED | `E23_COMPOSITION_RESULTS.json` | in-process |
| Real TCP Byzantine transport | TESTED | `E23_DISTRIBUTED_RESULTS.json` | **same-host loopback** |
| Multi-host (independent failure domains) | NOT_MEASURED | — | no multi-host infra |
| Chaos containment | TESTED | `E23_CHAOS_RESULTS.json` | in-process + same-host TCP |
| Recovery attacks caught | TESTED | `E23_RECOVERY_RESULTS.json` | in-process |
| Replay (logical determinism) | TESTED | `E23_FRONTIER_PROOF.json` | external nondeterminism recorded |
| Performance (control plane) | MEASURED | `E23_PERFORMANCE_RESULTS.json` | in-process; consensus/data plane not measured |
| Invariants I73–I96 | TESTED | `E23_INVARIANTS.json` | runtime checks, not proofs |
| Clean-room frontier proof verification | TESTED | `E23_FRONTIER_PROOF.json` | self-authored recomputation |
| Independent third-party verification | NOT_MEASURED | — | none |
| Distributed soak (1h/6h/24h/72h) | NOT_MEASURED | — | — |
| 10/20-product composition matrix | NOT_EXECUTED | — | only 5-product chain run |

## Non-claims
No certification, no third-party verification, no formal proof, no hardware/physical validation,
no production-enforcement claim.
