# E24 — Commercial Value Model (evidence-based; no fantasy valuations)

Scored from what is implemented, tested and evidenced — with assumptions and missing evidence stated
for every scenario. No monetary valuation is asserted.

## Capability scores (0–5, from evidence)

| Dimension | Score | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Enterprise utility | 4 | state-bound authorization, single-use permits, evidence bundles, conformance |
| Technical differentiation | 4 | composed state→authority→execution proof with cross-layer agreement |
| Integration depth | 3 | 5 products executed in-process; 20 conformance; composition graph validated |
| Switching cost potential | 3 | would rise sharply once ENFORCING + multi-host exist |
| Security/governance value | 4 | invariants I13–I108; Byzantine + chaos corpora; no known critical bypass in tested scope |
| Developer value | 3 | SDK/CLI + offline verifiers |
| Evidence credibility | 3 | published, offline-verifiable bundles; but self-authored verification |
| Maturity | 2 | E22 LIVE_SHADOW, not enforcing; multi-host NOT_MEASURED |
| Deployment readiness | 2 | live gateway, but E23/E24 not on the enforcement path |

## Scenarios

- **CURRENT EVIDENCE VALUE** — a verified, reproducible *governance research/engineering* asset.
  Assumption: self-verification. Missing: independent verification, multi-host, enforcement.
- **NEAR-TERM COMMERCIAL POTENTIAL** — pilot/staged deployments of the evidence + conformance layers
  (evidence bundles, conformance reports) sold as assurance tooling.
  Assumption: customers value court-admissible evidence + conformance. Missing: ENFORCING, SOC/ISO audit.
- **ENTERPRISE SCALE POTENTIAL** — the full substrate as an enforcement gateway for agent actions.
  Assumption: multi-host BFT + ENFORCING proven. Missing: both today.
- **HIGH-UPSIDE SCENARIO** — standards/conformance leadership for agent-execution governance.
  Assumption: ecosystem adoption + independent certification. Missing: everything external.

## Explicit non-claims
No ROI, no revenue, no valuation, no market leadership, no customer adoption. Those require evidence
that does not yet exist. Inflating them would contradict the repository's public-truth rule.
