# CAIN-42 E24 — Final Forensic Report

## 1–2. Summary & architecture
E24 turns the Frontier-20 into **one governed substrate**: a shared envelope, shared state root,
universal authority conservation, a machine-validated composition graph, shared policy/risk fusion,
conformance, and clean-room verification. All E20–E23 layers remain; E24 adds the substrate layer.
No authority is created by composition.

## 3. Shared substrate
`cain/e24/substrate.py` — `FrontierEnvelope` (attenuation-only; expansion raises) and
`FrontierStateRoot` (12 domain-separated dimensions; deterministic global root).

## 4. Composition graph
`cain/e24/composition_graph.py` — typed edges; `E24_GRAPH_RESULTS.json` PASS. Rejects
observation/evidence/reputation/prediction→authority and product→execution bypass. Verified with a
negative test.

## 5. Registry & product maturity
`cain/e24/frontier20_registry.json` — 20 products with governance role, authority boundary, HW class,
maturity. 5 have real in-process executors; 15 are conformance-only.

## 6. Authority conservation
`cain/e24/authority.py` `chain_conservation` — `AUTHORITY_OUT ⊆ AUTHORITY_IN`; PASS in the substrate
proof. `E23_FRONTIER_PROOF.json` records per-step deltas.

## 7. State fabric
Domain-separated Frontier state root; one product cannot substitute another's state.

## 8. Execution envelope
Attenuation-only shared envelope; every product consumes or attenuates; expansion raises.

## 9. Policy composition
`cain/e24/policy.py` — intersection + deny dominance + contradiction/shadow/gap detection; PASS.

## 10. Risk fusion
`cain/e24/risk.py` — segregates observed/correlated/contradictory/uncertain/simulated/predicted;
never averages into authority; PASS.

## 11. Capability graph / 12. supply chain / 13. transaction fabric / 14–16 behaviors / 17. cyber-physical
**Partially implemented or not implemented this session** (NOT_MEASURED / NOT_IMPLEMENTED). The
registry declares each product's role and boundary; deep graphs for these are E25 work.

## 18. Byzantine governance (from E23)
TCP loopback N=4/Q=3 detects drop/partition/forge/reorder/duplicate and Byzantine quorum loss.
Same-host only.

## 19. Recovery (from E23) — 7/7 recovery attacks caught.

## 20. Replay (from E23) — logical determinism; external nondeterminism recorded.

## 21. Conformance
`E24_CONFORMANCE_RESULTS.json` — 20/20 reachable; envelope contract PASS; 5 EXECUTED, 15
CONFORMANCE_ONLY. This is conformance, not certification.

## 22. Clean-room verification
`E24 FRONTIER SUBSTRATE PROOF VERIFIED (independent recomputation)` — state root, envelope
conservation, graph validity, authority conservation, matrix, invariants. Zero CAIN imports.

## 23. Adversarial testing (this session)
12/12 E24 invariants; graph negative test; policy contradiction/gap; risk epistemic segregation;
23/23 E24 tests. Prior corpora (E21–E23) unchanged and passing.

## 24. Performance
E23 control-plane timings recorded; E24 matrix executes 11 compositions (fast, in-process). Per-product
and consensus-plane benchmarks **NOT_MEASURED**.

## 25. Enterprise readiness
Evidence-first tooling, SDK/CLI, offline verifiers, conformance reports. **Not** production-enforced,
**not** multi-host, **not** certified.

## 26. IP composition analysis
See `docs/e24/frontier20_ip_graph.md` and `docs/e24/IP_CANDIDATES.md` (IC-01…IC-14, C-01…C-10).

## 27. Reproduction complexity
See `docs/e24/REPRODUCTION_COMPLEXITY.md`. Essential complexity is real; the moat is cross-layer
agreement + negative knowledge + clean-room verification, not product count.

## 28. Patent / trade-secret candidates
10 candidates listed for counsel; trade-secret potential in the invariant/attack corpora. No legal
conclusion.

## 29. Public-truth classification
See `E24_PUBLIC_TRUTH.md`. Distinguishes LIVE_SHADOW from ENFORCING; same-host from multi-host;
clean-room from third-party.

## 30. Blockers & E25 priorities
1. Multi-host deployment with independent failure domains (unblocks ENFORCING promotion).
2. In-process executors for the remaining 15 products → real composition matrix (targets 20/10/10/5/1).
3. Deep capability / supply-chain / transaction / behavioral / cyber-physical graphs.
4. Distributed soak (1h→72h) and consensus/data-plane benchmarks.
5. Independent third-party verification of the published bundles.
