# CAIN-42 E25 — Baseline (forensic freeze before E25 architecture)

Recorded before E25 changes. E20–E24 status (see each evolution's report for detail):

- **E20** governed state, temporal authorization, invariants I13–I26 — implemented/tested.
- **E21** verifiable state transitions, roots, witness, quorum certificate, replay, I27–I50 —
  implemented/tested; 24/24.
- **E22** governed execution, single-use permits, prepare/commit, certificates, I51–I72 — implemented;
  real RIG→OpenShell executed; **not** on the live enforcement path.
- **E23** distributed execution, 5-product composition, real TCP Byzantine transport (same-host),
  chaos, I73–I96 — implemented; **E22 LIVE_SHADOW** on `/frontier/authorize`; promotion NOT_PROMOTED.
- **E24** shared substrate, composition graph, registry, authority conservation, policy/risk fusion,
  conformance, I97–I108 — implemented; 11 compositions executed; 20/20 conformance.

## Actual enforcement / execution / distribution / composition
- Enforcement: E8 path live; **E22/E23/E24 observe (SHADOW) only**.
- Execution: in-process RIG/OpenShell/MemVault/VIGIL/SCITT real; 15 products conformance-only.
- Distribution: TCP loopback N=4/Q=3 (same host) — **not** multi-host.
- Composition: 11 meaningful compositions executed; full matrix NOT_EXECUTED.

## Known fail-open / fail-closed / races
- E22/E23/E24 primitives fail closed on missing/stale/unknown bindings.
- No known fail-open path in the tested in-process + same-host scope.
- Prepare/commit staleness is handled (abort). No unresolved race discovered in this session.

## Unresolved determinism / deployment
- Real composition replay is `NONDETERMINISTIC_EXTERNAL` (recorded).
- Multi-host, 72-hour soak, and consensus/data-plane benchmarks NOT_MEASURED.

No previous claim is promoted here because it appears in documentation; each is tied to its artifact.
