# CAIN-42 E25 — Final Forensic Report

## 1. Architecture E20–E25
E20 governed state → E21 verifiable transitions → E22 governed execution → E23 distributed Byzantine
execution (LIVE_SHADOW) → E24 shared Frontier substrate → **E25 governed autonomous control fabric**
(post-execution governance + control loop).

## 2–3. New mechanisms & control loop
`cain/e25/control_loop/`: PLAN→AUTHORIZE→EXECUTE→OBSERVE→EVALUATE→ADAPT. The loop compares
intended/authorized/actual action and expected/observed outcome, classifies deviation and consequence,
reassesses authority, and emits a `GovernedControlLoopCertificate`.

## 4. Post-execution governance
`ExecutionOutcome` + deviation classes (`NO/MINOR/POLICY/CAPABILITY/EXECUTION/SECURITY/CONSEQUENCE/
UNKNOWN`); exit-0 is not success; a non-OBSERVED layer cannot be recorded as observed.

## 5. Authority reassessment
`AuthorityReassessmentEngine` — CONTINUE/ATTENUATE/PAUSE/REQUIRE_REAUTHORIZATION/REVOKE/ABORT/RECOVER;
**never grants** authority; `authority_out ⊆ authority_in`.

## 6. Policy lifecycle
DRAFT→ANALYZED→TESTED→CANDIDATE→APPROVED→RELEASED→ACTIVE→SUPERSEDED→REVOKED, evidence per transition;
rollback mints a new version and preserves history.

## 7. Adaptive governance
Observation→evidence→analysis→proposal→review→release; no model self-authorization; the proposer
cannot be its own approver.

## 8–9. Delegation & multi-agent
DELEGATE/ACCEPT/ATTENUATE/REVOKE/EXPIRE/TRANSFER_ATTEMPT; child ⊆ parent, child expiry ≤ parent; a
transfer is an attenuated child, not an inheritance.

## 10–11. Orchestration & composition intelligence
Minimum governance set selected by consequence/risk/context (not every product for every action);
selection cannot exceed granted authority. Full composition-intelligence scoring is E26 work.

## 12–16. Distributed / Byzantine / recovery / soak / adversarial
Reused from E23: real TCP (same-host) fault matrix, recovery attacks caught. **Multi-host, 72-hour
soak and the 25k-scale adversarial campaign are NOT_MEASURED** — targets, not results.

## 17. Invariants I109–I130
22/22 PASS (`E25_INVARIANTS.json`). Runtime checks, not proofs.

## 18. Formalization
Labeled `RUNTIME_CHECK`. No `MODEL_CHECKED`/`FORMALLY_PROVEN` claim is made.

## 19. Clean-room verification
`E25 CONTROL LOOP PROOF VERIFIED (independent recomputation)` — control-loop certificate, outcome hash,
policy-history hash, delegation attenuation, invariant counts, non-authority reassessment. Zero CAIN
imports; standalone `tools/e25/e25_verify.py`.

## 20. Negative knowledge
`docs/e25/NEGATIVE_KNOWLEDGE.md` — 23 documented refusals (NK-01…NK-23), each mapped to a regression test.

## 21. Conformance
E24 profiles (CAIN-F20-CORE/… ) declared; this is conformance, not certification.

## 22–24. IP / reproduction / commercial
See `E25_IP_FORENSIC.md`, `E24` reproduction model, `COMMERCIAL_VALUE.md`.

## 25. Honest limitations
In-process execution; E22 LIVE_SHADOW not enforcing; TCP same-host; full matrix NOT_EXECUTED;
multi-host/soak NOT_MEASURED; no independent third-party verification.

## 26. Unresolved vulnerabilities
None found in tested scope; untested scopes labelled. No known fail-open path.

## 27. E26 priorities
1. Real multi-host (independent failure domains) → unblocks ENFORCING promotion (E23 GATE D/G).
2. In-process executors for the remaining 15 products → real 20/10/10/5/1 matrix.
3. 72-hour governed soak with failure preservation.
4. Composition-intelligence scoring + emergent-behavior study (observed only).
5. Independent third-party verification of the published bundles.
