# CAIN-42 E25 — Negative Knowledge Corpus

Engineering knowledge that is hard to reconstruct from source alone: what was tried and **refused**.

| # | Attack / failure | Affected mechanism | Expected | Observed | Mitigation | Regression |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NK-01 | Grant authority-bearing state without an authorization hash | E20 governed state | refuse | refused | fail-closed on missing authorization | `tests/e20/test_e20_state.py` |
| NK-02 | Relabel a PREDICTED value as OBSERVED without an observation event | E20/E21 fact layers | refuse | refused | fact-layer non-collapse | `tests/e20`, `tests/e21` |
| NK-03 | Execute after the authorization's validity interval | E20/E21 temporal | refuse | refused | I13 | `tests/e21` |
| NK-04 | Forge a state root unreproducible by replay | E21 replay | reject | rejected | recompute proposed root | `tests/e21` |
| NK-05 | Valid signature over a governance-invalid transition | E21 quorum | reject | rejected | cert ≠ validity | E21 byzantine suite |
| NK-06 | Reuse a single-use execution permit | E22 permits | reject | rejected | atomic consume | `tests/e22` |
| NK-07 | Execute against a stale/rolled-back state root | E22 binding | abort | aborted | staleness re-check at commit | `tests/e22` |
| NK-08 | Revoke capability between prepare and commit | E22 | abort | aborted (REVOKED_CAPABILITY) | commit recheck | `E23_CHAOS_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-09 | Change policy between prepare and commit | E22 | abort | aborted | commit recheck | `E23_CHAOS_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-10 | Change tenant between prepare and commit | E22 | abort | aborted | commit recheck | `E23_CHAOS_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-11 | Product failure mid-composition treated as success | E22/E23 | FAILED | FAILED | failure containment | `E23_CHAOS_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-12 | Quorum loss (2/4 replicas) | E23 transport | no authority | quorum not reached | require Q=3 | `E23_DISTRIBUTED_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-13 | Byzantine replica returning a forged root | E23 transport | divergence | 2 distinct roots, no quorum | divergence detection | `E23_DISTRIBUTED_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-14 | Reorder/duplicate/forge/drop a transport message | E23 transport | divergence | divergence detected | HMAC + parent binding | `E23_DISTRIBUTED_RESULTS.json` |
| NK-15 | Observation/evidence/reputation edge grants authority | E24 graph | reject | rejected | typed-edge validation | `tests/e24` |
| NK-16 | Product reaches execution bypassing MCPGate | E24 graph | reject | rejected | bypass rule | `tests/e24` |
| NK-17 | Composition selection exceeds granted authority | E24/E25 | refuse | refused | subset check | `tests/e24`, `tests/e25` |
| NK-18 | Predict/simulate an outcome and record it as observed | E25 control loop | refuse | refused | epistemic guard | `tests/e25` |
| NK-19 | Zero exit code with execution deviation treated as success | E25 | FAILED_DEVIATION | FAILED_DEVIATION | deviation classification | `tests/e25` |
| NK-20 | Adaptive change without review quorum | E25 | blocked | blocked | governed release | `tests/e25` |
| NK-21 | Delegation expands scope or outlives parent | E25 delegation | refuse | refused | subset + expiry clamp | `tests/e25` |
| NK-22 | Policy rollback erases history | E25 policy lifecycle | preserve | preserved | new version, history kept | `tests/e25` |
| NK-23 | Incident response without authorization | E25 governance tx | abort | aborted | authorization required | `tests/e25` |

This corpus is intended as a trade-secret-style asset: reproducing the code without reproducing these
refusals does not reproduce the assurance.
