# E26 — Final Forensic Report

## 1. Architecture E20–E26
E20 state → E21 verifiable transitions → E22 state-bound execution → E23 live governance + transport →
E24 compositional governance → E25 control loop → **E26 Byzantine distributed governance settlement**.

## 2–3. New E26 mechanisms
`cain/e26/`: `GovernanceSettlement` (cryptographically binds the full lifecycle); distributed
`NodeObservation` protocol; epistemic reconciliation; settlement protocol state machine; authority
double-entry accounting; cross-node causal lineage; distributed execution certificate; deterministic
settlement replay; Byzantine control-loop attack lab; multi-process settlement; invariants I131–I160;
zero-import clean-room verifier.

## 4–5. What E26 tested / measured
- **Settlement:** every construction law enforced (stale auth, authority expansion, delegation,
  outcome contradiction, epistemic substitution, unknown-as-known, ambiguous policy, incomplete
  lineage, unresolved evidence, insufficient quorum, unreconciled conflict, history rewrite,
  adaptation authority, recovery resurrection) — all refused.
- **Reconciliation:** majority ≠ truth (predicted majority stays UNRESOLVED; ties ESCALATE).
- **Accounting:** double-entry conservation.
- **Lineage:** 14-kind chain verified; gaps/impossible/temporal/tenant substitutions detected.
- **Adversarial lab:** 32/32 scenarios demonstrate their protected property.
- **Multi-process:** 4 independent OS processes; none valid, Byzantine diverges, drop rejected, forged
  rejected.
- **Invariants:** I131–I160 30/30.
- **Clean-room:** `E26 SETTLEMENT PROOF VERIFIED`; valid bundle PASS, and state/authority/outcome/
  lineage/certificate/observation/epistemic tampering all FAIL.
- **Tests:** 48/48 E26.

## 6. Distributed topology
4 independent OS processes via `multiprocessing.fork`, **same host**. `multi_host = NOT_MEASURED`;
`independent_failure_domains = False`.

## 7. Byzantine scenarios
See `artifacts/e26/E26_ADVERSARIAL_RESULTS.json` (32) and `E26_MULTIPROCESS_RESULTS.json`.

## 8. Invariant results
I131–I160: 30/30 PASS (EXECUTABLE RUNTIME CHECK — **not** formal proof).

## 9. Clean-room result
`tools/e26/e26_verify.py` / `verification/e26/cleanroom/verifier.py` — zero CAIN imports; positive PASS,
all tested tampering FAIL.

## 10. Frontier-20 execution
Reused E24/E25 composition authority envelope; full 20/10/10/5/1 matrix **NOT_EXECUTED** this session.

## 11. E20–E25 regression
224 passed, 4 skipped across tests/e20–e25 (unchanged); plus 48/48 E26.

## 12. Evidence bundle
`artifacts/e26/E26_*`; published to cainstudio/mcpgate (`/proof/bundle/`) and clawx (`/evidence/`).

## 13. IP candidates
E26-IP-01…12 (see `E26_IP_FORENSIC.md`).

## 14. Reproduction barriers
See `REPRODUCTION_COMPLEXITY.md`. Refuse-only construction + cross-layer agreement + epistemic
discipline.

## 15–16. Failures / NOT_MEASURED
- Multi-host settlement — NOT_MEASURED.
- 72-hour distributed soak — NOT_MEASURED.
- Full Frontier-20 composition matrix — NOT_EXECUTED.
- Independent third-party verification — NOT_MEASURED.
No unexplained failure occurred in the tested scope; no test was weakened.

## 17. Blockers to ENFORCING
E23 GATE D (multi-host) and GATE E (distributed soak) remain unmet; therefore E22 stays LIVE_SHADOW.

## 18. Final grade (evidence-based)
**PARTIAL.** Core distributed settlement is implemented, tested, adversarial-lab-covered and
clean-room verified; distributed multi-host, soak and full composition execution are NOT_MEASURED.
