# E86 Acceptance Gates (planned and computed)

Statuses: **PASS**, **PARTIAL**, **FAIL**, **BLOCKED**, **NOT EVALUABLE**.

Every gate records: id, requirement, evidence artifact, test command, expected result, actual
result, status, evidence class, limitations, reproduction instructions. A missing artifact is never
PASS. A local test never satisfies an independent-verification gate.

| ID | Requirement | Evidence | Pass criterion |
|---|---|---|---|
| G01 | E85 baseline reproduced | `artifacts/e86/baseline.json` | 40 tests + 43/43 verifier |
| G02 | E85 history preserved | git ancestry | E85 head is ancestor; no rewrite |
| G03 | Provider-neutral runtime | `artifacts/e86/providers.json` | >=2 local models + deterministic; remote BLOCKED |
| G04 | Remote provider gate honest | `providers.json` | 0 remote calls; BLOCKED without credential |
| G05 | Capability/budget enforcement | tests + artifact | over-budget/unknown provider refused |
| G06 | Durable mission contract | `artifacts/e86/missions.json` | state persisted, illegal transitions refused |
| G07 | Evidence-gated completion | tests | `COMPLETED_VERIFIED` impossible without evidence |
| G08 | Typed memory | `artifacts/e86/memory.json` | 8 categories; provenance fields present |
| G09 | Memory never grants authority | tests | every hit `grants_authority=false` |
| G10 | Cross-tenant isolation | tests | cross-tenant read/write refused |
| G11 | Poisoned memory quarantined | `memory.json` | injection candidate not retrieved |
| G12 | Governed learning pipeline | `artifacts/e86/learning.json` | candidate→validation→external approval→promotion/rollback |
| G13 | Proposer cannot self-approve | tests | self-approval refused |
| G14 | Memory improves measured performance | `artifacts/e86/memory_eval.json` | A/B paired result, reported even if negative |
| G15 | Cross-domain evaluation | `artifacts/e86/eval/summary.json` | 10 families, held-out, raw rows |
| G16 | Paired statistics | summary + verifier | McNemar/Wilson/Holm reported |
| G17 | Single-agent baseline reproduced | eval rows | A_single present |
| G18 | Tool/memory/learning arms | eval rows | each arm has raw rows |
| G19 | Collaboration vs single | summary | paired result, no assumed gain |
| G20 | Workforce identity vs process | `artifacts/e86/workforce.json` | separate counts |
| G21 | Capability-based assignment | tests | wrong capability refused |
| G22 | Delegation attenuation | tests | child expansion refused |
| G23 | Revocation | tests | revoked agent executes nothing |
| G24 | Kill-switch semantics | `artifacts/e86/killswitch.json` | stop-new-work tested; in-flight limitation stated |
| G25 | Three vertical missions | `artifacts/e86/verticals/` | real input, governed tool, verifiable output |
| G26 | External-agent interop | `artifacts/e86/interop.json` | 10-step flow, unauthorized step refused |
| G27 | Effect-bound receipt | `artifacts/e86/interop.json` | receipt verifies; tamper rejected |
| G28 | Offline verifier | `verification.json` | PASS; imports no CAIN code |
| G29 | Tamper rejection | `tamper.json` | modified/removed/added/reordered/re-signed rejected |
| G30 | Acceptance matrix derived from artifacts | `acceptance_matrix.json` | no hard-coded PASS |
| G31 | Security/lab tests | `artifacts/e86/lab.json` | all scenarios blocked, 0 bypass |
| G32 | No secrets in evidence | `lab.json` | secret scan clean |
| G33 | Independent verification | `acceptance_matrix.json` | status NOT PERFORMED unless named external party |
| G34 | Production deployment | `acceptance_matrix.json` | BLOCKED / NOT AUTHORIZED |
| G35 | Release decision reproducible | `release_decision.json` | derived from gate counts |

E86 must not convert a PARTIAL or BLOCKED gate into PASS to improve the count.
