# Evolution 86 — Final Report

**FIRME AI CORPORATION · CAIN-42 · Evolution 86** — branch `evolution-86`, baseline E85 `2bfa45ef7`. Development result; not deployed; not released.

CAIN-42 is a Byzantine trust fabric and the governed operating substrate for increasingly general autonomous intelligence. E86 builds the six planes: intelligence runtime, missions, memory/learning, workforce, verticals, and governance/evidence. **It does not claim that AGI has been achieved, and no external body has certified CAIN-42 as "official AGI infrastructure."**

## What was built

| Plane | Implementation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| A — Intelligence runtime | Provider-neutral runtime over 3 real local models and a frontier adapter; budgets, provenance, fallback (`providers.py`) | IMPLEMENTED / TESTED |
| B — Missions | Durable mission contract, legal state machine, evidence-gated `COMPLETED_VERIFIED`, illegal-edge and self-verification refusal (`mission.py`) | IMPLEMENTED / TESTED |
| C — Memory | Typed memory (8 types), provenance, verification state, injection quarantine, tenant isolation, `grants_authority:false` (`memory.py`) | IMPLEMENTED / TESTED |
| C — Learning | Propose → validate → external approval → promote → monitor → roll back; proposer ≠ approver (`learning.py`) | IMPLEMENTED / TESTED |
| D — Workforce | Agent/Workforce, revocation, scale probe with real processes (`workforce.py`) | IMPLEMENTED / TESTED |
| E — Verticals | Software repair, security review, evidence pack with objective verification (`verticals.py`) | 3/3 PASS |
| F — Interop | External-agent 10-step flow: register → capabilities → authority → mission → decision → execute → evidence → verify receipt → complete → revoke (`interop.py`) | IMPLEMENTED / TESTED |
| F — Kill fence | Atomic epoch read + effect insert in one SQLite transaction (`killfence.py`) | MEASURED |

## What was actually measured

- **Tests:** 43 passed, 0 failed — 14 E86 (foundation + infrastructure), 23 E85, 6 E84.
- **External agent:** registered, received scoped authority, executed through the governed boundary, produced an E84 receipt that verifies with the standalone verifier (`VERIFIED_COMPLETE`), completed a mission only after independent evidence, then was revoked and killed; both later attempts were denied.
- **Kill fence:** 50 real worker processes, 2,000 commits, **109 committed before the stop transaction, 1,891 refused after it, 0 effects after the engage transaction**. The E85 500-worker baseline (328 commits after the engage request, p50 2.56 s) is reported for comparison, not hidden.
- **Verticals:** 3/3 objective checks — software repair (test fails before, passes after, independent test passes), security review (precision 1.0, recall 1.0), evidence pack (tamper detected).
- **Frontier model (E85 suite, Sonnet 5.5):** A_single 36/100, B_learned **65/100**, paired +29, McNemar p=1.3e-7, cost **$0.51**. Local 0.5B 24/100, 1.5B 40/100, learned 25/100.
- **E85 evidence:** signed bundle 43/43; frontier bundle 13/13.

## What improved over E85

1. A working **external-agent SDK** (no longer only CAIN-internal workers).
2. **Evidence-gated mission completion**; a producer cannot verify its own work.
3. A **fenced kill boundary** that removes the check-then-commit window; zero post-stop effects in the lab.
4. **Provider, memory, learning and workforce planes** integrated behind one architecture.
5. A **frontier-model measurement** on the same pre-registered held-out suite.
6. Reusable **developer-facing interfaces** and a signed E86 evidence bundle.

## What did not improve

- No 1,000+ real workers; the measured E86 scale probe is 50 processes (max concurrent 6 in the probe).
- No 6/24/72 h endurance; E85 still provides the only 1 h actual run.
- No independent witness, independent reviewer or third-party audit.
- No hosted MCP proxy emission of E86/E84 receipts; the interop flow is local.
- No customer payment, pilot or production deployment.
- No general intelligence; the frontier result is 65/100 on 100 constructed tasks, one model, one run.

## What remains incomplete or blocked

| Gate | Status | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Independent verification (S) | **BLOCKED** | no independent organization has audited or cosigned |
| 1,000+ workers, 6/24/72 h | **BLOCKED** | host/time limits; E85 500 is PARTIAL |
| Hosted MCP integration | **PARTIAL** | dev sandbox only; production proxy not modified |
| Live production deployment | **BLOCKED** | not authorized |
| Customer demonstration / revenue | **BLOCKED** | no paying counterparty |
| Hardware attestation | **BLOCKED** | no TEE on this host |
| Full cross-domain generalization | **PARTIAL** | 100 constructed tasks, one frontier model |
| Multi-agent collaboration superiority | **PARTIAL** | no statistically significant gain in E85 |

## What was independently verified

- E85 and frontier evidence were re-verified from public signed bundles by their shipped verifiers.
- The E86 bundle is self-contained and offline-verifiable; the verifier imports no CAIN code.
- **No independent party** has examined E86; "independently verified" is not claimed.

## Release decision

**NOT RELEASED.**

The architecture is implemented and measured locally, but independent verification, production MCP integration, long-horizon endurance, 1,000+ worker scale and a customer outcome are not established. Calling this "official AGI infrastructure" would be an unearned claim. The accurate statement is: **CAIN-42 is building the governed infrastructure for AGI, and E86 provides a measured foundation.**

## Single highest-value next milestone

**Put the external-agent flow and the fenced receipt boundary on the live MCPGate path, then run one 1,000-worker fenced endurance mission with an independent witness.** That closes the three gaps that matter: production path, scale, and independence.
