# Evolution 14 — Project Sovereign Launchpad: final report

Generated 2026-10-12T03:35:59Z. Release under test: cain-launchpad 0.14.0, artifact `b18995520a67dc76…`,
built from commit `b6f440bd9eb0e34ece6d1db65701b0edfe964efa` (inputs match the commit).

## Executive summary

CAIN-42's execution path now runs as six kinds of separate OS processes (coordinator, policy, gate, state, evidence
log, four witnesses). Each has its own Ed25519 identity, state directory and socket. Every request and response
between them is signed. The gate re-checks the policy decision and the revocation status itself, so a compromised
coordinator can neither cause an effect nor record one. On one host, this deployment held its safety properties
under 26 injected failures (26 held). Releases are built deterministically,
described by a CycloneDX SBOM and in-toto/SLSA provenance, and signed by two policy-named keys. They are delivered
through The Update Framework's reference client and checked against a release policy before installation:
16/16 update attacks and recovery cases behaved safely, and 13/13
tampered releases were refused. A 72-hour soak of the installed release is **running, not complete**
(0.22 h when this report was generated). **Production release is NOT approved.**

## Answers

1. **Inspected:** Evolutions 1-13 evidence, the four E13 fix sites, the E13 reproduce script, an earlier unfinished
   Evolution 14 attempt (committed legacy modules plus uncommitted service code), the Top-100 registry, and the IP
   register (read only).
2. **Implemented:** separate signed services (finished and debugged from the earlier attempt), a release builder,
   clean-room release/deployment/soak verification, a python-tuf update path with a release-policy gate, a fault lab
   (26 scenarios), an update lab (16), a mutation check for the E13 fixes, a soak
   runner, and paged signed ledgers with windowed audits.
3. **Tests:** E1-E13 regression list 454/454. E13 fix mutation check
   5/5 defects caught. Legacy E14 test file
   12/14: superseded code, failures recorded, not hidden.
4. **Separate services, real network:** yes. Separate processes talk over loopback TCP with signed HTTP. They are
   one host, not separate machines or organizations.
5. **Failure injection:** 26/26 scenarios kept safety. Scenarios where losing
   liveness is by design: b01_gate_killed_after_effect_before_answer, b02_coordinator_killed_between_dispatch_record_and_gate_call, b05_policy_down_means_no_execution, b07_wrong_identity_or_exposed_key_refuses_to_start, c06_two_of_four_witnesses_partitioned, d01_evidence_log_truncated_on_disk, d02_state_database_tampered_and_rolled_back.
6. **Provenance and signatures:** both verify under policy. The builder is the developer host and three-person team holds
   both keys, so this is not SLSA Build L2 and gate F is BLOCKED.
7. **Secure update:** 16/16 (python-tuf 6.0.0).
8. **72-hour soak:** NOT completed (gate L OPEN).
9. **Independent operators:** none (gate J BLOCKED).
10. **Hardware attestation:** none (gate K BLOCKED).
11. **External review:** none (gate P BLOCKED).
12. **Top-100:** ranks 8, 21, 25 and 56 gained capability (product_mapping.json). No products were added.
13. **IP:** this session adds 0 families and makes 0 valuation change. The earlier ip_delta.json is preserved
    unchanged.
14. **Blocked or open gates:** see below.
15. **Reproduce:** `artifacts/evolution14/EVOLUTION14_REPRODUCE.sh`.

## Release labels (independent of each other)

| Label | Value |
|---|---|
| INTERNAL_TESTED | True |
| ADVERSARIALLY_TESTED | True |
| REMEDIATION_VERIFIED | True |
| DEPLOYMENT_DEMONSTRATED_LOCAL | True |
| MULTI_SERVICE_DEPLOYMENT_VERIFIED | True |
| MULTI_HOST_DEPLOYMENT_VERIFIED | False |
| BUILD_PROVENANCE_VERIFIED | PARTIAL: signed local provenance verifies; no hosted builder |
| ARTIFACT_SIGNATURES_VERIFIED | PARTIAL: verified under policy; both keys held by one person |
| SECURE_UPDATE_VERIFIED | True |
| 72_HOUR_SOAK_COMPLETED | False |
| MULTI_OPERATOR_INDEPENDENCE_VERIFIED | False |
| HARDWARE_ATTESTATION_VERIFIED | False |
| EXTERNAL_REVIEW_COMPLETED | False |
| PRODUCTION_RELEASE_APPROVED | False |

## Gates

| Gate | Name | Status | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Historical regression integrity | **PASS** | 454/454 passed |
| B | Evolution 13 defect regression | **PASS** | 5/5 defects caught; F13-05 is a documented protocol limit, not a pass |
| C | Cross-service authorization integrity | **PASS** |  |
| D | Durable recovery and delivery correctness | **PASS** |  |
| E | Artifact and dependency traceability | **PASS** | source repository is private, so an outsider cannot check the commit itself |
| F | Build provenance and signature verification | **BLOCKED** | signatures and policy verify (13/13 tampers refused), but the builder is the developer host: no hosted build service, keys held by one person |
| G | Secure update and rollback resistance | **PASS** | 16/16 scenarios |
| H | Deployment and network-failure behavior | **PASS** | 26/26 on ONE host |
| I | Evidence verification | **PASS** | same project wrote verifier and producer |
| J | Operator independence | **BLOCKED** | one owner, one host; no second operator exists |
| K | Hardware-backed attestation | **BLOCKED** | no TEE-capable host |
| L | Completed 72-hour soak | **OPEN** | running since 2026-10-12 03:23Z; 0.22 h so far |
| M | Observability and incident response | **PASS** | local only; no alert delivery (paging) is wired |
| N | Top-100 product mapping | **PASS** |  |
| O | IP register integrity | **PASS** | this session adds 0 families and changes no figure |
| P | External assurance | **BLOCKED** | no engagement has taken place |
| Q | Production deployment approval | **BLOCKED** | F, J, K, L, P are not PASS |

## Defects found and fixed in this evolution

F14-01 through F14-06 are described in evolution13_regression.json → hardening_found_in_this_evolution. The most
important: the witness and checkpoint store used to accept log growth without a consistency proof unless the caller
opted in. Rejection is now the default.
