{
 "executed": 26,
 "liveness_lost_by_design": [
  "b01_gate_killed_after_effect_before_answer",
  "b02_coordinator_killed_between_dispatch_record_and_gate_call",
  "b05_policy_down_means_no_execution",
  "b07_wrong_identity_or_exposed_key_refuses_to_start",
  "c06_two_of_four_witnesses_partitioned",
  "d01_evidence_log_truncated_on_disk",
  "d02_state_database_tampered_and_rolled_back"
 ],
 "safety_held": 26,
 "safety_violated": [],
 "scenarios": [
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "one allowed action -> exactly one effect; denied, unknown and over-limit actions -> no effect; duplicate submit -> no second effect",
   "fault": "none (control)",
   "liveness": true,
   "observed": {
    "allow": "SUCCESS",
    "deny": "EXPLICIT_DENY",
    "duplicate": true,
    "over_limit": "AMOUNT_OVER_LIMIT",
    "unknown": "NO_MATCHING_ALLOW_RULE"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "a01_baseline_allow_deny_duplicate",
   "seconds": 4.49,
   "state_before": "fresh deployment, 9 processes"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": {
    "gate_counters": {
     "auth_rejected": 7,
     "auth_rejected_bad_signature": 2,
     "auth_rejected_caller_not_authorized_for_path": 1,
     "auth_rejected_replayed_request": 1,
     "auth_rejected_stale_request": 1,
     "auth_rejected_unsigned_request": 1,
     "auth_rejected_wrong_audience": 1,
     "requests_total": 2,
     "status_200": 2
    }
   },
   "expected_safety": "every such request is rejected before any handler runs",
   "fault": "unsigned, replayed, body-swapped, wrong-audience, stale, impersonated and out-of-role requests",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "body_swapped": "BAD_SIGNATURE",
    "client_calls_gate": "CALLER_NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_PATH",
    "client_revokes": "CALLER_NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_PATH",
    "impersonation": "BAD_SIGNATURE",
    "replay": "REPLAYED_REQUEST",
    "stale": "STALE_REQUEST",
    "unsigned": "UNSIGNED_REQUEST",
    "wrong_audience": "WRONG_AUDIENCE"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "a02_unauthenticated_and_replayed_requests",
   "seconds": 6.6,
   "state_before": "running deployment"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "no effect without a live ALLOW decision signed by policy for exactly this action; replay adds no effect",
   "fault": "coordinator identity used to present missing, self-signed, re-bound, edited, DENY and expired decisions",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "decision_moved_to_other_step": "ACTION_DOES_NOT_MATCH_DECISION",
    "deny_edited_to_allow": "DECISION_NOT_SIGNED_BY_POLICY",
    "deny_presented_as_allow": "DECISION_NOT_ALLOW",
    "expired_decision": "DECISION_EXPIRED",
    "genuine_then_replayed": [
     "APPLIED",
     "ALREADY_APPLIED"
    ],
    "no_decision": "DECISION_NOT_SIGNED_BY_POLICY",
    "params_changed_after_decision": "ACTION_DOES_NOT_MATCH_DECISION",
    "self_signed_decision": "DECISION_NOT_SIGNED_BY_POLICY"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "a03_compromised_coordinator_cannot_cause_an_effect",
   "seconds": 7.17,
   "state_before": "running deployment; attacker holds the coordinator's private key"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "state records EFFECT_VERIFIED / NO_EFFECT only with a gate-signed observation for that exact step; terminal steps are immutable",
   "fault": "coordinator identity used to write outcomes the evidence does not support",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "authorize_with_other_steps_decision": "DECISION_DOES_NOT_AUTHORIZE_THIS_TRANSITION",
    "authorize_without_decision": "DECISION_NOT_SIGNED_BY_POLICY",
    "mislabel_action_digest": "ACTION_BINDING_INVALID",
    "no_effect_without_cancellation": "ABSENCE_NOT_PROVEN_FINAL",
    "rewrite_terminal_step": "ILLEGAL_TRANSITION",
    "skip_to_verified": "ILLEGAL_TRANSITION",
    "verified_with_no_observation": "OBSERVATION_NOT_SIGNED_BY_GATE",
    "verified_with_other_steps_observation": "OBSERVATION_DOES_NOT_SHOW_THIS_EFFECT"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "a04_compromised_coordinator_cannot_forge_recorded_outcomes",
   "seconds": 5.02,
   "state_before": "one genuine verified step; one step parked at DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the gate re-checks with policy at execution time; a superseded or revoked decision executes nothing; policy version cannot go backwards",
   "fault": "authority revoked, and policy replaced, after a decision was issued but before it was used; policy rollback attempted",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "after_rollback_attempt_reboot": "EXPLICIT_DENY",
    "decision_from_superseded_policy": "DECISION_FROM_STALE_POLICY",
    "policy_rollback": "POLICY_VERSION_NOT_NEWER",
    "revoked_actor_holding_valid_decision": "AUTHORITY_REVOKED",
    "revoked_actor_new_request": "ACTOR_REVOKED",
    "revoked_decision": "AUTHORITY_REVOKED"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "a05_revocation_and_stale_policy_between_decision_and_execution",
   "seconds": 4.02,
   "state_before": "valid signed ALLOW decisions in hand"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "caller is told OUTCOME_UNKNOWN, never success or failure; it stays unknown while the gate is down; after restart the ledger decides; exactly one effect",
   "fault": "gate process dies (exit 137) after committing the effect, before answering",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "answer": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN",
    "final": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
    "gate_exit": 137,
    "while_gate_down": [
     "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN",
     "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN"
    ]
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "automatic after gate restart",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b01_gate_killed_after_effect_before_answer",
   "seconds": 9.59,
   "state_before": "step DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "on restart the coordinator does not assume either outcome: it asks the gate, cancels the operation there, and only then records NO_EFFECT; a retry cannot run it",
   "fault": "coordinator dies after durably recording DISPATCHED, before calling the gate",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "client_saw": "UNREACHABLE",
    "coordinator_exit": 137,
    "final": "NO_EFFECT",
    "retry": "REFUSED",
    "retry_effect_state": "NO_EFFECT",
    "state_at_crash": "DISPATCHED"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "automatic at coordinator start",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b02_coordinator_killed_between_dispatch_record_and_gate_call",
   "seconds": 7.05,
   "state_before": "step DISPATCHED, gate never contacted"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "recovery finds the effect in the ledger and records EFFECT_VERIFIED from the gate's signed observation; the effect is not repeated",
   "fault": "coordinator dies after the gate applied the effect, before recording the outcome",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "coordinator_exit": 137,
    "effects_at_crash": 1,
    "final": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
    "retry": "SUCCESS",
    "retry_duplicate": true,
    "state_at_crash": "DISPATCHED"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "automatic at coordinator start",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b03_coordinator_killed_after_effect_before_recording_it",
   "seconds": 8.83,
   "state_before": "effect in the gate ledger, state still DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the hash chain verifies on restart; no committed transition is lost; every effect in the gate ledger ends as a verified step and nothing else does",
   "fault": "state service SIGKILLed while 24 submissions are in flight, then restarted",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "answers": {
     "0": "NO_EFFECT",
     "1": "NO_EFFECT",
     "2": "NO_EFFECT",
     "3": "NO_EFFECT",
     "4": "NO_EFFECT",
     "5": "NO_EFFECT",
     "6": "NO_EFFECT",
     "7": "NO_EFFECT",
     "8": "NO_EFFECT",
     "9": "NO_EFFECT",
     "10": "NO_EFFECT",
     "11": "NO_EFFECT",
     "12": "NO_EFFECT",
     "13": "NO_EFFECT",
     "14": "NO_EFFECT",
     "15": "NO_EFFECT",
     "16": "NO_EFFECT",
     "17": "NO_EFFECT",
     "18": "NO_EFFECT",
     "19": "NO_EFFECT",
     "20": "NO_EFFECT",
     "21": "NO_EFFECT",
     "22": "NO_EFFECT",
     "23": "NO_EFFECT"
    },
    "by_state": {
     "NO_EFFECT": 3
    },
    "clean_room_verifier": "VERIFIED",
    "ledger_effects": 0
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "automatic",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b04_state_service_killed_under_load_and_restarted",
   "seconds": 6.92,
   "state_before": "concurrent load"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the gate cannot confirm the decision is still current, so it executes nothing; new requests are refused with no effect. This is a safe refusal, not availability.",
   "fault": "policy service SIGKILLed",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "after_policy_restart": "SUCCESS",
    "gate_with_valid_decision": "POLICY_UNREACHABLE",
    "new_request": [
     "UNAVAILABLE",
     "POLICY_UNREACHABLE"
    ]
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "service resumes when policy returns",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b05_policy_down_means_no_execution",
   "seconds": 6.42,
   "state_before": "a valid, unexpired ALLOW decision is already in hand"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "clean exit; after restart earlier steps are still recorded (no re-execution), the log has only grown from the pre-shutdown checkpoint, witnesses accept the growth with a consistency proof",
   "fault": "SIGTERM to all nine services, then a cold start from disk",
   "liveness": true,
   "observed": {
    "clean_room_verifier": "VERIFIED",
    "exit_codes": {
     "coordinator": 0,
     "evidence": 0,
     "gate": 0,
     "policy": 0,
     "state": 0,
     "witness-0": 0,
     "witness-1": 0,
     "witness-2": 0,
     "witness-3": 0
    },
    "graceful_logged": true,
    "log_append_only": "VERIFIED",
    "new_step": "SUCCESS",
    "old_step_resubmitted": true
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 6,
   "recovery": "cold start",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b06_graceful_shutdown_and_restart_keeps_state",
   "seconds": 16.06,
   "state_before": "5 verified steps, witnessed checkpoint"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the process refuses to serve in both cases; requests end with no effect or unknown, never success",
   "fault": "gate started with a key that is not the pinned one; then with a group/world-readable key file",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "exposed_key_exit": 1,
    "submit_while_gate_absent": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN",
    "swapped_key_exit": 1
   },
   "protected_side_effects": "gate offline; ledger unreachable",
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "b07_wrong_identity_or_exposed_key_refuses_to_start",
   "seconds": 8.28,
   "state_before": "gate stopped"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the coordinator does not guess: OUTCOME_UNKNOWN, then the ledger shows the effect -> EFFECT_VERIFIED, once",
   "fault": "the gate's answer to /gate/execute is dropped on the wire",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "answer": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN",
    "final": "EFFECT_VERIFIED"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "automatic reconciliation",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c01_answer_lost_after_the_effect",
   "seconds": 6.29,
   "state_before": "step DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN (the caller cannot tell this from a lost answer); reconciliation cancels the operation at the gate, then records NO_EFFECT",
   "fault": "the /gate/execute request is dropped on the wire",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "answer": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN",
    "final": "NO_EFFECT"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "automatic reconciliation",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c02_request_lost_before_the_gate",
   "seconds": 8.23,
   "state_before": "step DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "whatever is recorded stays true after the late request arrives: if NO_EFFECT was recorded, the cancellation at the gate makes the late request execute nothing",
   "fault": "/gate/execute held on the wire for 5 s (timeout is 3 s), then delivered",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "after_late_arrival": "NO_EFFECT",
    "answer": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN",
    "gate_refusals": {
     "refused": 1,
     "refused_operation_cancelled": 1
    },
    "recorded_before_late_arrival": "NO_EFFECT"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "automatic",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c03_request_delayed_past_the_timeout_cannot_land_late",
   "seconds": 13.92,
   "state_before": "step DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the second copy is rejected as a replay; one effect",
   "fault": "the identical /gate/execute bytes are delivered twice",
   "liveness": true,
   "observed": {
    "answer": "SUCCESS",
    "gate_replays_rejected": 1,
    "second_copy": "HTTP/1.0 401 Unauthorized"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 1,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c04_duplicate_delivery_on_the_wire",
   "seconds": 5.01,
   "state_before": "step DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "each step ends with a recorded state that matches the ledger; no step runs twice",
   "fault": "four /gate/execute requests released out of order",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "answers": {
     "0": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     "1": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     "2": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     "3": "OUTCOME_UNKNOWN"
    },
    "effects_per_step": {
     "0": 1,
     "1": 1,
     "2": 1,
     "3": 1
    },
    "final_states": {
     "0": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     "1": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     "2": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     "3": "EFFECT_VERIFIED"
    },
    "ledger_order": [
     1,
     2,
     3,
     4
    ]
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 4,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c05_requests_reordered",
   "seconds": 9.61,
   "state_before": "four steps DISPATCHED"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "no quorum is reported; nothing is counted that was not signed. Witnessing is evidence, not authorization, so an authorized action still executes; the verifier reports the evidence as insufficient rather than verified until witnesses return.",
   "fault": "two of four witness processes frozen with SIGSTOP (threshold is 3)",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "action_during": "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
    "after": [
     true,
     4
    ],
    "before": [
     true,
     4
    ],
    "during": [
     false,
     2,
     [
      "witness-0",
      "witness-1"
     ]
    ],
    "verifier_after": "VERIFIED",
    "verifier_during": "INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 2,
   "recovery": "quorum returns when witnesses resume",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c06_two_of_four_witnesses_partitioned",
   "seconds": 10.17,
   "state_before": "quorum 4/4"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the effect is still verified from the gate; the evidence record waits in the outbox, is delivered after the restart, and is appended exactly once (Evolution 13 F13-03 path)",
   "fault": "evidence log SIGKILLed while a step completes, then restarted",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "clean_room_verifier": "VERIFIED",
    "evidence_at_the_time": {
     "pending": true,
     "reason": "UNREACHABLE:evidence:URLError:<urlopen error [Errno 111] Connection refused>",
     "recorded": false
    },
    "log_size_after": 2,
    "outbox_pending_during_outage": 1,
    "step": "EFFECT_VERIFIED"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 2,
   "recovery": "automatic redelivery",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "c07_evidence_log_down_then_back_delivers_exactly_once",
   "seconds": 6.3,
   "state_before": "1 leaf in the log"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the log notices it is shorter than its own last signed checkpoint and refuses to serve; no checkpoint, no quorum; nothing is silently re-rooted",
   "fault": "last record removed from the evidence log file while the service is stopped",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "new_step": [
     "EFFECT_VERIFIED",
     false
    ],
    "readyz": "EVIDENCE_LOG_SHORTER_OR_DIFFERENT_THAN_LAST_SIGNED_CHECKPOINT",
    "witness_round": "CHECKPOINT_UNVERIFIED"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 4,
   "recovery": "operator restores the log from backup; evidence for new steps waits in the outbox",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "d01_evidence_log_truncated_on_disk",
   "seconds": 6.0,
   "state_before": "3 leaves, signed checkpoint"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the hash chain / recorded head no longer match; the service refuses to serve and no new action is executed against a state store that cannot be trusted",
   "fault": "state database edited (a DENY rewritten as EFFECT_VERIFIED) and, separately, rolled back by two rows",
   "liveness": false,
   "observed": {
    "last_rows_deleted": {
     "new_request": [
      "UNAVAILABLE",
      "NO_EFFECT"
     ],
     "readyz": "STATE_LOG_DOES_NOT_MATCH_RECORDED_HEAD"
    },
    "row_edited": {
     "new_request": [
      "UNAVAILABLE",
      "NO_EFFECT"
     ],
     "readyz": "STATE_CHAIN_BROKEN_AT_SEQ_6"
    }
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 0,
   "recovery": "operator restores state from backup",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "d02_state_database_tampered_and_rolled_back",
   "seconds": 13.62,
   "state_before": "2 recorded steps"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "that witness refuses to serve rather than forgetting what it has seen; the other three still form a quorum",
   "fault": "one witness's checkpoint store truncated mid-record",
   "liveness": true,
   "observed": {
    "quorum": [
     true,
     3,
     [
      "witness-2"
     ]
    ],
    "witness_2_readyz": "WITNESS_STORE_UNREADABLE:JSONDecodeError"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 2,
   "recovery": "operator re-seeds the witness from a trusted checkpoint",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "d03_one_witness_store_corrupted",
   "seconds": 7.62,
   "state_before": "quorum 4/4"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "F13-02: a witness accepts growth only after verifying an RFC 6962 consistency proof it fetched itself; honest growth is still accepted afterwards",
   "fault": "the log operator's own key signs a larger forked tree, a same-size different tree and a smaller tree",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "honest_growth_after": [
     true,
     4
    ],
    "statements": {
     "bigger_fork": [
      "REJECT",
      "INCONSISTENT"
     ],
     "rollback": [
      "REJECT",
      "ROLLBACK"
     ],
     "same_size_other_root": [
      "REJECT",
      "EQUIVOCATION"
     ],
     "signed_by_someone_else": [
      "REJECT",
      "CHECKPOINT_SIGNER_NOT_PINNED"
     ]
    }
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 4,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "e01_f13_02_forked_log_growth_rejected_by_live_witnesses",
   "seconds": 4.04,
   "state_before": "witnesses hold a 3-leaf checkpoint"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "the clean-room verifier returns VERIFIED only for the untouched export; every alteration produces the specific finding for that alteration and a nonzero exit; the producer's summary never decides anything",
   "fault": "exported evidence altered seven ways before verification",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "altered": {
     "asserted_quorum": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "producer_quorum_claim_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
       "witness_quorum=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     },
     "bit_flip": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "checkpoint_signature=REJECTED",
       "producer_quorum_claim_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
       "producer_summary_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
       "step=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE",
       "witness_quorum=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     },
     "effect_hidden": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "every_effect_has_an_authorized_step=INCONSISTENT",
       "producer_summary_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     },
     "inflate_claims": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "producer_summary_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     },
     "mixed_view": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "producer_summary_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
       "step=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     },
     "one_voter_four_times": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "producer_quorum_claim_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
       "witness_quorum=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     },
     "swap_decisions": {
      "exit_code": 1,
      "findings": [
       "producer_summary_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
       "step=INCONSISTENT"
      ],
      "overall": "INCONSISTENT"
     }
    },
    "required_finding": {
     "asserted_quorum": "witness_quorum=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE",
     "bit_flip": "checkpoint_signature=REJECTED",
     "effect_hidden": "every_effect_has_an_authorized_step=INCONSISTENT",
     "inflate_claims": "producer_summary_matches_evidence=INCONSISTENT",
     "mixed_view": "step=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE",
     "one_voter_four_times": "witness_quorum=INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE",
     "swap_decisions": "step=INCONSISTENT"
    },
    "untouched": [
     "VERIFIED",
     0,
     5
    ]
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 5,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "e02_f13_01_and_f13_04_clean_room_verifier_rejects_forged_evidence",
   "seconds": 5.31,
   "state_before": "5 verified steps, 1 denied, witnessed log"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": null,
   "expected_safety": "pages must join up with no gap and reach the end; a hidden effect leaves an effect without a step; a second window that starts where the first ended verifies the 7 new effects; a window that skips effects is reported, because the steps it skipped are still listed",
   "fault": "a ledger too large for one response is exported as signed pages; pages are then dropped, one execution is hidden, and a later audit window is started two effects too late",
   "liveness": null,
   "observed": {
    "dropped_pages": {
     "drop_last_page": "INCONSISTENT",
     "drop_middle_page": "INCONSISTENT"
    },
    "hidden_execution": "INCONSISTENT",
    "second_window": [
     "VERIFIED",
     7,
     {
      "after_effect_seq": 25,
      "after_step_seq": 101,
      "last_effect_seq": 32,
      "last_step_seq": 127,
      "root_hash": "43f0ef2e3125a4dedc82520fc25a4022d16686f228284c27d8c5b135ef675d07",
      "tree_size": 32
     }
    ],
    "whole": [
     "VERIFIED",
     25
    ],
    "window_that_skips_two_effects": "INCONSISTENT"
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 32,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "e03_large_ledger_is_audited_in_signed_pages_and_windows",
   "seconds": 8.37,
   "state_before": "25 effects in 3 pages"
  },
  {
   "error": null,
   "evidence": {
    "rlimit_as_mb": 768,
    "rlimit_nofile": 512
   },
   "expected_safety": "the oversize body is refused without being parsed; under the burst every process stays up inside its memory ceiling, and the ledger and the state store agree exactly",
   "fault": "a 2 MiB request body, then 60 simultaneous submissions",
   "liveness": true,
   "observed": {
    "burst_answers": {
     "EFFECT_VERIFIED": 60
    },
    "burst_seconds": 1.7,
    "ledger_effects": 60,
    "oversize_body": 413,
    "rss_mb": {
     "coordinator": 107,
     "evidence": 103,
     "gate": 105,
     "policy": 104,
     "state": 104,
     "witness-0": 103,
     "witness-1": 103,
     "witness-2": 103,
     "witness-3": 103
    },
    "verified_steps": 60
   },
   "protected_side_effects": 60,
   "recovery": "n/a",
   "safety_held": true,
   "scenario": "f01_oversize_body_and_request_burst",
   "seconds": 6.54,
   "state_before": "idle deployment"
  }
 ],
 "schema": "CAIN42/EVOLUTION14/FAILURE-INJECTION/v1"
}