# Evolution 2 — limitations (preserved, not hidden)

1. **No production replication.** The quorum module (`cain_contract_quorum.py`) is tested with in-process replicas
   behind a fault-injecting transport, for N = 1, 3, 4, 7 and 10, under crash and Byzantine faults. The gateway does
   not use it. Production consistency is SQLite on one host, shared by the blue and green processes. That host is a
   single point of failure for contract state.
2. **Online trust root.** The contract root key defaults to `/root/.cain-contract-root/root_ed25519.pem` on the
   gateway host. A host compromise is therefore a root compromise. There is no HSM, TPM or enclave.
3. **Self-asserted time.** Signers assert their own signing times. Only SCITT inclusion gives an external time
   reference.
4. **Revocation can only be proven by presence.** Offline, a verifier sees revocations that are present. It cannot
   prove that none exists. Check SCITT or the live API for that.
5. **Contracts are an additional governed path, not the only one.** The products' direct routes still exist. OpenShell
   execute is operator-only; MemVault and SCITT writes need a tenant key. Making contracts mandatory for a tenant is
   not done.
6. **E8 is per tenant.** The E8 instance belongs to the tenant fabric and is separate from the hosted MCP E8 gate.
   The kernel keeps an in-memory evidence list that grows for the life of the process. This is pre-existing kernel
   behaviour; the durable record is the receipt chain plus SCITT.
7. **Concurrency throughput is bounded by SQLite.** With 8 threads, invoke throughput is about 36/s and p99 is
   about 1.3 s on this host (PERFORMANCE.json). The decision transaction serializes per tenant database.
8. **Scope is 4 of the 20 Frontier products.** The other 16 do not consult contracts
   (FRONTIER20_CONTRACT_INTEGRATION.json). Several have no real substrate yet (no CAN/ROS bus, no CXL hardware, no
   gossip network).
9. **The SDK module is unreleased.** The published `cainstudio` is 0.5.0, without `contracts`.
10. **The clean-room verifier is not independent in authorship.** It has no CAIN imports, but the same AI author wrote
    it from the same specification. It proves structure, signatures, chains and replay. It does not prove that an
    action was safe.
11. **Not a legal or valuation opinion.** Patent and IP notes are hypotheses that need counsel and a prior-art search.
