# EVOLUTION7_FORENSIC_BASELINE.md

**Evolution 7 of 42 — Project Sovereign Action Commit**
**Baseline commit:** `4b16f6b0cd73000afb7088ac0b7d17436cffa1c3`
**Method:** inspect first; classify each important prior claim; never silently upgrade a classification.

## A. Evolution 1–6 baseline reproduction

- `pytest` across the 11 Evolution 1–6 test files: **222 passed** on this checkout (`TEST_REPRODUCED (B)`).
- The Evolution 6 final report's "222 PASSED" is reproducible. Its commercial and soak claims are not.

## B. Claim-by-claim classification (do not conflate categories)

| Claim | Class | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 222 tests pass | **B. TEST-REPRODUCED** | 222 passed in 7.33s on this checkout |
| 72-hour multi-region soak PASSED | **F. NOT VERIFIED** | no soak artifact with machine-verifiable start/end times or continuous workload was found in artifacts/evolution6; only prose in the final report |
| hardware-backed attestation (SEV-SNP/TDX/Nitro) | **E. SIMULATED / FIXTURE-ONLY** | cain/isolation/attestation.py defines provider constants and refuses SOFTWARE_SIMULATED-as-hardware, but makes no live provider/ioctl/HTTP call; no TEE on this host (/dev/kvm ABSENT) |
| N>=3f+1 independent validator processes | **E/G. CONTRADICTED (single process)** | cain/isolation/byzantine_settlement.py defines SettlementValidatorNode/ByzantineSettlementCluster as Python objects; no subprocess/multiprocessing/socket; failure domains are not independent |
| hardened sandbox | **A/B. SOURCE-INSPECTED / TEST-REPRODUCED (process-level)** | cain/isolation/sandbox.py executes via subprocess.run with resource limits; it is OS process isolation, NOT hardware/TEE isolation |
| 3 paying customers / $193 | **F. NOT VERIFIED (contradicts AGENTS.md)** | AGENTS.md permanent memory records 2 customers, $97 founder-attested; the E6 report's '3 customers / $193' is not independently corroborated |
| FIRME AI appraised $15.4M | **F. NOT AN APPRAISAL** | self-labelled internal analytical scenario; no third party; not a valuation |

Classes: **A** source-inspected · **B** test-reproduced · **C** independently verified · **D** live-infrastructure verified ·
**E** simulated/fixture-only · **F** not verified · **G** contradicted by observed evidence.

## C. What Evolution 7 therefore must (and must not) assume

- It MUST NOT assume hardware attestation, an independent multi-process quorum, or a passed 72h soak.
- It MUST build on the parts that are real: C AIN identity/authority, `cain.mcp_proxy` enforcement, the process sandbox,
  and the clean-room verifier pattern.
- It MUST keep new enforcement RESTRICTION_ONLY until evidence supports more.
