# Byzantine Autonomous State Fabric — IP Candidate Register

**Engineering inventory only. No legal patentability, novelty or valuation determination. Prior-art
search and professional counsel required.** Prior art is strong (state-machine replication, Merkle
state commitments, PBFT commit certificates, CRDTs, provenance graphs, trust/reputation systems).

| ID | Name | Problem → mechanism | Differentiation | Evidence | Prior-art questions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S-IP-01 | Canonical 21-dimension governance state with deterministic state root | governance state spread across unrelated stores → one canonical state + RFC-8785 state root | one commitment over all governance dimensions | `artifacts/govkernel/STATE_PROOF.json` | state-machine replication prior art |
| S-IP-02 | Quorum-gated state transition machine (PROPOSE→…→EVIDENCE) | unilateral state creation → every commit requires a valid quorum certificate | stage log + fail-closed guards | `E03S_GATE_RESULTS.json` | PBFT commit prior art |
| S-IP-03 | Conflicting-realities reconciliation (FACT/OBSERVATION/CLAIM/PROPOSAL/DECISION/COMMITMENT) | unverified observation silently becomes state → typed reconciliation that never promotes unverified to authoritative | epistemic typing + conflict surfacing | `E03S_GATE_RESULTS.json` | oracle/consensus prior art |
| S-IP-04 | Agent behavior consistency layer | agents misreport outcomes → PROPOSED/AUTHORIZED/EXECUTED/OBSERVED/REPORTED comparison | five-way discrepancy evidence | `E03S_GATE_RESULTS.json` | observability prior art |
| S-IP-05 | Governed memory layering (UNVERIFIED→…→AUTHORITATIVE) | memory silently becomes authority → layered promotion with evidence/quorum gates | memory never authority | `E03S_GATE_RESULTS.json` | memory-provenance prior art |
| S-IP-06 | Evidence-gated trust transitions | trust rises on a claim → verified-evidence/quorum-gated increases | claim cannot raise trust | `E03S_GATE_RESULTS.json` | reputation-system prior art |
| S-IP-07 | Fail-closed incident containment + recovery-no-self-authorize | Byzantine behavior uncontained → staged containment with emergency halt and verified recovery | containment + recovery safety | `E03S_GATE_RESULTS.json` | incident-response prior art |

## Trade-secret candidates
The negative-knowledge corpus (S-01…S-12 + the authority/Byzantine attack matrices) and the specific
fail-closed ordering are better protected as trade secrets than disclosed.
