# CAIN42 — Patent Collision Analysis (Prompt 13)

> **Not legal advice. No patent filed. No freedom-to-operate opinion.** Colours are a self-assessment of overlap
> risk for engineering triage only; a professional prior-art search and counsel review are required before any
> proprietary claim.

| Mechanism | Colour | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Effect contract (authority bound to intended effect) | YELLOW | authorization + capability systems exist; effect-binding formulation less common |
| Effect fingerprint | GREEN | deterministic intended/realized comparison is not a known product category |
| Two-phase effect commit | ORANGE | two-phase commit / saga / outbox are decades old; the novelty would be the agent-authority binding |
| In-doubt resolution without blind retry | YELLOW | distributed transactions address in-doubt; agent framing differs |
| Reversibility-aware authority | YELLOW | risk-adaptive authz exists; reversibility classes as authority primitive less common |
| Compensation graph authority-bound | ORANGE | compensating transactions / sagas are prior art; authority-bound recovery is the differentiator |
| Causal effect graph | YELLOW | provenance/lineage graphs exist; authority-to-effect chain differs |
| Verified effect receipt | YELLOW | receipts/attestations exist; effect-bound receipt differs |
| Idempotency duplication defense | ORANGE | idempotency keys are standard |
| Effect evidence independence | GREEN | correlated-evidence independence as an authority gate is differentiated |
| Temporal effect validity | ORANGE | TTLs / token expiry are standard |
| Human oversight budget | GREEN | escalation-fatigue routing is differentiated |
| Physical effect adapter | ORANGE | sim-to-real verification is a broad robotics field |
| Economic effect contract | ORANGE | payment authorization is crowded |

**RED = high overlap / do not market as proprietary without professional review.** No item is currently RED, but
oranges require counsel review before any proprietary claim.
