{
 "base_view": 0,
 "bundle_type": "CAIN42/PBFT/BYZANTINE-EVIDENCE/v1",
 "byzantine_mode": "equivocate",
 "byzantine_node": "qcbz-node-1",
 "byzantine_node_status": {
  "commit_index": 14,
  "health_state": "BYZANTINE_SUSPECTED",
  "is_primary": false,
  "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
  "view": 1
 },
 "classification": "MEASURED on a disposable 4-container cluster on one host",
 "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
 "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
 "generated_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:32Z",
 "height": 14,
 "honest_nodes": [
  "qcbz-node-2",
  "qcbz-node-3",
  "qcbz-node-4"
 ],
 "membership": {
  "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
  "domain": "CAIN42/PBFT/MEMBERSHIP/v1",
  "epoch": 1,
  "f": 1,
  "members": [
   {
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
    "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk="
   },
   {
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-2",
    "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc="
   },
   {
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-3",
    "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M="
   },
   {
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-4",
    "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew="
   }
  ],
  "n": 4,
  "protocol": "PBFT/Castro-Liskov-1999+CAIN-Hardened",
  "quorum": 3,
  "view_change_join": 2,
  "watermark_window": 100
 },
 "nodes": {
  "qcbz-node-2": {
   "application_state_hash": "7b087245556ee965e477e02979865ee25d45fd813728d74b11f0a027bdf55793",
   "commit_index": 14,
   "commit_qcs": [
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "65f34f4d0ffec9bdf38f5e43dc2550d60f21f7b8f35805af4606b302bae03cfb",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "ae2468e7d4244e50b35ab6551d5dcca8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ef3eaf99911ee7369692a1aca1500db502f53e6347e9f1e0a0fb9a6f5fa0211",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "IWNUQryGKeEQ3Fj80o7KYnzNskpGuMYZ7tMfxKy4bEf1CDrBsjQ8h1pfXYwtO9muV0GhDyJXoXsoa7bWoYU9Dw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7112405,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "4d0ea41bded74b46b3808a08f346fa12",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "389898505222d559349b1a692daf025bfd01dda78305351c59c0b3b539d27d7f",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "MiJ3Doz8X4kv6F+qu4xDPMmSUQHEbBiLvIWOquwbOcVsa96BBnKYjBoRJeBHNXFh/MSNgH2akt5K+xY9Us6vDw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7313712,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "44763f3765704feaa9b87a44663a414e",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "2dfd206de6d3016125165f1943ae5c1046bb4cc5aa0adf0fa1eb859c99fcbee1",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "qMK2Txfti/QeLn1Eo7Xd372DeUX1pgypIYLrBN2bEijdISFPSOAW1aAaNnod0KNhPB8BFWODkHSWf6Q4PDvrBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7313783,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "65f34f4d0ffec9bdf38f5e43dc2550d60f21f7b8f35805af4606b302bae03cfb",
     "certificate_hash": "f6d1e94d4ec1266cd850773cfadc1fed3ffc5094a0f0d04ae1684e19e8651892",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "d7da1ea278f1c35939d1305258b658b3392e536c68dfbb3e4b1386b2ccd7695b",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "ba6446e1e5d78ada78e3c8b7a70f54af21c37a75708b849c0b3235f03308100d",
     "proposal_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 1,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "fed9cc4231847c2a0c5102da2a79103ff18ef105ce95785dae264959ea2cf984",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "89f7375106db428ba0d87c6df99a5948",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "edb815bda869f126bdcc5d712c73b0be3c106b608bddf086557b3aef1cd19935",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "8tOaqJDJUCyoFd03DZPR4M3H8TopV0vDeoZ+6w2pkfJgx+Wp/neaOAdjmO0FjsKX6hF3OwzUvct3n06VFZG8Bw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.1033826,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "08d43851a3724a9fa4d4902ef5882bb7",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "b6f27890616393d289ee7e4b5128252f726799f9c71bfbfdf47ac6e8715cd770",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "jREUkFNAN9fn5j86rHdiM61pmqax1Q/roKxOiKaotUS6xd3b8TCI1pocQv7F2NA6hWyO1fzPpNQGAVjKOwcYBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.1043222,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "700e9e4a036c41719f1c4df6b8229d04",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "b6f27890616393d289ee7e4b5128252f726799f9c71bfbfdf47ac6e8715cd770",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "vB02aYaHJUzE1NScYWlKT7GKtmNLGAvazuP1dmtJnf1O+qNzQTF9ZjlgaunYthI1eFQDgZPZlUOF2EdkPXNqCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.0962112,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "fed9cc4231847c2a0c5102da2a79103ff18ef105ce95785dae264959ea2cf984",
     "certificate_hash": "1d3e77c1d5f0f25ea43042996193d52c87762f62a4aed7160c11e04f7b315416",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "1bd183f447e872cdbb938292e77bfde278965154c4205c3bef93272bb8646398",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "d7da1ea278f1c35939d1305258b658b3392e536c68dfbb3e4b1386b2ccd7695b",
     "proposal_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 2,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "137c557017f295d683076267b82db0cd17279d907441a1731df65eb2768cdc3a",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "c6ce9d69d4e34092a7cd9e9b1d5a76f7",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "378d5c7987c19ebdeaaa4197ef379a1d033b2fbf812c0dc7f8306f3dab7d9fef",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "MelMeN2GNN96+713l9ddcYc+r2jzAV4Fuo73EQXJ+SDq5ndTSX+tJDzZ3LzXaW1XYWpNSPmGzlw6DkB3qbuTDg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.511522,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "316542e552374cc78c17c84e0436e5a0",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "4567aa1a1416fd72f1979529f4f12444ba61e1dfffb98a1d6083a797fbecce8a",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "rDKiVZGS+2L6xC7ARtBDk3BIp1bK91yCU4/xAxAMaVCTyxjWq0+FldkKYxQeHG8JjkP3QRyRp7SVPbjF1/apDw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.5059075,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bfd88077f9e64060b9e6bf2f6b344c2a",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "378d5c7987c19ebdeaaa4197ef379a1d033b2fbf812c0dc7f8306f3dab7d9fef",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "UhbcaDnrDfn3/asahbKEJExEnpipfoZ1aJawwGfQw9HzQE15CjjFHNln4+a+Qvqk0bA0V3xLwWq3SPZbS7kCAQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.496535,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "137c557017f295d683076267b82db0cd17279d907441a1731df65eb2768cdc3a",
     "certificate_hash": "83cc66db1d0b1bba5837a999a054d5082b6c87e336d58bcc2b27bd5cd3ecdc01",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "03c14fe06599755a79344891b26d134ffdaea014c8746afe763dce946da7b730",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "1bd183f447e872cdbb938292e77bfde278965154c4205c3bef93272bb8646398",
     "proposal_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 3,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "b5292fd41779c8a3dc5a4b1c45e1f01392bdb9972fc38d43d03249599b1605a3",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "939e7f0001314e6ca0c79b53424c73a5",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a769c2e47b4a0a0ea5b1198608e73defa278ed4be917587417a2d2465332c457",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "XtVF1tt2J8wCecK9QVBlm0SIYr10uyBldepi5Z56uGs8p7HIXl0bW58/ZbZecBv2cuXT4sHT2ahhFW8tZYrBBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.925223,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "5843957a9809425ea9db46f384fb9d2d",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a3493cfb982f53a970110de7e4c5c947866924211387b6ad3840c91edb120bbc",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "9W7gTnfwWx8K0dsktIyH7/y6Ur2Pi5IHwF8o55bZ21BUtclFrsiag5WS3786YDLAWFKr54c58MPmKSoPqLQQCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.9067109,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "cdaafdf65b1a44fbb72ecadf3e40e954",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "1f9509fec57516db9ede0577e696526f65c3941c9dab24b2626c6e199dba3a32",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "pPNx7ttHuFi9xfx5dCC9bFZaSk1wRT4ibPPc8EkNRhCCjpIYcz5rlIjjRLOfpMmMIRFrisZdYpcGUSEDxy+/Cw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.9172,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "b5292fd41779c8a3dc5a4b1c45e1f01392bdb9972fc38d43d03249599b1605a3",
     "certificate_hash": "95bd267951c974c963da5cd31f4805ef987570a0afa787cad16cf04913d4eb8d",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "280e1a9ca677546f018f187df50d258e9a21d33311a86212f1d5efff48db2551",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "03c14fe06599755a79344891b26d134ffdaea014c8746afe763dce946da7b730",
     "proposal_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 4,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "ffdf9d111828c5e81d67e1b7d1db80c051dc3a99e012efbbdb060824c9e0a5ad",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bd616cae2d734445b8722a58ce865fb8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "59846d54cb0c9034203a871f8c60f1d7162ceb14178c943426b3f636e74aa766",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "zR7cx0xRkBtlSSm2v4GjTh2ucDvPgNsnkqF/mexkeTR6xDdk+QZ2CBSI2wEO+xCUhypowXrpQbuL+hzNaXBOCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.266133,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "a020b13d493b435cb926ba6fe9ba0543",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "369777e3474d5fac35a8b1b7b30097639d4b9260ddd60624c0f65b9abb5fb7ae",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "s6WfSVdQtqjmw5sjUPwUY/hGEdGakoWC47s01OncEZp/SPNJ+gcpOjDuIZnog3kIEkc8OY0J+oSSxTyL8WkpBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2679513,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "81bfd0cb246d4404a8d96d886f2f5f59",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "369777e3474d5fac35a8b1b7b30097639d4b9260ddd60624c0f65b9abb5fb7ae",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "KvaGtTzyWGq+JuQ8MytJq+rECN7Z98BaeKsWNY7pyYJUNvdf6BUgwX5N0HCgXgIeduQLOqfxzVHKSpGqoQb3AA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2765458,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "ffdf9d111828c5e81d67e1b7d1db80c051dc3a99e012efbbdb060824c9e0a5ad",
     "certificate_hash": "ea29588fa619c3a49858bd1bb37fb9e47830823b9dbc6e773b4e61b7b8e4940a",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "f58926bad193a2ed2123ced6cd9e79fdb59f6e07aa71fe8d5c9edbbe3db8a336",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "280e1a9ca677546f018f187df50d258e9a21d33311a86212f1d5efff48db2551",
     "proposal_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 5,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "f55f87453253cfa80b89e0fed612e8ea0c7c2301a8e484b3825d6a3fcdd049c1",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "04bb4e91327945a288ec234cd6720888",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7649ccfd2d2833c9380428eb5fa58a6e92f09b1488a1a722b5f3948cade3fa1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "0sVU5oGA4mWQjqwVY9NNViQ8qLtyVxS6SaY7ELAFLwdeUd+97zV2CpOaCbhfY4O07UesSqWvpkkNMMd8XMgPBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.658396,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "84bacdde4f0644009b79dd735f54fa31",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "57a3e7b0acd6e2112ae055886549cd4f9249bfcff153c6750fcb025c69702d1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "/YsFSwKIZ48+ElcbGVF25p1KKuQXtdt8y4Ek5G9TdpPhq+FHnHERp1L7f0JholXAz76a+Kwp96u9kxiR+4TJCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6666667,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "b833172b7e2a46588c1e10fdaa1c8888",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "57a3e7b0acd6e2112ae055886549cd4f9249bfcff153c6750fcb025c69702d1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "7f1PXmAF/sCwQZHhvOToKFVxMHnKthv/lTUdKoEldpmB48J9nMcfwQCPMST3rQdOFEr9JRii3ipGZ47OPy3OBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6653566,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "f55f87453253cfa80b89e0fed612e8ea0c7c2301a8e484b3825d6a3fcdd049c1",
     "certificate_hash": "8d8f7de4c1fcd52fa6b117858424c240ce9c916420efe95f994a2c1b878f6b63",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "4096e06ea2dc72fbb88e85a679254c9df22f0ccaea2eef81c8d32b7bab121fa7",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "f58926bad193a2ed2123ced6cd9e79fdb59f6e07aa71fe8d5c9edbbe3db8a336",
     "proposal_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 6,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "a09463b6b7b15d4887faaebc5bb55a408ccae76ee9c65eac59ec454c8b863a44",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "19cc916df6b34d9db694dfa51a1cddfc",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "f5f09b2bfa496b266be11d35b22d665324d35de7e67e593eff4aa577c65bd724",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "damrHDmwyyHx9KmemjILLT2tay2WHIK2uvuywfMKbC+BPNMec739TpDK6VEM/1/cpVbtzVXYn17kh0eTb6D6Aw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.0990534,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "05253690870d48ad9c116bdd296c682b",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "5a094ca4be4b14312079b773c984b2f294526580792791751ce87e419d88547a",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "5S1Lc16pB2+w5jaPoXFHTo2SrCAVCkva1Q8AAdK/0L/63RLkONNgvqjxfYaRtaC6V10n4z0qAuhCgkMvcsCZAQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.10748,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2a1939986d274b96bb52648257346b55",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "5a094ca4be4b14312079b773c984b2f294526580792791751ce87e419d88547a",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "+DG3VnxrQPcDGO6qe7N0KZNqyWLTpY75qwhzxGcUNwfSoxFoUHGafXV0I+eNhVdx3fIAl/gBtK8oh+22nT0XAA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.1048973,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "a09463b6b7b15d4887faaebc5bb55a408ccae76ee9c65eac59ec454c8b863a44",
     "certificate_hash": "7f36796c8aace0b359919378fc1a58c92dd8916aafaa6155628e1787ea5c70ae",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "641a3d939e110b151863022f4221070fa885cfb0c18807b31a302168814424b5",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "4096e06ea2dc72fbb88e85a679254c9df22f0ccaea2eef81c8d32b7bab121fa7",
     "proposal_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 7,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "09c1b24ac242788d505b480fbf1830bdb3e31920f76d0c678ec00e7d2d42a306",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "35ae7b95e4c943deb1bc61246bace4d8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "bca88169a16c8fe362dd2ba280ff02e8b0752d8e99267b86b004e44171f47f58",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "43s9yteH2L+YN+HmxQOpIIPzuOuluPcsSAY+slFWdzWjjchBlg8FbMnKK33kfOI9w2qbUmeKYk/5Ge+CWO6yCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3557553,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2316a558de45429caf1f19207a6d231c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7ac764e1aa436d44d7b2f648b9478f37b615d3141e72ce50ce74714c55c8ca74",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "kiDmILnPjXcwcimbwq73vodzOSfj/f3VgouXIqD8+vyZJCaePrj/+TOcw3OS5hhg1m00nDQLbNN8zD5n1gNHAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3478785,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "7a7a9a08da274de7974023b3cfa23fbf",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7ac764e1aa436d44d7b2f648b9478f37b615d3141e72ce50ce74714c55c8ca74",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "XQ9D8N+7GPL5RvxDwuG/buev2uYwrbT9fJ0sMOInkf6+m/1cFq4MuEcBQjpkFQalDgDqFxjn2iR8+julMdfECg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3520267,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "09c1b24ac242788d505b480fbf1830bdb3e31920f76d0c678ec00e7d2d42a306",
     "certificate_hash": "b90e9ce1e21fb902ee5e9f7f621578742ab6042a92b22af7c65ec824c6038d6b",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "bc662bcfcc8fa2f6f8330fc4b881a0df4886bf805671142ba74b05c8f2d30e4c",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "641a3d939e110b151863022f4221070fa885cfb0c18807b31a302168814424b5",
     "proposal_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 8,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "ad2051d7f5b5d99d0388ac8ee2be5b284c0d0036bf22c97ad848b0fc323fb6a4",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "a1d1efdaee4f443c948f34b7940be575",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "9750bf536aa0ab9c0adba8e069e17057beda05b8e9c3f6ebe00c0e0f058192de",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "05IEqzG8OzJ4QR4XCH8zUZ1jS4atJej94elzIkBXAePlFHLJKoOsKDAwSDm3Vv58yMzrAc7an5BX/EN0z5zOCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0243025,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "7e520997a62b480fa1bac80370debc99",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "94e4b2ee639881419d662837afaade9481912a013a976dc0270bbab2e2844835",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "dd3l4rVteOdA12gl55KwvGGb7zeZ1GKsuK6kHedyAxD+c3Pz9iuCFzKF7+FB686cAKe1SO8c+9JrjFshCfFPCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0058327,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "086c2cc30a6f4fcebdf513ae7612cbb8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "94e4b2ee639881419d662837afaade9481912a013a976dc0270bbab2e2844835",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "4JbCnaW2+nNxaWOmxZb+q0bIMVCDyWBwJe4AYs7RPtuLvk8ewRqzSqufjgWUu0KsCKz2XVS1MHBGTOuNHkSIBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0153315,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "ad2051d7f5b5d99d0388ac8ee2be5b284c0d0036bf22c97ad848b0fc323fb6a4",
     "certificate_hash": "e42eb9607cd141cb94e48b376b48a881104764369f2691e4f3a1170659bb1366",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "931517324f12aed00fe0b28bca91772fb61072e677b43c9ef41c03a55b50eccd",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "bc662bcfcc8fa2f6f8330fc4b881a0df4886bf805671142ba74b05c8f2d30e4c",
     "proposal_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 9,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "b16d574f117ef88a8e513669697fb204caae03363c4952a721a18b58bb6c4565",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "32e4d659887f43f8be11901e64f9ddcf",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "e4f29c563727803ada09a04e2c0fcec625fbfccb1a200ddb901f97653c026f26",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "aq9xlE/w+nWWf6q3fUfxXBXGPWKSKI3bdHKElUmR7NapMyeL/3TzLgEiB5f15dCUKhFH2f7vkEE4HIudUYUHBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4923973,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "b105a4ed082044349f216c07f19856d0",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "95db6bc89a100008f805b56369030ce209180ff85df403bcf87354b8f11140b6",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "nGiWrOJb97v+WlOFfq2rATImUF9Xc5bwzUOwDZWuWO0wXlPZqPbpDdrErIwtKuPAgjC7zTHSmyppN8A5exTJBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4924612,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bfedb645bdd249f291ed7c99eed02a3c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "95db6bc89a100008f805b56369030ce209180ff85df403bcf87354b8f11140b6",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "I8XK6MMIdenG2U/+M+MAjgkjYxfNR1WCdvkTN3931dtVSzSA2qfyryF3lBEi9/rr2LHl9WdhU/foWIP2gtKDBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4929764,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "b16d574f117ef88a8e513669697fb204caae03363c4952a721a18b58bb6c4565",
     "certificate_hash": "9fa968ae8afc899285e154e9b47422501a98f92eca50b88da19c92f174184686",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "7136232f112f5fb92686e42e744de2deb29cf9b6df20ed9a20294b27899f7b4c",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "931517324f12aed00fe0b28bca91772fb61072e677b43c9ef41c03a55b50eccd",
     "proposal_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 10,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "47418403bd4c002b04d9aa9c2889aa45cea79f457d2ced986d2be8d50858db6c",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "313ebec3696e48afabfb226ff898dbeb",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a0f271b3c58ade581bb1c4b890b6d7fff40c8075d8fa212cde7199f1de1d04ba",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "M36v8BevepIP7gYFU2Qu/oY3d6ir2ByxPUwKgsGbVxfqxAevcY9+osROX5feQphoEPJve0zpfDbeijlYLvANCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.5572307,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "632406960aaa463daff6232ca3bf47c9",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "18adb16b4e21e01ee07d5940ae67f709c017ae9d89c7d64ae7af7b74ccdf7bd9",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "9tB+sZeKLNpApZHQ2tYH2MJOHO9rUlc8LjzGQCPX2Ld+qV4kKse8lQ+jCTwXkLKIDtCMjW+rBsxy3hN06TPVCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.5975354,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "29bf405894b44dc69fea9be57b7517df",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "18adb16b4e21e01ee07d5940ae67f709c017ae9d89c7d64ae7af7b74ccdf7bd9",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "3qDaucgCBEwmrVZxTzbS59EZqP5QKZpks1Kk/bWpma8gUqRbsDZjqS2EiX7+aTfz5k9UgNRXaeN3MDVxFKvUCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.4968648,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "47418403bd4c002b04d9aa9c2889aa45cea79f457d2ced986d2be8d50858db6c",
     "certificate_hash": "d231a4ef8c8fce44184c4f744437f27ab71858cd599f88d127a71e919a5fdc7e",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "9cba07fbd29827fe74ee4755fc94eef8ea92be2aa0e2f5d7c937ab80a3d918e8",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "7136232f112f5fb92686e42e744de2deb29cf9b6df20ed9a20294b27899f7b4c",
     "proposal_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 11,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "c252f3f31648940f246a8f7107107ae569950dab2462f550201757e46f6f9a2d",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "c52c4a8729354ba581a6c3728bace892",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "d05166c95bb5f527aad8d4c18fe077c439aa0b075ef1a93019c035e784161421",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "QC/+Xy+0EYMC0WZhIX0FhJqTmCKtiNbBuPJiqZKbkqK/ENsnXEXgg6dkbWg/Wozy2xharoY+Gp/Jku334nnvCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.2562323,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2ceb3eaa911744a0a14a1ea0a2dc2d10",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ad4be7ee39445b1ecc92f35734c25e33b25f304e00fed0069b07a355dbc1b4a",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "CWapoWaGt71FNpJilZ/Hu+64phAz96Z9Gpky+jl7lKv842h2DEC6MrIhr3QWNcl5qBjZTCnqCqCQxiektLKjBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.24661,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "8844deea28224ed3809a19c1823cbdde",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ad4be7ee39445b1ecc92f35734c25e33b25f304e00fed0069b07a355dbc1b4a",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "97Ict+hkS8fZ144HMqmw/i7gstUvw7BIt1wKk3bUge8xpHkVG1pB+thxbuPFyTa9wOhEnzwbUvatjU/3ZgIEAA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.2458797,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "c252f3f31648940f246a8f7107107ae569950dab2462f550201757e46f6f9a2d",
     "certificate_hash": "1dec005d1ae45036b3cda81ec109e105e1e94b889dc75a471eb995fb72b556b0",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "868699fdcf3c2fe57681de8d4b3067da3a9252a9a23883ae6cd6cfd08773fe3f",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "9cba07fbd29827fe74ee4755fc94eef8ea92be2aa0e2f5d7c937ab80a3d918e8",
     "proposal_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 12,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "9dfca54afe5cb3df2d869d39c6d7c850680a159fe1f644b51dba6b44193a8fda",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "9eb91abc1b984588b7b753f355d22ca5",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "e9114bcbb8738f27c8afbbbeee407d014fe9bd718a0ad94eae0cff87d380bd7c",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "fowtKVwdpnDOYr5zNVrSV+8s1Mojs6ho2Xy7AyO6iT9hG1ltf/UYFjo2o874XsvL2pNsSh5T7rniCpqLgAi8Dg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6442034,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2c4b0d18bf414cbaa74721b6fbca7d2b",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "548a802f7b02b8d908a673a5e15946a12cdcf1f6eaaab1be8f5ad6c1177d0201",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "JVF5SqL0JrdNrbtSsHnpf5kQArmpNVYiui2vJ/gYVwLhoOGg8cFZMRMWwndVvszslbBAk+d3bB869von71SZAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6589327,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "f8b93a869c52476aab86b2c1826583cc",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "548a802f7b02b8d908a673a5e15946a12cdcf1f6eaaab1be8f5ad6c1177d0201",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "GQfLCslz5ENVLiaf5fS3rort7vub6iMSwg8c90jmULn8HKdQLhwZD5+0xjHiFKb22H8MVl5/cQD0OYDuNohGCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6310282,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "9dfca54afe5cb3df2d869d39c6d7c850680a159fe1f644b51dba6b44193a8fda",
     "certificate_hash": "c243652d3bee8b67685771c64db83842da8a10962c28214133c013bbd9add1fa",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "e6dcf57097b44da80d7dc179e2030b5fc4b01bfec5134f06e0827165f24e72c3",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "868699fdcf3c2fe57681de8d4b3067da3a9252a9a23883ae6cd6cfd08773fe3f",
     "proposal_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 13,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "df3816d4b88d6fdac4cceeb9861fc808c7869538dee007561583187621ad6edc",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "d4f202011b834aa78cb213d86e587093",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "948e2f36f7b2c74d63d535738c6268b0ae9f886398e7338a33632b15bc00d937",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "XQ3LpRHRQQe4WQsvfOcnTOK8VNDYyW7pG+9Jcn2HFGd8+ZSfV3qWep7ZnwBvaq5d+rv4k2PAUqMsKAC4emruCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.068737,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "776f44a70a1c4c9ea0daa8839b1e0ee3",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "61c3315e727bc161d70ea4027ab3ada6d77ea04beaab7e8486a3ddb0a531fa4f",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "L6fHaGBXXRbXaAfU2+pXhO0eiZo3rejzvKOVm0E1afrCvxraIxTdyWJOn6wysZj9e/txwq1qIhRQm21d4qhNBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.0711305,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "5c376305fcf043d383708bf151eac427",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "61c3315e727bc161d70ea4027ab3ada6d77ea04beaab7e8486a3ddb0a531fa4f",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "JPaxfnyy3oKluxT6HTIyZP8unb0n96E1vzQ9pFllAQQVTtxqdFwdKfgXaF7RPGhUcEv5I4r9LJqpDF4X22k7Ag==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.0680206,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "df3816d4b88d6fdac4cceeb9861fc808c7869538dee007561583187621ad6edc",
     "certificate_hash": "b75659279cc4431110fd40bb7731b601530681a45d30d79254daf350a0398b8a",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "711d699c138e52a61af8f2db977e8dd156b035fb057997329d1526679a2b6641",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "e6dcf57097b44da80d7dc179e2030b5fc4b01bfec5134f06e0827165f24e72c3",
     "proposal_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 14,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    }
   ],
   "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
   "equivocation_proofs": [
    {
     "canonical_digest_A": "746f0b35b3077a20bb1287b19250adf97f526b88c2c233b04a025f2d05c3d640",
     "canonical_digest_B": "e5b45f868ae81bf6ffab933ec97735dd125afbf278eb1fecbac8a7c451f9fa96",
     "detected_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.506150+00:00",
     "detected_by": "qcbz-node-2",
     "epoch": 1,
     "evidence": "primary proposed two different digests for one (view,sequence)",
     "evidence_reference": "cain:bft:equivocation:qcbz-node-1:0:7",
     "height": 7,
     "message_A": {
      "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
      "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
      "epoch": 1,
      "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
      "nonce": "bdbff177aca34d2c9887e4ad3f8610af",
      "payload": {
       "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
       "operation": {
        "action": "write",
        "data": {
         "n": "equiv-1"
        },
        "resource": "byz/equiv-1"
       },
       "request_id": "equiv-1",
       "requested_authority": "standard"
      },
      "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
      "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
      "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "sequence": 7,
      "signature_b64": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
      "timestamp": 1794873504.9901676,
      "view": 0
     },
     "message_B": {
      "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
      "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
      "epoch": 1,
      "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
      "nonce": "100869d31ed6479c98b2b900fb29c6f1",
      "payload": {
       "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
       "operation": {
        "action": "read"
       },
       "request_id": "equiv-1:equivocation",
       "requested_authority": "standard"
      },
      "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
      "request_digest": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
      "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "sequence": 7,
      "signature_b64": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
      "timestamp": 1794873505.0019994,
      "view": 0
     },
     "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
     "phase": "PRE_PREPARE",
     "sequence": 7,
     "signature_A": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
     "signature_B": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
     "statement_A": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
     "statement_B": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
     "timestamp": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.506137+00:00",
     "type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
     "view": 0,
     "witnesses": [
      "qcbz-node-2"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "evidence": {
    "chain_detail": "1 records, head b392426f06d772db5bd0d99223934eee943ec25ec57d0177271bc32fac415055",
    "chain_valid": true,
    "evidence_root": "b392426f06d772db5bd0d99223934eee943ec25ec57d0177271bc32fac415055",
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-2",
    "peer_public_keys": {
     "qcbz-node-1": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
     "qcbz-node-2": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
     "qcbz-node-3": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
     "qcbz-node-4": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew="
    },
    "quorum_health": {
     "can_reach_quorum": true,
     "eligible_voters": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "f": 1,
     "members": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "n": 4,
     "proven_byzantine": 1,
     "quarantined": [
      "qcbz-node-1"
     ],
     "quorum": 3,
     "safe_for_consequential_authorization": true,
     "state": "DEGRADED"
    },
    "records": [
     {
      "event_type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
      "idx": 0,
      "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "payload": {
       "canonical_digest_A": "746f0b35b3077a20bb1287b19250adf97f526b88c2c233b04a025f2d05c3d640",
       "canonical_digest_B": "e5b45f868ae81bf6ffab933ec97735dd125afbf278eb1fecbac8a7c451f9fa96",
       "detected_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.506150+00:00",
       "detected_by": "qcbz-node-2",
       "epoch": 1,
       "evidence": "primary proposed two different digests for one (view,sequence)",
       "evidence_reference": "cain:bft:equivocation:qcbz-node-1:0:7",
       "height": 7,
       "message_A": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
        "nonce": "bdbff177aca34d2c9887e4ad3f8610af",
        "payload": {
         "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
         "operation": {
          "action": "write",
          "data": {
           "n": "equiv-1"
          },
          "resource": "byz/equiv-1"
         },
         "request_id": "equiv-1",
         "requested_authority": "standard"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.9901676,
        "view": 0
       },
       "message_B": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
        "nonce": "100869d31ed6479c98b2b900fb29c6f1",
        "payload": {
         "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
         "operation": {
          "action": "read"
         },
         "request_id": "equiv-1:equivocation",
         "requested_authority": "standard"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.0019994,
        "view": 0
       },
       "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
       "phase": "PRE_PREPARE",
       "sequence": 7,
       "signature_A": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
       "signature_B": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
       "statement_A": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
       "statement_B": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
       "timestamp": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.506137+00:00",
       "type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
       "view": 0,
       "witnesses": [
        "qcbz-node-2"
       ]
      },
      "prev_hash": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
      "record_hash": "b392426f06d772db5bd0d99223934eee943ec25ec57d0177271bc32fac415055",
      "recorded_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.506734+00:00",
      "sequence": 7,
      "view": 0
     }
    ]
   },
   "head_decision_hash": "711d699c138e52a61af8f2db977e8dd156b035fb057997329d1526679a2b6641",
   "quarantined_nodes": [
    "qcbz-node-1"
   ],
   "view": 1
  },
  "qcbz-node-3": {
   "application_state_hash": "7b087245556ee965e477e02979865ee25d45fd813728d74b11f0a027bdf55793",
   "commit_index": 14,
   "commit_qcs": [
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "a848f6d05739281a3cb3b84864cfcac02ffd3579ff03732051b92f1f7a8bd16f",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "ae2468e7d4244e50b35ab6551d5dcca8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ef3eaf99911ee7369692a1aca1500db502f53e6347e9f1e0a0fb9a6f5fa0211",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "IWNUQryGKeEQ3Fj80o7KYnzNskpGuMYZ7tMfxKy4bEf1CDrBsjQ8h1pfXYwtO9muV0GhDyJXoXsoa7bWoYU9Dw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7112405,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "44763f3765704feaa9b87a44663a414e",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "2dfd206de6d3016125165f1943ae5c1046bb4cc5aa0adf0fa1eb859c99fcbee1",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "qMK2Txfti/QeLn1Eo7Xd372DeUX1pgypIYLrBN2bEijdISFPSOAW1aAaNnod0KNhPB8BFWODkHSWf6Q4PDvrBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7313783,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "d8f0dbd1ce1345839c746495ad5714f4",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "2dfd206de6d3016125165f1943ae5c1046bb4cc5aa0adf0fa1eb859c99fcbee1",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "Y+BCrFowF2o4q8vWo/Xegaqzr52mmjmA3ImstqfDdgLB0mx3AgtAlW6+Gp2nEGXKiFKhhC0UcL87owO468tlBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7310822,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "a848f6d05739281a3cb3b84864cfcac02ffd3579ff03732051b92f1f7a8bd16f",
     "certificate_hash": "978580bdf540ef26f6d3a0f17b964cf6508e7a02a2e5101c468ba3260819d1f4",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "d7da1ea278f1c35939d1305258b658b3392e536c68dfbb3e4b1386b2ccd7695b",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "ba6446e1e5d78ada78e3c8b7a70f54af21c37a75708b849c0b3235f03308100d",
     "proposal_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 1,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "278786bb4da14b2eb787594c0a8f33ae4e4e941760aab8dcbf12892c1cdd2d9c",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "89f7375106db428ba0d87c6df99a5948",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "edb815bda869f126bdcc5d712c73b0be3c106b608bddf086557b3aef1cd19935",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "8tOaqJDJUCyoFd03DZPR4M3H8TopV0vDeoZ+6w2pkfJgx+Wp/neaOAdjmO0FjsKX6hF3OwzUvct3n06VFZG8Bw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.1033826,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "700e9e4a036c41719f1c4df6b8229d04",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "b6f27890616393d289ee7e4b5128252f726799f9c71bfbfdf47ac6e8715cd770",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "vB02aYaHJUzE1NScYWlKT7GKtmNLGAvazuP1dmtJnf1O+qNzQTF9ZjlgaunYthI1eFQDgZPZlUOF2EdkPXNqCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.0962112,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "15b9db4ce7a44d79814ee182fce53c2c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "9b21777d6584acb9992c5872eeb7e4614465594e1dff3099d36cfa4a798ca4a6",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "OjdW95z9JeN8JuDTf7ROCxhwODVsyOtsgr6n+aqCzscHCd25AMXhSAnNlna3IvtEOrryWuYsa3suE/VN8xNiDA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.1043425,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "278786bb4da14b2eb787594c0a8f33ae4e4e941760aab8dcbf12892c1cdd2d9c",
     "certificate_hash": "30b86601221ca33ec766f8e0d8bc6fe1e2ca85e0ac3b896d3b0000c30372c218",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "1bd183f447e872cdbb938292e77bfde278965154c4205c3bef93272bb8646398",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "d7da1ea278f1c35939d1305258b658b3392e536c68dfbb3e4b1386b2ccd7695b",
     "proposal_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 2,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "2a086472f4a419f45b0b9a8f28631b4f3efe5d479478485e2470e5583dd0e26f",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "161cedbedfa8442f8b7968a2539d84c9",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6552d8119d6a771a95fddc34cfb80fbc917d66af517651365ff980cada315c30",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "PM648lbUfkoAUBtsl2Gg5023t5byY06AC2Vo+viUT0uFmBGfJ55WexWPT750zRt0SMQXT6RtisNWH7NQY3EICA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.5150883,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "316542e552374cc78c17c84e0436e5a0",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "4567aa1a1416fd72f1979529f4f12444ba61e1dfffb98a1d6083a797fbecce8a",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "rDKiVZGS+2L6xC7ARtBDk3BIp1bK91yCU4/xAxAMaVCTyxjWq0+FldkKYxQeHG8JjkP3QRyRp7SVPbjF1/apDw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.5059075,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bfd88077f9e64060b9e6bf2f6b344c2a",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "378d5c7987c19ebdeaaa4197ef379a1d033b2fbf812c0dc7f8306f3dab7d9fef",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "UhbcaDnrDfn3/asahbKEJExEnpipfoZ1aJawwGfQw9HzQE15CjjFHNln4+a+Qvqk0bA0V3xLwWq3SPZbS7kCAQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.496535,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "2a086472f4a419f45b0b9a8f28631b4f3efe5d479478485e2470e5583dd0e26f",
     "certificate_hash": "314fe8e3c10afb9375e93301f39646170dde5da65aee154b35fa4a4c68295f32",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "03c14fe06599755a79344891b26d134ffdaea014c8746afe763dce946da7b730",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "1bd183f447e872cdbb938292e77bfde278965154c4205c3bef93272bb8646398",
     "proposal_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 3,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "884641e6b9fa8006c28d3d7d44c4f5375ca4f9e9c692211156bc385fe8b886f0",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "5843957a9809425ea9db46f384fb9d2d",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a3493cfb982f53a970110de7e4c5c947866924211387b6ad3840c91edb120bbc",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "9W7gTnfwWx8K0dsktIyH7/y6Ur2Pi5IHwF8o55bZ21BUtclFrsiag5WS3786YDLAWFKr54c58MPmKSoPqLQQCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.9067109,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "cdaafdf65b1a44fbb72ecadf3e40e954",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "1f9509fec57516db9ede0577e696526f65c3941c9dab24b2626c6e199dba3a32",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "pPNx7ttHuFi9xfx5dCC9bFZaSk1wRT4ibPPc8EkNRhCCjpIYcz5rlIjjRLOfpMmMIRFrisZdYpcGUSEDxy+/Cw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.9172,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "c457d753fd9a407e98b343a49501f2e2",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a3493cfb982f53a970110de7e4c5c947866924211387b6ad3840c91edb120bbc",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "al2D3a/yaC4y7EeQDHaLvq95ns3ud3afI7yW6SlbJABlNnrD/Fk0u/5pGbTDhTfV3IwVA+UqSSd0OPxa8j0/AQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.91306,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "884641e6b9fa8006c28d3d7d44c4f5375ca4f9e9c692211156bc385fe8b886f0",
     "certificate_hash": "e0c39962cbecfc692154b82137c0451a360a60c11fc683b59512875763a152a7",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "280e1a9ca677546f018f187df50d258e9a21d33311a86212f1d5efff48db2551",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "03c14fe06599755a79344891b26d134ffdaea014c8746afe763dce946da7b730",
     "proposal_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 4,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "ffdf9d111828c5e81d67e1b7d1db80c051dc3a99e012efbbdb060824c9e0a5ad",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bd616cae2d734445b8722a58ce865fb8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "59846d54cb0c9034203a871f8c60f1d7162ceb14178c943426b3f636e74aa766",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "zR7cx0xRkBtlSSm2v4GjTh2ucDvPgNsnkqF/mexkeTR6xDdk+QZ2CBSI2wEO+xCUhypowXrpQbuL+hzNaXBOCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.266133,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "a020b13d493b435cb926ba6fe9ba0543",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "369777e3474d5fac35a8b1b7b30097639d4b9260ddd60624c0f65b9abb5fb7ae",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "s6WfSVdQtqjmw5sjUPwUY/hGEdGakoWC47s01OncEZp/SPNJ+gcpOjDuIZnog3kIEkc8OY0J+oSSxTyL8WkpBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2679513,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "81bfd0cb246d4404a8d96d886f2f5f59",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "369777e3474d5fac35a8b1b7b30097639d4b9260ddd60624c0f65b9abb5fb7ae",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "KvaGtTzyWGq+JuQ8MytJq+rECN7Z98BaeKsWNY7pyYJUNvdf6BUgwX5N0HCgXgIeduQLOqfxzVHKSpGqoQb3AA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2765458,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "ffdf9d111828c5e81d67e1b7d1db80c051dc3a99e012efbbdb060824c9e0a5ad",
     "certificate_hash": "ea29588fa619c3a49858bd1bb37fb9e47830823b9dbc6e773b4e61b7b8e4940a",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "f58926bad193a2ed2123ced6cd9e79fdb59f6e07aa71fe8d5c9edbbe3db8a336",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "280e1a9ca677546f018f187df50d258e9a21d33311a86212f1d5efff48db2551",
     "proposal_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 5,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "f55f87453253cfa80b89e0fed612e8ea0c7c2301a8e484b3825d6a3fcdd049c1",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "04bb4e91327945a288ec234cd6720888",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7649ccfd2d2833c9380428eb5fa58a6e92f09b1488a1a722b5f3948cade3fa1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "0sVU5oGA4mWQjqwVY9NNViQ8qLtyVxS6SaY7ELAFLwdeUd+97zV2CpOaCbhfY4O07UesSqWvpkkNMMd8XMgPBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.658396,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "84bacdde4f0644009b79dd735f54fa31",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "57a3e7b0acd6e2112ae055886549cd4f9249bfcff153c6750fcb025c69702d1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "/YsFSwKIZ48+ElcbGVF25p1KKuQXtdt8y4Ek5G9TdpPhq+FHnHERp1L7f0JholXAz76a+Kwp96u9kxiR+4TJCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6666667,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "b833172b7e2a46588c1e10fdaa1c8888",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "57a3e7b0acd6e2112ae055886549cd4f9249bfcff153c6750fcb025c69702d1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "7f1PXmAF/sCwQZHhvOToKFVxMHnKthv/lTUdKoEldpmB48J9nMcfwQCPMST3rQdOFEr9JRii3ipGZ47OPy3OBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6653566,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "f55f87453253cfa80b89e0fed612e8ea0c7c2301a8e484b3825d6a3fcdd049c1",
     "certificate_hash": "8d8f7de4c1fcd52fa6b117858424c240ce9c916420efe95f994a2c1b878f6b63",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "4096e06ea2dc72fbb88e85a679254c9df22f0ccaea2eef81c8d32b7bab121fa7",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "f58926bad193a2ed2123ced6cd9e79fdb59f6e07aa71fe8d5c9edbbe3db8a336",
     "proposal_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 6,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "a09463b6b7b15d4887faaebc5bb55a408ccae76ee9c65eac59ec454c8b863a44",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "19cc916df6b34d9db694dfa51a1cddfc",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "f5f09b2bfa496b266be11d35b22d665324d35de7e67e593eff4aa577c65bd724",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "damrHDmwyyHx9KmemjILLT2tay2WHIK2uvuywfMKbC+BPNMec739TpDK6VEM/1/cpVbtzVXYn17kh0eTb6D6Aw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.0990534,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "05253690870d48ad9c116bdd296c682b",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "5a094ca4be4b14312079b773c984b2f294526580792791751ce87e419d88547a",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "5S1Lc16pB2+w5jaPoXFHTo2SrCAVCkva1Q8AAdK/0L/63RLkONNgvqjxfYaRtaC6V10n4z0qAuhCgkMvcsCZAQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.10748,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2a1939986d274b96bb52648257346b55",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "5a094ca4be4b14312079b773c984b2f294526580792791751ce87e419d88547a",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "+DG3VnxrQPcDGO6qe7N0KZNqyWLTpY75qwhzxGcUNwfSoxFoUHGafXV0I+eNhVdx3fIAl/gBtK8oh+22nT0XAA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.1048973,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "a09463b6b7b15d4887faaebc5bb55a408ccae76ee9c65eac59ec454c8b863a44",
     "certificate_hash": "7f36796c8aace0b359919378fc1a58c92dd8916aafaa6155628e1787ea5c70ae",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "641a3d939e110b151863022f4221070fa885cfb0c18807b31a302168814424b5",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "4096e06ea2dc72fbb88e85a679254c9df22f0ccaea2eef81c8d32b7bab121fa7",
     "proposal_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 7,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "09c1b24ac242788d505b480fbf1830bdb3e31920f76d0c678ec00e7d2d42a306",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "35ae7b95e4c943deb1bc61246bace4d8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "bca88169a16c8fe362dd2ba280ff02e8b0752d8e99267b86b004e44171f47f58",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "43s9yteH2L+YN+HmxQOpIIPzuOuluPcsSAY+slFWdzWjjchBlg8FbMnKK33kfOI9w2qbUmeKYk/5Ge+CWO6yCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3557553,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2316a558de45429caf1f19207a6d231c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7ac764e1aa436d44d7b2f648b9478f37b615d3141e72ce50ce74714c55c8ca74",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "kiDmILnPjXcwcimbwq73vodzOSfj/f3VgouXIqD8+vyZJCaePrj/+TOcw3OS5hhg1m00nDQLbNN8zD5n1gNHAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3478785,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "7a7a9a08da274de7974023b3cfa23fbf",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7ac764e1aa436d44d7b2f648b9478f37b615d3141e72ce50ce74714c55c8ca74",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "XQ9D8N+7GPL5RvxDwuG/buev2uYwrbT9fJ0sMOInkf6+m/1cFq4MuEcBQjpkFQalDgDqFxjn2iR8+julMdfECg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3520267,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "09c1b24ac242788d505b480fbf1830bdb3e31920f76d0c678ec00e7d2d42a306",
     "certificate_hash": "b90e9ce1e21fb902ee5e9f7f621578742ab6042a92b22af7c65ec824c6038d6b",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "bc662bcfcc8fa2f6f8330fc4b881a0df4886bf805671142ba74b05c8f2d30e4c",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "641a3d939e110b151863022f4221070fa885cfb0c18807b31a302168814424b5",
     "proposal_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 8,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "ad2051d7f5b5d99d0388ac8ee2be5b284c0d0036bf22c97ad848b0fc323fb6a4",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "a1d1efdaee4f443c948f34b7940be575",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "9750bf536aa0ab9c0adba8e069e17057beda05b8e9c3f6ebe00c0e0f058192de",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "05IEqzG8OzJ4QR4XCH8zUZ1jS4atJej94elzIkBXAePlFHLJKoOsKDAwSDm3Vv58yMzrAc7an5BX/EN0z5zOCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0243025,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "7e520997a62b480fa1bac80370debc99",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "94e4b2ee639881419d662837afaade9481912a013a976dc0270bbab2e2844835",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "dd3l4rVteOdA12gl55KwvGGb7zeZ1GKsuK6kHedyAxD+c3Pz9iuCFzKF7+FB686cAKe1SO8c+9JrjFshCfFPCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0058327,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "086c2cc30a6f4fcebdf513ae7612cbb8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "94e4b2ee639881419d662837afaade9481912a013a976dc0270bbab2e2844835",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "4JbCnaW2+nNxaWOmxZb+q0bIMVCDyWBwJe4AYs7RPtuLvk8ewRqzSqufjgWUu0KsCKz2XVS1MHBGTOuNHkSIBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0153315,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "ad2051d7f5b5d99d0388ac8ee2be5b284c0d0036bf22c97ad848b0fc323fb6a4",
     "certificate_hash": "e42eb9607cd141cb94e48b376b48a881104764369f2691e4f3a1170659bb1366",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "931517324f12aed00fe0b28bca91772fb61072e677b43c9ef41c03a55b50eccd",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "bc662bcfcc8fa2f6f8330fc4b881a0df4886bf805671142ba74b05c8f2d30e4c",
     "proposal_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 9,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "b16d574f117ef88a8e513669697fb204caae03363c4952a721a18b58bb6c4565",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "32e4d659887f43f8be11901e64f9ddcf",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "e4f29c563727803ada09a04e2c0fcec625fbfccb1a200ddb901f97653c026f26",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "aq9xlE/w+nWWf6q3fUfxXBXGPWKSKI3bdHKElUmR7NapMyeL/3TzLgEiB5f15dCUKhFH2f7vkEE4HIudUYUHBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4923973,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "b105a4ed082044349f216c07f19856d0",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "95db6bc89a100008f805b56369030ce209180ff85df403bcf87354b8f11140b6",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "nGiWrOJb97v+WlOFfq2rATImUF9Xc5bwzUOwDZWuWO0wXlPZqPbpDdrErIwtKuPAgjC7zTHSmyppN8A5exTJBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4924612,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bfedb645bdd249f291ed7c99eed02a3c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "95db6bc89a100008f805b56369030ce209180ff85df403bcf87354b8f11140b6",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "I8XK6MMIdenG2U/+M+MAjgkjYxfNR1WCdvkTN3931dtVSzSA2qfyryF3lBEi9/rr2LHl9WdhU/foWIP2gtKDBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4929764,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "b16d574f117ef88a8e513669697fb204caae03363c4952a721a18b58bb6c4565",
     "certificate_hash": "9fa968ae8afc899285e154e9b47422501a98f92eca50b88da19c92f174184686",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "7136232f112f5fb92686e42e744de2deb29cf9b6df20ed9a20294b27899f7b4c",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "931517324f12aed00fe0b28bca91772fb61072e677b43c9ef41c03a55b50eccd",
     "proposal_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 10,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "47418403bd4c002b04d9aa9c2889aa45cea79f457d2ced986d2be8d50858db6c",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "313ebec3696e48afabfb226ff898dbeb",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a0f271b3c58ade581bb1c4b890b6d7fff40c8075d8fa212cde7199f1de1d04ba",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "M36v8BevepIP7gYFU2Qu/oY3d6ir2ByxPUwKgsGbVxfqxAevcY9+osROX5feQphoEPJve0zpfDbeijlYLvANCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.5572307,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "632406960aaa463daff6232ca3bf47c9",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "18adb16b4e21e01ee07d5940ae67f709c017ae9d89c7d64ae7af7b74ccdf7bd9",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "9tB+sZeKLNpApZHQ2tYH2MJOHO9rUlc8LjzGQCPX2Ld+qV4kKse8lQ+jCTwXkLKIDtCMjW+rBsxy3hN06TPVCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.5975354,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "29bf405894b44dc69fea9be57b7517df",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "18adb16b4e21e01ee07d5940ae67f709c017ae9d89c7d64ae7af7b74ccdf7bd9",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "3qDaucgCBEwmrVZxTzbS59EZqP5QKZpks1Kk/bWpma8gUqRbsDZjqS2EiX7+aTfz5k9UgNRXaeN3MDVxFKvUCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.4968648,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "47418403bd4c002b04d9aa9c2889aa45cea79f457d2ced986d2be8d50858db6c",
     "certificate_hash": "d231a4ef8c8fce44184c4f744437f27ab71858cd599f88d127a71e919a5fdc7e",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "9cba07fbd29827fe74ee4755fc94eef8ea92be2aa0e2f5d7c937ab80a3d918e8",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "7136232f112f5fb92686e42e744de2deb29cf9b6df20ed9a20294b27899f7b4c",
     "proposal_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 11,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "c252f3f31648940f246a8f7107107ae569950dab2462f550201757e46f6f9a2d",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "c52c4a8729354ba581a6c3728bace892",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "d05166c95bb5f527aad8d4c18fe077c439aa0b075ef1a93019c035e784161421",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "QC/+Xy+0EYMC0WZhIX0FhJqTmCKtiNbBuPJiqZKbkqK/ENsnXEXgg6dkbWg/Wozy2xharoY+Gp/Jku334nnvCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.2562323,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2ceb3eaa911744a0a14a1ea0a2dc2d10",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ad4be7ee39445b1ecc92f35734c25e33b25f304e00fed0069b07a355dbc1b4a",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "CWapoWaGt71FNpJilZ/Hu+64phAz96Z9Gpky+jl7lKv842h2DEC6MrIhr3QWNcl5qBjZTCnqCqCQxiektLKjBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.24661,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "8844deea28224ed3809a19c1823cbdde",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ad4be7ee39445b1ecc92f35734c25e33b25f304e00fed0069b07a355dbc1b4a",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "97Ict+hkS8fZ144HMqmw/i7gstUvw7BIt1wKk3bUge8xpHkVG1pB+thxbuPFyTa9wOhEnzwbUvatjU/3ZgIEAA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.2458797,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "c252f3f31648940f246a8f7107107ae569950dab2462f550201757e46f6f9a2d",
     "certificate_hash": "1dec005d1ae45036b3cda81ec109e105e1e94b889dc75a471eb995fb72b556b0",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "868699fdcf3c2fe57681de8d4b3067da3a9252a9a23883ae6cd6cfd08773fe3f",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "9cba07fbd29827fe74ee4755fc94eef8ea92be2aa0e2f5d7c937ab80a3d918e8",
     "proposal_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 12,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "9dfca54afe5cb3df2d869d39c6d7c850680a159fe1f644b51dba6b44193a8fda",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "9eb91abc1b984588b7b753f355d22ca5",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "e9114bcbb8738f27c8afbbbeee407d014fe9bd718a0ad94eae0cff87d380bd7c",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "fowtKVwdpnDOYr5zNVrSV+8s1Mojs6ho2Xy7AyO6iT9hG1ltf/UYFjo2o874XsvL2pNsSh5T7rniCpqLgAi8Dg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6442034,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2c4b0d18bf414cbaa74721b6fbca7d2b",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "548a802f7b02b8d908a673a5e15946a12cdcf1f6eaaab1be8f5ad6c1177d0201",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "JVF5SqL0JrdNrbtSsHnpf5kQArmpNVYiui2vJ/gYVwLhoOGg8cFZMRMWwndVvszslbBAk+d3bB869von71SZAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6589327,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "f8b93a869c52476aab86b2c1826583cc",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "548a802f7b02b8d908a673a5e15946a12cdcf1f6eaaab1be8f5ad6c1177d0201",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "GQfLCslz5ENVLiaf5fS3rort7vub6iMSwg8c90jmULn8HKdQLhwZD5+0xjHiFKb22H8MVl5/cQD0OYDuNohGCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6310282,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "9dfca54afe5cb3df2d869d39c6d7c850680a159fe1f644b51dba6b44193a8fda",
     "certificate_hash": "c243652d3bee8b67685771c64db83842da8a10962c28214133c013bbd9add1fa",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "e6dcf57097b44da80d7dc179e2030b5fc4b01bfec5134f06e0827165f24e72c3",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "868699fdcf3c2fe57681de8d4b3067da3a9252a9a23883ae6cd6cfd08773fe3f",
     "proposal_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 13,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "df3816d4b88d6fdac4cceeb9861fc808c7869538dee007561583187621ad6edc",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "d4f202011b834aa78cb213d86e587093",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "948e2f36f7b2c74d63d535738c6268b0ae9f886398e7338a33632b15bc00d937",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "XQ3LpRHRQQe4WQsvfOcnTOK8VNDYyW7pG+9Jcn2HFGd8+ZSfV3qWep7ZnwBvaq5d+rv4k2PAUqMsKAC4emruCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.068737,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "776f44a70a1c4c9ea0daa8839b1e0ee3",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "61c3315e727bc161d70ea4027ab3ada6d77ea04beaab7e8486a3ddb0a531fa4f",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "L6fHaGBXXRbXaAfU2+pXhO0eiZo3rejzvKOVm0E1afrCvxraIxTdyWJOn6wysZj9e/txwq1qIhRQm21d4qhNBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.0711305,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "5c376305fcf043d383708bf151eac427",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "61c3315e727bc161d70ea4027ab3ada6d77ea04beaab7e8486a3ddb0a531fa4f",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "JPaxfnyy3oKluxT6HTIyZP8unb0n96E1vzQ9pFllAQQVTtxqdFwdKfgXaF7RPGhUcEv5I4r9LJqpDF4X22k7Ag==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.0680206,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "df3816d4b88d6fdac4cceeb9861fc808c7869538dee007561583187621ad6edc",
     "certificate_hash": "b75659279cc4431110fd40bb7731b601530681a45d30d79254daf350a0398b8a",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "711d699c138e52a61af8f2db977e8dd156b035fb057997329d1526679a2b6641",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "e6dcf57097b44da80d7dc179e2030b5fc4b01bfec5134f06e0827165f24e72c3",
     "proposal_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 14,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    }
   ],
   "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
   "equivocation_proofs": [
    {
     "canonical_digest_A": "746f0b35b3077a20bb1287b19250adf97f526b88c2c233b04a025f2d05c3d640",
     "canonical_digest_B": "e5b45f868ae81bf6ffab933ec97735dd125afbf278eb1fecbac8a7c451f9fa96",
     "detected_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.499041+00:00",
     "detected_by": "qcbz-node-3",
     "epoch": 1,
     "evidence": "primary proposed two different digests for one (view,sequence)",
     "evidence_reference": "cain:bft:equivocation:qcbz-node-1:0:7",
     "height": 7,
     "message_A": {
      "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
      "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
      "epoch": 1,
      "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
      "nonce": "bdbff177aca34d2c9887e4ad3f8610af",
      "payload": {
       "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
       "operation": {
        "action": "write",
        "data": {
         "n": "equiv-1"
        },
        "resource": "byz/equiv-1"
       },
       "request_id": "equiv-1",
       "requested_authority": "standard"
      },
      "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
      "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
      "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "sequence": 7,
      "signature_b64": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
      "timestamp": 1794873504.9901676,
      "view": 0
     },
     "message_B": {
      "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
      "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
      "epoch": 1,
      "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
      "nonce": "100869d31ed6479c98b2b900fb29c6f1",
      "payload": {
       "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
       "operation": {
        "action": "read"
       },
       "request_id": "equiv-1:equivocation",
       "requested_authority": "standard"
      },
      "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
      "request_digest": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
      "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "sequence": 7,
      "signature_b64": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
      "timestamp": 1794873505.0019994,
      "view": 0
     },
     "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
     "phase": "PRE_PREPARE",
     "sequence": 7,
     "signature_A": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
     "signature_B": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
     "statement_A": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
     "statement_B": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
     "timestamp": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.499030+00:00",
     "type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
     "view": 0,
     "witnesses": [
      "qcbz-node-3"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "evidence": {
    "chain_detail": "1 records, head 07f85f3fc30d9373eae16cf6a33b493c97a3c1bb8b62688654cfa82f1ec6a51f",
    "chain_valid": true,
    "evidence_root": "07f85f3fc30d9373eae16cf6a33b493c97a3c1bb8b62688654cfa82f1ec6a51f",
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-3",
    "peer_public_keys": {
     "qcbz-node-1": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
     "qcbz-node-2": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
     "qcbz-node-3": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
     "qcbz-node-4": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew="
    },
    "quorum_health": {
     "can_reach_quorum": true,
     "eligible_voters": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "f": 1,
     "members": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "n": 4,
     "proven_byzantine": 1,
     "quarantined": [
      "qcbz-node-1"
     ],
     "quorum": 3,
     "safe_for_consequential_authorization": true,
     "state": "DEGRADED"
    },
    "records": [
     {
      "event_type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
      "idx": 0,
      "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "payload": {
       "canonical_digest_A": "746f0b35b3077a20bb1287b19250adf97f526b88c2c233b04a025f2d05c3d640",
       "canonical_digest_B": "e5b45f868ae81bf6ffab933ec97735dd125afbf278eb1fecbac8a7c451f9fa96",
       "detected_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.499041+00:00",
       "detected_by": "qcbz-node-3",
       "epoch": 1,
       "evidence": "primary proposed two different digests for one (view,sequence)",
       "evidence_reference": "cain:bft:equivocation:qcbz-node-1:0:7",
       "height": 7,
       "message_A": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
        "nonce": "bdbff177aca34d2c9887e4ad3f8610af",
        "payload": {
         "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
         "operation": {
          "action": "write",
          "data": {
           "n": "equiv-1"
          },
          "resource": "byz/equiv-1"
         },
         "request_id": "equiv-1",
         "requested_authority": "standard"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.9901676,
        "view": 0
       },
       "message_B": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
        "nonce": "100869d31ed6479c98b2b900fb29c6f1",
        "payload": {
         "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
         "operation": {
          "action": "read"
         },
         "request_id": "equiv-1:equivocation",
         "requested_authority": "standard"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.0019994,
        "view": 0
       },
       "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
       "phase": "PRE_PREPARE",
       "sequence": 7,
       "signature_A": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
       "signature_B": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
       "statement_A": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
       "statement_B": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
       "timestamp": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.499030+00:00",
       "type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
       "view": 0,
       "witnesses": [
        "qcbz-node-3"
       ]
      },
      "prev_hash": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
      "record_hash": "07f85f3fc30d9373eae16cf6a33b493c97a3c1bb8b62688654cfa82f1ec6a51f",
      "recorded_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.499528+00:00",
      "sequence": 7,
      "view": 0
     }
    ]
   },
   "head_decision_hash": "711d699c138e52a61af8f2db977e8dd156b035fb057997329d1526679a2b6641",
   "quarantined_nodes": [
    "qcbz-node-1"
   ],
   "view": 1
  },
  "qcbz-node-4": {
   "application_state_hash": "7b087245556ee965e477e02979865ee25d45fd813728d74b11f0a027bdf55793",
   "commit_index": 14,
   "commit_qcs": [
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "a848f6d05739281a3cb3b84864cfcac02ffd3579ff03732051b92f1f7a8bd16f",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "ae2468e7d4244e50b35ab6551d5dcca8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ef3eaf99911ee7369692a1aca1500db502f53e6347e9f1e0a0fb9a6f5fa0211",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "IWNUQryGKeEQ3Fj80o7KYnzNskpGuMYZ7tMfxKy4bEf1CDrBsjQ8h1pfXYwtO9muV0GhDyJXoXsoa7bWoYU9Dw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7112405,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "44763f3765704feaa9b87a44663a414e",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "2dfd206de6d3016125165f1943ae5c1046bb4cc5aa0adf0fa1eb859c99fcbee1",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "qMK2Txfti/QeLn1Eo7Xd372DeUX1pgypIYLrBN2bEijdISFPSOAW1aAaNnod0KNhPB8BFWODkHSWf6Q4PDvrBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7313783,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "d8f0dbd1ce1345839c746495ad5714f4",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "2dfd206de6d3016125165f1943ae5c1046bb4cc5aa0adf0fa1eb859c99fcbee1",
         "state_root_claim": "6c40c5b342bef51ef0e4af13a039befbc3a9dee50f7d5f10a011f1021c2a785d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 1,
        "signature_b64": "Y+BCrFowF2o4q8vWo/Xegaqzr52mmjmA3ImstqfDdgLB0mx3AgtAlW6+Gp2nEGXKiFKhhC0UcL87owO468tlBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873502.7310822,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "a848f6d05739281a3cb3b84864cfcac02ffd3579ff03732051b92f1f7a8bd16f",
     "certificate_hash": "978580bdf540ef26f6d3a0f17b964cf6508e7a02a2e5101c468ba3260819d1f4",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "d7da1ea278f1c35939d1305258b658b3392e536c68dfbb3e4b1386b2ccd7695b",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "ba6446e1e5d78ada78e3c8b7a70f54af21c37a75708b849c0b3235f03308100d",
     "proposal_digest": "a6452d99174fe286899a2bf7377f1043e07919ab6f2ba6ece826ae6db8a641d5",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 1,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "278786bb4da14b2eb787594c0a8f33ae4e4e941760aab8dcbf12892c1cdd2d9c",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "89f7375106db428ba0d87c6df99a5948",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "edb815bda869f126bdcc5d712c73b0be3c106b608bddf086557b3aef1cd19935",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "8tOaqJDJUCyoFd03DZPR4M3H8TopV0vDeoZ+6w2pkfJgx+Wp/neaOAdjmO0FjsKX6hF3OwzUvct3n06VFZG8Bw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.1033826,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "700e9e4a036c41719f1c4df6b8229d04",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "b6f27890616393d289ee7e4b5128252f726799f9c71bfbfdf47ac6e8715cd770",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "vB02aYaHJUzE1NScYWlKT7GKtmNLGAvazuP1dmtJnf1O+qNzQTF9ZjlgaunYthI1eFQDgZPZlUOF2EdkPXNqCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.0962112,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "15b9db4ce7a44d79814ee182fce53c2c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "9b21777d6584acb9992c5872eeb7e4614465594e1dff3099d36cfa4a798ca4a6",
         "state_root_claim": "885085053db4399915de2349c2a7e490ba1aed78f7ec11aa7ed903e34608cf5d"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 2,
        "signature_b64": "OjdW95z9JeN8JuDTf7ROCxhwODVsyOtsgr6n+aqCzscHCd25AMXhSAnNlna3IvtEOrryWuYsa3suE/VN8xNiDA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.1043425,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "278786bb4da14b2eb787594c0a8f33ae4e4e941760aab8dcbf12892c1cdd2d9c",
     "certificate_hash": "30b86601221ca33ec766f8e0d8bc6fe1e2ca85e0ac3b896d3b0000c30372c218",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "1bd183f447e872cdbb938292e77bfde278965154c4205c3bef93272bb8646398",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "d7da1ea278f1c35939d1305258b658b3392e536c68dfbb3e4b1386b2ccd7695b",
     "proposal_digest": "9a07ae375c63bb397bf9967d185a8b7df388aa3e79a7ed937a2bee7b53660a3a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 2,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "2a086472f4a419f45b0b9a8f28631b4f3efe5d479478485e2470e5583dd0e26f",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "161cedbedfa8442f8b7968a2539d84c9",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6552d8119d6a771a95fddc34cfb80fbc917d66af517651365ff980cada315c30",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "PM648lbUfkoAUBtsl2Gg5023t5byY06AC2Vo+viUT0uFmBGfJ55WexWPT750zRt0SMQXT6RtisNWH7NQY3EICA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.5150883,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "316542e552374cc78c17c84e0436e5a0",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "4567aa1a1416fd72f1979529f4f12444ba61e1dfffb98a1d6083a797fbecce8a",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "rDKiVZGS+2L6xC7ARtBDk3BIp1bK91yCU4/xAxAMaVCTyxjWq0+FldkKYxQeHG8JjkP3QRyRp7SVPbjF1/apDw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.5059075,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bfd88077f9e64060b9e6bf2f6b344c2a",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "378d5c7987c19ebdeaaa4197ef379a1d033b2fbf812c0dc7f8306f3dab7d9fef",
         "state_root_claim": "126cab37363836b95af3721d97b4882a2c175db2b2873d838a3de4647347db98"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 3,
        "signature_b64": "UhbcaDnrDfn3/asahbKEJExEnpipfoZ1aJawwGfQw9HzQE15CjjFHNln4+a+Qvqk0bA0V3xLwWq3SPZbS7kCAQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.496535,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "2a086472f4a419f45b0b9a8f28631b4f3efe5d479478485e2470e5583dd0e26f",
     "certificate_hash": "314fe8e3c10afb9375e93301f39646170dde5da65aee154b35fa4a4c68295f32",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "03c14fe06599755a79344891b26d134ffdaea014c8746afe763dce946da7b730",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "1bd183f447e872cdbb938292e77bfde278965154c4205c3bef93272bb8646398",
     "proposal_digest": "7597f622a8c7b4b28335117d39d25f1874bfe14f20ccc5b01e3d1f54774ba816",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 3,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "884641e6b9fa8006c28d3d7d44c4f5375ca4f9e9c692211156bc385fe8b886f0",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "5843957a9809425ea9db46f384fb9d2d",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a3493cfb982f53a970110de7e4c5c947866924211387b6ad3840c91edb120bbc",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "9W7gTnfwWx8K0dsktIyH7/y6Ur2Pi5IHwF8o55bZ21BUtclFrsiag5WS3786YDLAWFKr54c58MPmKSoPqLQQCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.9067109,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "cdaafdf65b1a44fbb72ecadf3e40e954",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "1f9509fec57516db9ede0577e696526f65c3941c9dab24b2626c6e199dba3a32",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "pPNx7ttHuFi9xfx5dCC9bFZaSk1wRT4ibPPc8EkNRhCCjpIYcz5rlIjjRLOfpMmMIRFrisZdYpcGUSEDxy+/Cw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.9172,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "c457d753fd9a407e98b343a49501f2e2",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a3493cfb982f53a970110de7e4c5c947866924211387b6ad3840c91edb120bbc",
         "state_root_claim": "e86579d2ed67550708973a5805b38d5f6eb79ecf09f587e7ce989f3e6cc01cdd"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 4,
        "signature_b64": "al2D3a/yaC4y7EeQDHaLvq95ns3ud3afI7yW6SlbJABlNnrD/Fk0u/5pGbTDhTfV3IwVA+UqSSd0OPxa8j0/AQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873503.91306,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "884641e6b9fa8006c28d3d7d44c4f5375ca4f9e9c692211156bc385fe8b886f0",
     "certificate_hash": "e0c39962cbecfc692154b82137c0451a360a60c11fc683b59512875763a152a7",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "280e1a9ca677546f018f187df50d258e9a21d33311a86212f1d5efff48db2551",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "03c14fe06599755a79344891b26d134ffdaea014c8746afe763dce946da7b730",
     "proposal_digest": "d0475ad9ff65dc37d166834c593a8822560d2daaff6449b4fa8dfbf0916c0a03",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 4,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "6ccd838a66796c2a53189ea2ed88b313cf6edfefd4817d2f2a5a61d5c2ff0380",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-1": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "ad1865eddab44107861b4950784a3c46",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "14a6650d3592101cc2981ab3a56012548f089e271b2aa4b499f5faa4a620e5a3",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "WrpuSIinAHzSK6WBtQ6wlVIRCc85yLHDyoXHxLE3q+w2uQjbGDWy4NlR/lY3seJnpnZEmwWhSzrdmPnlcpYLAw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2822428,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "a020b13d493b435cb926ba6fe9ba0543",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "369777e3474d5fac35a8b1b7b30097639d4b9260ddd60624c0f65b9abb5fb7ae",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "s6WfSVdQtqjmw5sjUPwUY/hGEdGakoWC47s01OncEZp/SPNJ+gcpOjDuIZnog3kIEkc8OY0J+oSSxTyL8WkpBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2679513,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "81bfd0cb246d4404a8d96d886f2f5f59",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "369777e3474d5fac35a8b1b7b30097639d4b9260ddd60624c0f65b9abb5fb7ae",
         "state_root_claim": "f39c5639b6a9a0a4400e141a77e9c997317c3898b2a640473b773e30d49adbe7"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 5,
        "signature_b64": "KvaGtTzyWGq+JuQ8MytJq+rECN7Z98BaeKsWNY7pyYJUNvdf6BUgwX5N0HCgXgIeduQLOqfxzVHKSpGqoQb3AA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.2765458,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-1",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "6ccd838a66796c2a53189ea2ed88b313cf6edfefd4817d2f2a5a61d5c2ff0380",
     "certificate_hash": "85c3f9d045ac64220f8b9424ff934c121f0d788badd6504d1a9175f5ad3e324c",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "f58926bad193a2ed2123ced6cd9e79fdb59f6e07aa71fe8d5c9edbbe3db8a336",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "280e1a9ca677546f018f187df50d258e9a21d33311a86212f1d5efff48db2551",
     "proposal_digest": "442f83cf141d1f727c07de19687fb40f398c82a9651a2fadd642edbc5000138a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 5,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "78c2e67a95804657f9129a34d46c650b780c893aa4e33e7110373cf0fcec83a5",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "84bacdde4f0644009b79dd735f54fa31",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "57a3e7b0acd6e2112ae055886549cd4f9249bfcff153c6750fcb025c69702d1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "/YsFSwKIZ48+ElcbGVF25p1KKuQXtdt8y4Ek5G9TdpPhq+FHnHERp1L7f0JholXAz76a+Kwp96u9kxiR+4TJCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6666667,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "b833172b7e2a46588c1e10fdaa1c8888",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "57a3e7b0acd6e2112ae055886549cd4f9249bfcff153c6750fcb025c69702d1f",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "7f1PXmAF/sCwQZHhvOToKFVxMHnKthv/lTUdKoEldpmB48J9nMcfwQCPMST3rQdOFEr9JRii3ipGZ47OPy3OBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6653566,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "0b9db7d72c3645babaaee2c5293737b5",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "264a72def1483a3acf1fda3966c3d8e6194839ca72c0037c31cdc86439b7bf5c",
         "state_root_claim": "767918c1eb3c4873e45021c696c8a9414122d4dbf488c2f2f9db61eb25379221"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 6,
        "signature_b64": "/gUHlxa1jNARB+NvccY+KXBKxsZM2Phpwg58j7ZApmmBHwrpf+SrMfPvmZLBC1yDMj/KIlEmKtVJ6M/lbDzLBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.6714075,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "78c2e67a95804657f9129a34d46c650b780c893aa4e33e7110373cf0fcec83a5",
     "certificate_hash": "5f141d2bad78209ed3e69529289595ee4c5febb24fcc5d2c3be52d8b684da6c7",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "4096e06ea2dc72fbb88e85a679254c9df22f0ccaea2eef81c8d32b7bab121fa7",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "f58926bad193a2ed2123ced6cd9e79fdb59f6e07aa71fe8d5c9edbbe3db8a336",
     "proposal_digest": "e1de96859b981e799a183cd9a6c1d180be0b366b3b8d97dd59d0ba456546cb05",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 6,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "7e49633deb72f378949b8323a6fe85c128995486e280fc6ab2db75883ea481a6",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "05253690870d48ad9c116bdd296c682b",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "5a094ca4be4b14312079b773c984b2f294526580792791751ce87e419d88547a",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "5S1Lc16pB2+w5jaPoXFHTo2SrCAVCkva1Q8AAdK/0L/63RLkONNgvqjxfYaRtaC6V10n4z0qAuhCgkMvcsCZAQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.10748,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2a1939986d274b96bb52648257346b55",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "5a094ca4be4b14312079b773c984b2f294526580792791751ce87e419d88547a",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "+DG3VnxrQPcDGO6qe7N0KZNqyWLTpY75qwhzxGcUNwfSoxFoUHGafXV0I+eNhVdx3fIAl/gBtK8oh+22nT0XAA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.1048973,
        "view": 0
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "f189b1a40a764b9db995d4f1547cb8b9",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "8f0e3014c1973e1b57992a8e698cd49418d2e24f128770b0e5c2db06bd4e7e1c",
         "state_root_claim": "2cd7dc9188f7128068088ce490c7114ac9becfba16a1ae9008be92b904fc4612"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "wkn+PUhQ9zKb6vHrCqkldDWB+Pz2M26etdJHBjHlXWlyZLTcBECrXa3z30BhIKlrmMIRh5IvL8WwgC5vXgtXDw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.1122532,
        "view": 0
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "7e49633deb72f378949b8323a6fe85c128995486e280fc6ab2db75883ea481a6",
     "certificate_hash": "f3513d7a52e09a8401046f2c97e3eebcb7049b1ff0e196c2975bdd2cfc60e5a1",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "641a3d939e110b151863022f4221070fa885cfb0c18807b31a302168814424b5",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "4096e06ea2dc72fbb88e85a679254c9df22f0ccaea2eef81c8d32b7bab121fa7",
     "proposal_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 7,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 0
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "09c1b24ac242788d505b480fbf1830bdb3e31920f76d0c678ec00e7d2d42a306",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "35ae7b95e4c943deb1bc61246bace4d8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "bca88169a16c8fe362dd2ba280ff02e8b0752d8e99267b86b004e44171f47f58",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "43s9yteH2L+YN+HmxQOpIIPzuOuluPcsSAY+slFWdzWjjchBlg8FbMnKK33kfOI9w2qbUmeKYk/5Ge+CWO6yCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3557553,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2316a558de45429caf1f19207a6d231c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7ac764e1aa436d44d7b2f648b9478f37b615d3141e72ce50ce74714c55c8ca74",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "kiDmILnPjXcwcimbwq73vodzOSfj/f3VgouXIqD8+vyZJCaePrj/+TOcw3OS5hhg1m00nDQLbNN8zD5n1gNHAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3478785,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "7a7a9a08da274de7974023b3cfa23fbf",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "7ac764e1aa436d44d7b2f648b9478f37b615d3141e72ce50ce74714c55c8ca74",
         "state_root_claim": "29b39cf9c8748f2801f015f78199579ac4ab78e55e990ddd067843a8af2a73ec"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 8,
        "signature_b64": "XQ9D8N+7GPL5RvxDwuG/buev2uYwrbT9fJ0sMOInkf6+m/1cFq4MuEcBQjpkFQalDgDqFxjn2iR8+julMdfECg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873506.3520267,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "09c1b24ac242788d505b480fbf1830bdb3e31920f76d0c678ec00e7d2d42a306",
     "certificate_hash": "b90e9ce1e21fb902ee5e9f7f621578742ab6042a92b22af7c65ec824c6038d6b",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "bc662bcfcc8fa2f6f8330fc4b881a0df4886bf805671142ba74b05c8f2d30e4c",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "641a3d939e110b151863022f4221070fa885cfb0c18807b31a302168814424b5",
     "proposal_digest": "622b3f22488f492b668be0c192b5a848e750cc7e0edb7df5f3986eb94422182c",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 8,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "ad2051d7f5b5d99d0388ac8ee2be5b284c0d0036bf22c97ad848b0fc323fb6a4",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "a1d1efdaee4f443c948f34b7940be575",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "9750bf536aa0ab9c0adba8e069e17057beda05b8e9c3f6ebe00c0e0f058192de",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "05IEqzG8OzJ4QR4XCH8zUZ1jS4atJej94elzIkBXAePlFHLJKoOsKDAwSDm3Vv58yMzrAc7an5BX/EN0z5zOCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0243025,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "7e520997a62b480fa1bac80370debc99",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "94e4b2ee639881419d662837afaade9481912a013a976dc0270bbab2e2844835",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "dd3l4rVteOdA12gl55KwvGGb7zeZ1GKsuK6kHedyAxD+c3Pz9iuCFzKF7+FB686cAKe1SO8c+9JrjFshCfFPCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0058327,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "086c2cc30a6f4fcebdf513ae7612cbb8",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "94e4b2ee639881419d662837afaade9481912a013a976dc0270bbab2e2844835",
         "state_root_claim": "6f83e85cb474efb9b97c064a234fce3e92544af05024c8f3022f4e6a0cca5196"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 9,
        "signature_b64": "4JbCnaW2+nNxaWOmxZb+q0bIMVCDyWBwJe4AYs7RPtuLvk8ewRqzSqufjgWUu0KsCKz2XVS1MHBGTOuNHkSIBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.0153315,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "ad2051d7f5b5d99d0388ac8ee2be5b284c0d0036bf22c97ad848b0fc323fb6a4",
     "certificate_hash": "e42eb9607cd141cb94e48b376b48a881104764369f2691e4f3a1170659bb1366",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "931517324f12aed00fe0b28bca91772fb61072e677b43c9ef41c03a55b50eccd",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "bc662bcfcc8fa2f6f8330fc4b881a0df4886bf805671142ba74b05c8f2d30e4c",
     "proposal_digest": "452aa2f5e004efcf6d471c227c347b946bb867f971489745545de440b39cb59a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 9,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "b16d574f117ef88a8e513669697fb204caae03363c4952a721a18b58bb6c4565",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "32e4d659887f43f8be11901e64f9ddcf",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "e4f29c563727803ada09a04e2c0fcec625fbfccb1a200ddb901f97653c026f26",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "aq9xlE/w+nWWf6q3fUfxXBXGPWKSKI3bdHKElUmR7NapMyeL/3TzLgEiB5f15dCUKhFH2f7vkEE4HIudUYUHBw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4923973,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "b105a4ed082044349f216c07f19856d0",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "95db6bc89a100008f805b56369030ce209180ff85df403bcf87354b8f11140b6",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "nGiWrOJb97v+WlOFfq2rATImUF9Xc5bwzUOwDZWuWO0wXlPZqPbpDdrErIwtKuPAgjC7zTHSmyppN8A5exTJBQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4924612,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "bfedb645bdd249f291ed7c99eed02a3c",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "95db6bc89a100008f805b56369030ce209180ff85df403bcf87354b8f11140b6",
         "state_root_claim": "764b7c8eea2dfaa9c4636df9a41ab323e75ad71789f6d63d7e2ed0dc01098315"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 10,
        "signature_b64": "I8XK6MMIdenG2U/+M+MAjgkjYxfNR1WCdvkTN3931dtVSzSA2qfyryF3lBEi9/rr2LHl9WdhU/foWIP2gtKDBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873507.4929764,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "b16d574f117ef88a8e513669697fb204caae03363c4952a721a18b58bb6c4565",
     "certificate_hash": "9fa968ae8afc899285e154e9b47422501a98f92eca50b88da19c92f174184686",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "7136232f112f5fb92686e42e744de2deb29cf9b6df20ed9a20294b27899f7b4c",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "931517324f12aed00fe0b28bca91772fb61072e677b43c9ef41c03a55b50eccd",
     "proposal_digest": "d565d5f4ea074c3b87428b83046692b21a9908765273070b058d4f3903293bc3",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 10,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "47418403bd4c002b04d9aa9c2889aa45cea79f457d2ced986d2be8d50858db6c",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "313ebec3696e48afabfb226ff898dbeb",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "a0f271b3c58ade581bb1c4b890b6d7fff40c8075d8fa212cde7199f1de1d04ba",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "M36v8BevepIP7gYFU2Qu/oY3d6ir2ByxPUwKgsGbVxfqxAevcY9+osROX5feQphoEPJve0zpfDbeijlYLvANCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.5572307,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "632406960aaa463daff6232ca3bf47c9",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "18adb16b4e21e01ee07d5940ae67f709c017ae9d89c7d64ae7af7b74ccdf7bd9",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "9tB+sZeKLNpApZHQ2tYH2MJOHO9rUlc8LjzGQCPX2Ld+qV4kKse8lQ+jCTwXkLKIDtCMjW+rBsxy3hN06TPVCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.5975354,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "29bf405894b44dc69fea9be57b7517df",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "18adb16b4e21e01ee07d5940ae67f709c017ae9d89c7d64ae7af7b74ccdf7bd9",
         "state_root_claim": "0af56eaf82b718bd47499d4f4a696713721e981fc2bc57fdb4e8b50ef9d711a9"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 11,
        "signature_b64": "3qDaucgCBEwmrVZxTzbS59EZqP5QKZpks1Kk/bWpma8gUqRbsDZjqS2EiX7+aTfz5k9UgNRXaeN3MDVxFKvUCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873508.4968648,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "47418403bd4c002b04d9aa9c2889aa45cea79f457d2ced986d2be8d50858db6c",
     "certificate_hash": "d231a4ef8c8fce44184c4f744437f27ab71858cd599f88d127a71e919a5fdc7e",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "9cba07fbd29827fe74ee4755fc94eef8ea92be2aa0e2f5d7c937ab80a3d918e8",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "7136232f112f5fb92686e42e744de2deb29cf9b6df20ed9a20294b27899f7b4c",
     "proposal_digest": "345e01bddaa3c6b5bb94ab165484baa755547cf2559558cea09360781b1a8230",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 11,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "c252f3f31648940f246a8f7107107ae569950dab2462f550201757e46f6f9a2d",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "c52c4a8729354ba581a6c3728bace892",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "d05166c95bb5f527aad8d4c18fe077c439aa0b075ef1a93019c035e784161421",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "QC/+Xy+0EYMC0WZhIX0FhJqTmCKtiNbBuPJiqZKbkqK/ENsnXEXgg6dkbWg/Wozy2xharoY+Gp/Jku334nnvCQ==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.2562323,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2ceb3eaa911744a0a14a1ea0a2dc2d10",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ad4be7ee39445b1ecc92f35734c25e33b25f304e00fed0069b07a355dbc1b4a",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "CWapoWaGt71FNpJilZ/Hu+64phAz96Z9Gpky+jl7lKv842h2DEC6MrIhr3QWNcl5qBjZTCnqCqCQxiektLKjBg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.24661,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "8844deea28224ed3809a19c1823cbdde",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "6ad4be7ee39445b1ecc92f35734c25e33b25f304e00fed0069b07a355dbc1b4a",
         "state_root_claim": "589603a35f84892752afa59b3d531611229cd05eb2682d84e39737732cf028c0"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 12,
        "signature_b64": "97Ict+hkS8fZ144HMqmw/i7gstUvw7BIt1wKk3bUge8xpHkVG1pB+thxbuPFyTa9wOhEnzwbUvatjU/3ZgIEAA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.2458797,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "c252f3f31648940f246a8f7107107ae569950dab2462f550201757e46f6f9a2d",
     "certificate_hash": "1dec005d1ae45036b3cda81ec109e105e1e94b889dc75a471eb995fb72b556b0",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "868699fdcf3c2fe57681de8d4b3067da3a9252a9a23883ae6cd6cfd08773fe3f",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "9cba07fbd29827fe74ee4755fc94eef8ea92be2aa0e2f5d7c937ab80a3d918e8",
     "proposal_digest": "6bf3f784c887e7b6d2f7e1ce5baf6764f443ce8b47fffb28c5228e2d9a509f01",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 12,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "9dfca54afe5cb3df2d869d39c6d7c850680a159fe1f644b51dba6b44193a8fda",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "9eb91abc1b984588b7b753f355d22ca5",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "e9114bcbb8738f27c8afbbbeee407d014fe9bd718a0ad94eae0cff87d380bd7c",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "fowtKVwdpnDOYr5zNVrSV+8s1Mojs6ho2Xy7AyO6iT9hG1ltf/UYFjo2o874XsvL2pNsSh5T7rniCpqLgAi8Dg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6442034,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "2c4b0d18bf414cbaa74721b6fbca7d2b",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "548a802f7b02b8d908a673a5e15946a12cdcf1f6eaaab1be8f5ad6c1177d0201",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "JVF5SqL0JrdNrbtSsHnpf5kQArmpNVYiui2vJ/gYVwLhoOGg8cFZMRMWwndVvszslbBAk+d3bB869von71SZAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6589327,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "f8b93a869c52476aab86b2c1826583cc",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "548a802f7b02b8d908a673a5e15946a12cdcf1f6eaaab1be8f5ad6c1177d0201",
         "state_root_claim": "f1a2dae48cb02576edf4192d9161e29d52a1556b8de58817c30510b97e206d21"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 13,
        "signature_b64": "GQfLCslz5ENVLiaf5fS3rort7vub6iMSwg8c90jmULn8HKdQLhwZD5+0xjHiFKb22H8MVl5/cQD0OYDuNohGCg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873509.6310282,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "9dfca54afe5cb3df2d869d39c6d7c850680a159fe1f644b51dba6b44193a8fda",
     "certificate_hash": "c243652d3bee8b67685771c64db83842da8a10962c28214133c013bbd9add1fa",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "e6dcf57097b44da80d7dc179e2030b5fc4b01bfec5134f06e0827165f24e72c3",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "868699fdcf3c2fe57681de8d4b3067da3a9252a9a23883ae6cd6cfd08773fe3f",
     "proposal_digest": "81795abe905ff813ea14a6364a72ca6f81f5d9b8840d0169d2e900733a369903",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 13,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    },
    {
     "bundle": {
      "aggregate_signature": null,
      "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
      "algorithm_version": 1,
      "bundle_hash": "df3816d4b88d6fdac4cceeb9861fc808c7869538dee007561583187621ad6edc",
      "individual_signatures": {
       "qcbz-node-2": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "d4f202011b834aa78cb213d86e587093",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "948e2f36f7b2c74d63d535738c6268b0ae9f886398e7338a33632b15bc00d937",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-2",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "XQ3LpRHRQQe4WQsvfOcnTOK8VNDYyW7pG+9Jcn2HFGd8+ZSfV3qWep7ZnwBvaq5d+rv4k2PAUqMsKAC4emruCw==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.068737,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-3": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "776f44a70a1c4c9ea0daa8839b1e0ee3",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "61c3315e727bc161d70ea4027ab3ada6d77ea04beaab7e8486a3ddb0a531fa4f",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-3",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "L6fHaGBXXRbXaAfU2+pXhO0eiZo3rejzvKOVm0E1afrCvxraIxTdyWJOn6wysZj9e/txwq1qIhRQm21d4qhNBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.0711305,
        "view": 1
       },
       "qcbz-node-4": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "COMMIT",
        "nonce": "5c376305fcf043d383708bf151eac427",
        "payload": {
         "prepared_cert_hash": "61c3315e727bc161d70ea4027ab3ada6d77ea04beaab7e8486a3ddb0a531fa4f",
         "state_root_claim": "4330ea1198208d7b86c3fc4ab3fa7613139f0e0a8167bca3b1c4dacb22cf27b1"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew=",
        "request_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-4",
        "sequence": 14,
        "signature_b64": "JPaxfnyy3oKluxT6HTIyZP8unb0n96E1vzQ9pFllAQQVTtxqdFwdKfgXaF7RPGhUcEv5I4r9LJqpDF4X22k7Ag==",
        "timestamp": 1794873510.0680206,
        "view": 1
       }
      },
      "signer_set": [
       "qcbz-node-2",
       "qcbz-node-3",
       "qcbz-node-4"
      ]
     },
     "bundle_hash": "df3816d4b88d6fdac4cceeb9861fc808c7869538dee007561583187621ad6edc",
     "certificate_hash": "b75659279cc4431110fd40bb7731b601530681a45d30d79254daf350a0398b8a",
     "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
     "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
     "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
     "decision_hash": "711d699c138e52a61af8f2db977e8dd156b035fb057997329d1526679a2b6641",
     "epoch": 1,
     "leader_proposal": null,
     "leader_proposal_digest": null,
     "parent_decision_hash": "e6dcf57097b44da80d7dc179e2030b5fc4b01bfec5134f06e0827165f24e72c3",
     "proposal_digest": "e7acb14d4c932cb050ec007bde6eaf853761a400e3ec73049b8f9818ea1b2d7a",
     "quorum": 3,
     "quorum_policy": {
      "f": 1,
      "n": 4,
      "quorum": 3,
      "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
     },
     "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
     "sequence": 14,
     "signer_set": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "view": 1
    }
   ],
   "configuration_hash": "b6f116e556a7d7da0fa446e9d8db02f2c6649168d51a5ef3a82ceb776cae3013",
   "equivocation_proofs": [
    {
     "canonical_digest_A": "746f0b35b3077a20bb1287b19250adf97f526b88c2c233b04a025f2d05c3d640",
     "canonical_digest_B": "e5b45f868ae81bf6ffab933ec97735dd125afbf278eb1fecbac8a7c451f9fa96",
     "detected_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.704865+00:00",
     "detected_by": "qcbz-node-4",
     "epoch": 1,
     "evidence": "primary proposed two different digests for one (view,sequence)",
     "evidence_reference": "cain:bft:equivocation:qcbz-node-1:0:7",
     "height": 7,
     "message_A": {
      "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
      "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
      "epoch": 1,
      "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
      "nonce": "bdbff177aca34d2c9887e4ad3f8610af",
      "payload": {
       "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
       "operation": {
        "action": "write",
        "data": {
         "n": "equiv-1"
        },
        "resource": "byz/equiv-1"
       },
       "request_id": "equiv-1",
       "requested_authority": "standard"
      },
      "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
      "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
      "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "sequence": 7,
      "signature_b64": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
      "timestamp": 1794873504.9901676,
      "view": 0
     },
     "message_B": {
      "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
      "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
      "epoch": 1,
      "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
      "nonce": "100869d31ed6479c98b2b900fb29c6f1",
      "payload": {
       "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
       "operation": {
        "action": "read"
       },
       "request_id": "equiv-1:equivocation",
       "requested_authority": "standard"
      },
      "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
      "request_digest": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
      "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "sequence": 7,
      "signature_b64": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
      "timestamp": 1794873505.0019994,
      "view": 0
     },
     "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
     "phase": "PRE_PREPARE",
     "sequence": 7,
     "signature_A": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
     "signature_B": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
     "statement_A": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
     "statement_B": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
     "timestamp": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.704854+00:00",
     "type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
     "view": 0,
     "witnesses": [
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "evidence": {
    "chain_detail": "1 records, head 47b4c859ccfaf4cd87d8de8e9c9e6dd08fdfa18db8c899f5d395c34d355e9ef2",
    "chain_valid": true,
    "evidence_root": "47b4c859ccfaf4cd87d8de8e9c9e6dd08fdfa18db8c899f5d395c34d355e9ef2",
    "node_id": "qcbz-node-4",
    "peer_public_keys": {
     "qcbz-node-1": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
     "qcbz-node-2": "nS1KvohE8wU8PG0vtaqfpnwcc9LhiBIjz5nwtQsxlBc=",
     "qcbz-node-3": "EJgty1XrI/GoR7n1rY8IqiUGWpKKaLiJVL86eCfay7M=",
     "qcbz-node-4": "ijU4Avbe3pG1GMXneuDT1hJfEFndk+m/o3g/6n1X1ew="
    },
    "quorum_health": {
     "can_reach_quorum": true,
     "eligible_voters": [
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "f": 1,
     "members": [
      "qcbz-node-1",
      "qcbz-node-2",
      "qcbz-node-3",
      "qcbz-node-4"
     ],
     "n": 4,
     "proven_byzantine": 1,
     "quarantined": [
      "qcbz-node-1"
     ],
     "quorum": 3,
     "safe_for_consequential_authorization": true,
     "state": "DEGRADED"
    },
    "records": [
     {
      "event_type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
      "idx": 0,
      "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
      "payload": {
       "canonical_digest_A": "746f0b35b3077a20bb1287b19250adf97f526b88c2c233b04a025f2d05c3d640",
       "canonical_digest_B": "e5b45f868ae81bf6ffab933ec97735dd125afbf278eb1fecbac8a7c451f9fa96",
       "detected_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.704865+00:00",
       "detected_by": "qcbz-node-4",
       "epoch": 1,
       "evidence": "primary proposed two different digests for one (view,sequence)",
       "evidence_reference": "cain:bft:equivocation:qcbz-node-1:0:7",
       "height": 7,
       "message_A": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
        "nonce": "bdbff177aca34d2c9887e4ad3f8610af",
        "payload": {
         "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
         "operation": {
          "action": "write",
          "data": {
           "n": "equiv-1"
          },
          "resource": "byz/equiv-1"
         },
         "request_id": "equiv-1",
         "requested_authority": "standard"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
        "timestamp": 1794873504.9901676,
        "view": 0
       },
       "message_B": {
        "cluster_id": "cain42-pbft-byzantine-evidence",
        "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
        "epoch": 1,
        "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
        "nonce": "100869d31ed6479c98b2b900fb29c6f1",
        "payload": {
         "client_id": "byzantine-evidence",
         "operation": {
          "action": "read"
         },
         "request_id": "equiv-1:equivocation",
         "requested_authority": "standard"
        },
        "public_key_b64": "+Cp6zfCDPtI3fKLv14ZBw1Z4jA+YABX9GXlSOIqo7Zk=",
        "request_digest": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
        "sender_id": "qcbz-node-1",
        "sequence": 7,
        "signature_b64": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
        "timestamp": 1794873505.0019994,
        "view": 0
       },
       "node_id": "qcbz-node-1",
       "phase": "PRE_PREPARE",
       "sequence": 7,
       "signature_A": "rMflhEF538rHKGpG5u+/FJBkQDkv6blQP3TCZFOpYYrbx6q9V1QhBtgBzw9wmX7drXutZYLaE6wfWLEIzjFLAg==",
       "signature_B": "+ZXnb5zordTQCpwch6ErcWfE6bUhejqKACbatIfv1B9CCGWUaEmZe+YLFXwRQjijXQpwxA9cjd7i25QQeJGnBA==",
       "statement_A": "02256b4dbcedddf6bf4cd94cefd8b7a4ba8a7ecbbae931d4be46c142b9203299",
       "statement_B": "9f1535f29c85b5e1b2a5141e5833103ff466e1debedad579bdd8ea2fba411ed9",
       "timestamp": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.704854+00:00",
       "type": "EQUIVOCATION_PROOF",
       "view": 0,
       "witnesses": [
        "qcbz-node-4"
       ]
      },
      "prev_hash": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
      "record_hash": "47b4c859ccfaf4cd87d8de8e9c9e6dd08fdfa18db8c899f5d395c34d355e9ef2",
      "recorded_at": "2026-11-16T23:58:25.705320+00:00",
      "sequence": 7,
      "view": 0
     }
    ]
   },
   "head_decision_hash": "711d699c138e52a61af8f2db977e8dd156b035fb057997329d1526679a2b6641",
   "quarantined_nodes": [
    "qcbz-node-1"
   ],
   "view": 1
  }
 },
 "not_claimed": [
  "independent failure domains (all four containers ran on one VPS)",
  "that the live clusters run this build",
  "fault tolerance beyond f=1",
  "third-party review",
  "absence of bugs"
 ],
 "run_log": [
  {
   "event": "building cain-cluster-node:qcbz-b40c05b from b40c05b988a8f1eafd37c3b55b0eb7cac39d45b1",
   "t": 1794873441.292
  },
  {
   "event": "deployed 4 disposable nodes; fault injection enabled, mode none",
   "t": 1794873471.905
  },
  {
   "event": "6 warm-up writes committed in view 0, height 6",
   "t": 1794873504.916
  },
  {
   "event": "set qcbz-node-1 byzantine_mode=equivocate (primary for view 0)",
   "t": 1794873504.954
  },
  {
   "event": "equivocation trigger 1: ALLOW COMMITTED",
   "t": 1794873506.127
  },
  {
   "event": "equivocation trigger 2: ALLOW COMMITTED",
   "t": 1794873506.62
  },
  {
   "event": "honest replicas quarantined qcbz-node-1 and installed view 1",
   "t": 1794873506.84
  },
  {
   "event": "6 writes committed after containment; honest height 14 view 1",
   "t": 1794873510.534
  },
  {
   "event": "collected evidence and 14 commit certificates from 3 honest nodes",
   "t": 1794873512.656
  }
 ],
 "source_commitment": {
  "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
  "git_commit": "b40c05b988a8f1eafd37c3b55b0eb7cac39d45b1",
  "image_id": "sha256:96fe07622d5415a1767f72aeef9979581e935f2bd36cc357938e3dc4f6725944",
  "note": "source is not published; the commit hash is a commitment"
 },
 "view_after_containment": 1,
 "what_this_is": "A primary that signed two conflicting PRE_PREPAREs for the same (view, sequence) was detected by the honest replicas, which persisted signed equivocation proofs, quarantined it, changed view and kept committing. The bundle carries each honest node's hash-chained Byzantine evidence log, its proofs, and every commit certificate up to height 14."
}