{
  "schema": "cain42.sovereign.evo01.z3_results.v1",
  "z3_version": "5.1.0",
  "results": [
    {
      "property": "strict_mode_executes_without_valid_proof",
      "invariant": "I1,I12",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "f280a6829862401120c7a8178c5bd2d95a17d84eb67798cdcde4862e63903bb4"
    },
    {
      "property": "strict_mode_executes_with_unproved_status",
      "invariant": "I8",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "538c3ef27a57fbe29f87f462ca33eee8351c3c7fdc38d171a5d35db9623534c7"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_unpinned_signer",
      "invariant": "I2,I3",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "000e1a49f51fb8db20bd207992e8a165d7b8fb7d942e0d02ef7182e742cead9a"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_unbound_or_changed_arguments",
      "invariant": "I5,I13",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "6e7c5acb1b34e38d8e082496cb15679e5ad18cb5af7c32dde993b0137aaa9c8f"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_other_principal",
      "invariant": "I6",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "32405f9337a1f34639a7d42f45c4a72983b39278c2cf51cac34d9d196b0613ab"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_expired_or_unbounded",
      "invariant": "I4",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "536dbefd9fd06ef45b5c497b5e6eaa6c9fd7ec05668e031bf5b8e03de4992620"
    },
    {
      "property": "same_proof_allowed_twice",
      "invariant": "I10,I14",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "3f0afbe94b6d7c024a391ada80d2e28f9b70dee7c1b97060f8e28b44d1426c5b"
    },
    {
      "property": "strict_mode_executes_without_valid_proof",
      "invariant": "I1,I12",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "other_stage_allow": "False",
        "other_stage_deny": "False",
        "proof_stage_installed": "True",
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_agent_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_nonce_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "False",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "False",
        "strict_mode": "True"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "6f21fc52039caa15e8cf774077dc0e411d48eeee66a821e03d215cbbc7876166"
    },
    {
      "property": "strict_mode_executes_with_unproved_status",
      "invariant": "I8",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "other_stage_allow": "True",
        "other_stage_deny": "False",
        "proof_stage_installed": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "False",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "False",
        "strict_mode": "True"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "45271394283ab577d400842027d6a22f6366fabe7b9c30ad131c6773e344cc77"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_unpinned_signer",
      "invariant": "I2,I3",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_agent_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "False",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "False"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "3c8700ba9f3b025b3276275d67c3ce2c5b0fa516f6ebb52eedc131002e3c5cac"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_unbound_or_changed_arguments",
      "invariant": "I5,I13",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_agent_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "False",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "False"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "0f516bef1612c7d18a81f351928e3682f92a24097155ff90186e59453932859e"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_other_principal",
      "invariant": "I6",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_agent_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "False",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "False"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "7a35025fe74be54b00a33ab4e7fe1c278c8f7d1811a0a8fd493c5b93386ccb32"
    },
    {
      "property": "proof_stage_allows_expired_or_unbounded",
      "invariant": "I4",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_agent_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "False",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "False"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "61cd1f3731f1c5a57285541959ab7d315b867fecb9f1b1e8805aa6d07cfcccb6"
    },
    {
      "property": "same_proof_allowed_twice",
      "invariant": "I10,I14",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_agent_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_nonce_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "False",
        "r2_agent_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r2_agent_matches": "False",
        "r2_arguments_digest_matches": "False",
        "r2_arguments_digest_nonempty": "False",
        "r2_nonce_nonempty": "False",
        "r2_proof_present": "True",
        "r2_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r2_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r2_signed": "True",
        "r2_signer_is_pinned_key": "False",
        "r2_tenant_id_nonempty": "False",
        "r2_tenant_matches": "False",
        "r2_tool_matches": "True",
        "r2_valid_until_set": "False",
        "r2_within_validity_window": "False",
        "stage_ledger_configured": "False",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "False"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "540ac67a832421d1062dce460c59e30bf0259b303b4528b679d25c2b1acda1ae"
    },
    {
      "property": "FIXED_allows_attacker_holding_pinned_key",
      "invariant": "I3 (A2 dropped)",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "attacker_holds_pinned_key": "True",
        "r1_agent_id_nonempty": "True",
        "r1_agent_matches": "True",
        "r1_arguments_digest_matches": "True",
        "r1_arguments_digest_nonempty": "True",
        "r1_nonce_nonempty": "True",
        "r1_proof_present": "True",
        "r1_proof_status_PROVED": "True",
        "r1_signature_verifies": "True",
        "r1_signed": "True",
        "r1_signer_is_pinned_key": "True",
        "r1_tenant_id_nonempty": "True",
        "r1_tenant_matches": "True",
        "r1_tool_matches": "True",
        "r1_valid_until_set": "True",
        "r1_within_validity_window": "True",
        "stage_ledger_configured": "True",
        "stage_pinned_configured": "True"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A3"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "802e6080b537f48491f45b7b9ba516f2d933d94e1498944d8eca2f0050a120db"
    },
    {
      "property": "any_stage_deny_is_executed",
      "invariant": "I1",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "05dbb7dc154509b2fa79edd6465161065be2959e0b821ed560f6bafa423aa6d6"
    },
    {
      "property": "any_stage_deny_is_executed",
      "invariant": "I1",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A3",
        "A4",
        "A5",
        "A6"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "3d4744c209cc71c71e33ddc2a52964094797cdef9b98b187c0a602ac330fdaec"
    },
    {
      "property": "mcpgate_token_forwards_contained_agent",
      "invariant": "I1,I12",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A5",
        "A6",
        "A7: quarantine state readable and current at decision time"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "125e2c73a5f1c976edf26da35085ffa33cb0305871762013e6c718fbcee20448"
    },
    {
      "property": "mcpgate_token_forwards_contained_agent",
      "invariant": "I1,I12",
      "version": "BEFORE",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "action_hash_matches": "True",
        "agent_quarantined_or_killswitch": "True",
        "identity_grants_tool": "True",
        "model_continuity_ok": "True",
        "principal_key_registered_active": "True",
        "token_nonce_unused": "True",
        "token_signature_valid": "True"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A5",
        "A6",
        "A7: quarantine state readable and current at decision time"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "16af9fbd69a027a62d99b879bbdbbb2ca53371e70f981e36fcb7d3bc9d819145"
    },
    {
      "property": "mcpgate_token_overrides_operator_allowlist (OPEN D-S46-11)",
      "invariant": "I11,I12",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "SAT",
      "actual": "SAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": {
        "action_hash_matches": "True",
        "agent_quarantined_or_killswitch": "False",
        "identity_grants_tool": "True",
        "model_continuity_ok": "True",
        "operator_allowlist_allows": "False",
        "principal_key_registered_active": "True",
        "token_nonce_unused": "True",
        "token_signature_valid": "True"
      },
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A5",
        "A6",
        "A7: quarantine state readable and current at decision time"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "6a56358e622b4786ea2772e65a7f04d785849f9bc88ebcc8be27b781d2836b3b"
    },
    {
      "property": "mcpgate_token_executes_with_changed_parameters",
      "invariant": "I5,I13",
      "version": "FIXED",
      "expected": "UNSAT",
      "actual": "UNSAT",
      "match": true,
      "counterexample": null,
      "assumptions": [
        "A1",
        "A2",
        "A5",
        "A6",
        "A7: quarantine state readable and current at decision time"
      ],
      "smt2_sha256": "b56abf4a77912c93ba2b4c79781c6ef03126facd15ba29d929891136cf74ed9f"
    }
  ]
}
