{
  "schema": "cain42.sovereign.evo03.traceability.v1",
  "note": "UNSAT rules out a counterexample only inside the encoded model; it does not establish code/model equivalence",
  "rows": [
    {
      "item": "Operator allowlist precedence (I11/I12)",
      "formal": "no ALLOW with token unless baseline ALLOWs",
      "source": "cain/mcp_proxy.py token branch (eaf8d4fa)",
      "test": "test_sovereign_e2_token_precedence_side_effects.py",
      "model": "evolution-02 formal: E2 UNSAT, E1/BEFORE SAT",
      "discrepancy": "none known; model abstracts baseline as one predicate",
      "production": "NO PRODUCTION PATH"
    },
    {
      "item": "Quarantine before invocation (I1)",
      "formal": "contained -> no forward",
      "source": "token branch containment + baseline",
      "test": "side-effect tests http/stdio",
      "model": "UNSAT E2/E1",
      "discrepancy": "A7: store current",
      "production": "NO PRODUCTION PATH"
    },
    {
      "item": "Landlock confinement of stdio tool servers",
      "formal": "fs/TCP access outside profile denied in child and descendants",
      "source": "cain/landlock_sandbox.py, StdioMCPProxy (bfe0637e)",
      "test": "test_sovereign_e3_landlock.py",
      "model": "not modelled (kernel behaviour measured directly)",
      "discrepancy": "n/a",
      "production": "opt-in, not configured anywhere"
    },
    {
      "item": "Hostile input fails safe",
      "formal": "malformed/oversized/nested/burst -> no forward, proxy survives",
      "source": "process_incoming_request + evaluate try/except",
      "test": "test_sovereign_e3_resource_exhaustion.py",
      "model": "none",
      "discrepancy": "n/a",
      "production": "NO PRODUCTION PATH"
    },
    {
      "item": "Hosted proof stage binding/replay",
      "formal": "see Evolution 1",
      "source": "cain/continuum/hosted_pipeline.py (c0b6a64b)",
      "test": "test_sovereign_e1_hosted_proof_stage_fail_closed.py",
      "model": "evolution-01 formal",
      "discrepancy": "PROVED is a signed claim",
      "production": "NOT ROUTED (v27)"
    },
    {
      "item": "Optional signer pins (cain_proof_carrying_action.py, z3_solver_gate.verify_proof_action, attestation_bound_pca.py, swarm_protocol.py)",
      "formal": "unpinned -> any key",
      "source": "unchanged",
      "test": "none new",
      "model": "evolution-01 A2-dropped SAT",
      "discrepancy": "n/a",
      "production": "no production caller"
    },
    {
      "item": "Stolen pinned/release key",
      "formal": "key holder can sign",
      "source": "all signature checks",
      "test": "n/a",
      "model": "SAT by construction when A2 dropped",
      "discrepancy": "n/a",
      "production": "explicit risk"
    },
    {
      "item": "Kit confidentiality + integrity",
      "formal": "no source in kit; manifest bytes verify; signature verifies",
      "source": "KIT_SLOT/manifests; kit 8.3.1",
      "test": "test_sovereign_e3_evidence_integrity.py; cain42_verify.py PASS_INTEGRITY",
      "model": "none",
      "discrepancy": "trust anchor operator-asserted",
      "production": "8.3.1 published; 8.3.0 withdrawn (verified)"
    }
  ]
}