# Sovereign Evolution 4 — Baseline Reconciliation Report
## Forensic Verification of Evolution 3 Baseline, Three-Site Routing, and IHVRK State

**Timestamp:** 2026-10-12T05:20:00Z  
**Branch:** `ironclad-prompt8-qualification`  
**Commit:** `d190f159ae668d9baf970daec3c83b9af981dac2`  
**Host Kernel:** Linux 7.0.0-38-generic (x86_64), Landlock ABI 8  

---

### 1. Repository & Commit Lineage

- **Active HEAD:** `d190f159ae668d9baf970daec3c83b9af981dac2`
- **Branch:** `ironclad-prompt8-qualification`
- **Remote Configuration:** `git remote -v` returns empty. There is no configured remote Git origin.
- **Working Tree State:** 213 files modified/untracked, reflecting ongoing multi-session developments across Sovereign evolutions, IHVRK, and platform gateway.
- **Commit History Lineage:**
  - `d190f159`: MCPGate hostile-input tests (resource exhaustion, fuzzing, concurrency).
  - `bb8b313e`: IHVRK evidence carriage in `ihvrk/related_evidence/`.
  - `bfe0637e`: Landlock restriction for stdio tool servers.
  - `62abf1cb`: Auditor kit 8.3.1 release.
  - `96d5c1d5`: Auditor kit 8.3.1 release manifest signature.

---

### 2. Local Test Execution Verification

All reported Evolution 2, Evolution 3, and IHVRK test suites were executed directly:

| Test Suite | Command | Result | Duration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mediated Launcher Boundary | `python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_evolution_3_mediated_launcher.py` | 9 passed, 0 failed | 2.22s |
| Landlock ABI 8 Kernel Sandboxing | `python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_sovereign_e3_landlock.py` | 11 passed, 0 failed | 2.03s |
| Resource Ceilings & Fuzzing | `python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_sovereign_e3_resource_exhaustion.py` | 11 passed, 0 failed | 6.36s |
| Evolution 2 Adversarial Suite | `python3 -m pytest -q tests/test_evolution_2_adversarial.py` | 17 passed, 0 failed | 1.21s |
| IHVRK Full Regression Suite | `python3 -m pytest -q ihvrk/tests` | 300 passed, 0 failed | 23.58s |
| **Total** | | **348 passed, 0 failed** | **35.40s** |

All 348 tests passed with exit code 0.

---

### 3. IHVRK Manifest & Standalone Verifier Reconciliation

- **File Count:** 68 files registered in `ihvrk/evidence/MANIFEST.json`.
- **Standalone Verifier Execution:**
  ```bash
  cd ihvrk/evidence && python3 verify_ihvrk_evidence.py
  ```
  - **Verdict:** `RESULT: PASS (9 checks, 0 failed)`.
  - E1 Manifest file hashes: PASS (68 files match SHA-256).
  - E2 Test results: PASS (300 passed, 0 failed, 0 error, 0 skipped).
  - E3 Z3 Proofs: PASS (control SAT, 15 invariants UNSAT, sensitivity SAT).
  - E4 TLC Model Check: PASS (design NO_ERROR, broken variants caught).
  - E5 Mutation Testing: PASS (30/30 mutants killed).
  - E6 Sample Ledger: PASS (chain, digests, and signed checkpoint verified).
  - E7 Tamper Detection: PASS (modified, deleted, truncated ledgers rejected).

---

### 4. Three-Site Live Status Probing

All three production domains were probed via read-only HTTPS GET requests on 2026-10-12 at 05:07:04Z:

| Domain | URL / Resource | HTTP Status | Content-Length / SHA-256 |
|---|---|---|---|
| `cainstudio.online` | `/verification-center/` | **200 OK** | 41,499 bytes |
| `cainstudio.online` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.0/cain42-auditor-kit-8.3.0.zip` | **404 Not Found** | (Withdrawn) |
| `cainstudio.online` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.0/WITHDRAWN.json` | **200 OK** | 589 bytes |
| `cainstudio.online` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.1/cain42-auditor-kit-8.3.1.zip` | **200 OK** | 2,448,822 bytes (`7a42d690...`) |
| `mcpgate.online` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.0/cain42-auditor-kit-8.3.0.zip` | **404 Not Found** | (Withdrawn) |
| `mcpgate.online` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.1/cain42-auditor-kit-8.3.1.zip` | **200 OK** | 2,448,822 bytes (`7a42d690...`) |
| `clawx.click` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.0/cain42-auditor-kit-8.3.0.zip` | **404 Not Found** | (Withdrawn) |
| `clawx.click` | `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.1/cain42-auditor-kit-8.3.1.zip` | **200 OK** | 2,448,822 bytes (`7a42d690...`) |
| All three sites | `/health` | **200 OK** | 49 bytes |

**Findings:**
1. **Kit 8.3.0 is completely withdrawn across all three sites:** Direct HTTP GET returns `404 Not Found` everywhere; `WITHDRAWN.json` explains the reason.
2. **Kit 8.3.1 is consistently served across all three sites:** All three return byte-for-byte identical archives (2,448,822 bytes, SHA-256 `7a42d69055a059207fbdc0f0f39c713507662cf707c737e6ad578694b0f222d6`).
3. **Verification Center:** Exists on `cainstudio.online` at `/verification-center/` (HTTP 200).

---

### 5. Homepage Verification Center Discoverability Gap

Inspection of `platform-gateway/frontend/index.html` revealed:
- An announcement bar / command center (`.c42-command-center`) exists at lines 359–448 with header `CAIN-42 Independent Verification Center`.
- However, its primary buttons and links lead to `/evidence/auditor-kit/8.3.1/` rather than the canonical `/verification-center/` front door.
- The top bar has a single link `Auditors: verify CAIN-42 →` to `/verification-center/`, but the main navigation menu (`nav.c42-nav`) does not include `/verification-center/` under the Proof category.
- **Requirement:** Integrate a prominent, unambiguous direct link to `/verification-center/` in both the hero section and navigation to ensure visitors arriving at https://cainstudio.online find the Verification Center immediately.

---

### 6. Operational Status & Release Gate Reconciliation

- **Local Software Tests:** **PASS** (348/348 passed).
- **Kernel Containment:** **PARTIAL** (Active on stdio proxy and mediated launcher; gateway hosted tools unconfined).
- **Auditor Kit:** **PASS** (8.3.1 verified `PASS_INTEGRITY`).
- **Hosted CI:** **BLOCKED** (No Git remote configured).
- **Production Deployment:** **BLOCKED** (No live production route passes customer traffic through MCPGate).
- **Overall Release Gate Verdict:** **BLOCKED** (Honest four-dimension gate).
