# FORMAL MATHEMATICAL VERIFICATION REPORT
## Project Sovereign — CAIN-42 × TALOS × IHVRK
### Evolution 6: Operation Absolute Sovereign

**Engine:** Microsoft Z3 SMT Solver v5.1.0  
**Model File:** [`verification/sovereign/e6_cain_talos_z3.py`](file:///root/cain-studio-platform/verification/sovereign/e6_cain_talos_z3.py)  
**Schema:** `cain42.sovereign.evo06.z3_proofs.v1`  
**Execution Result:** **PASS (18/18 Invariants UNSAT, Control SAT, 18 Sensitivity Mutants SAT)**  
**Runtime:** 0.0808 seconds  

---

### Verification Methodology & Mathematical Guarantees

1. **Control Consistency (SAT):**
   - Asserts that when all security predicates are satisfied (valid signature, trusted key, unrevoked decision, matching principal/tenant, matching action/target/scope, matching parameters digest, fresh nonce, unexpired timestamp, active Landlock enforcement boundary, and isolated worker), execution is permitted (`ALLOW`).
   - Outcome: **`SAT`** (Proven satisfiable).

2. **Counterexample Falsification (UNSAT):**
   - For each invariant, the negation of the safety guarantee is asserted alongside the verification constraints. An **`UNSAT`** result proves that no counterexample state exists within the mathematical model.
   - Outcome: **`UNSAT`** for all 18 invariants.

3. **Mutation Non-Vacuity (SAT):**
   - For every invariant, a mutation is introduced that drops or weakens the corresponding defensive constraint.
   - Outcome: **`SAT`** for all 18 mutants, mathematically proving that every constraint is active, load-bearing, and non-vacuous.

---

### Invariant Verification Table

| Invariant ID | Formal Property Proved | Z3 Result | Mutant Result | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `INV-01` | **No Authorization, No Execution:** Forged/invalid authorization cannot yield execution. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-02` | **Expired Envelopes Rejected:** Envelopes past expiration timestamp fail closed (`EXPIRED`). | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-03` | **Consumed Nonces Rejected:** Single-use nonce reuse fails closed (`REPLAYED`). | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-04` | **Signature Tampering Rejected:** Byte alteration in signed payload fails verification. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-05` | **Scope Attenuation Monotonicity:** Privilege widening beyond authorized scope is rejected. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-06` | **Untrusted Keys Rejected:** Signatures from keys outside trusted keystore fail closed. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-07` | **Indeterminate Fail-Closed:** System faults or uncertainty never convert to `ALLOW`. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-08` | **Policy Hash Mismatch Rejected:** Stale or altered policy digests fail closed (`DENY`). | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-09` | **Revocation Enforcement:** Revoked keys or decisions immediately fail closed (`REVOKED`). | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-10` | **Independent TALOS Boundary:** CAIN decisions cannot bypass TALOS verification. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-11` | **Mandatory Human Approval:** High-impact critical operations require signed human approval. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-12` | **Identity Spoofing Rejected:** Cross-tenant or agent DID substitution fails verification. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-13` | **Enforcement Boundary Integrity:** Execution cannot proceed without active barrier. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-14` | **Clock Drift Protection:** Future-dated envelopes outside tolerance window rejected. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-15` | **Denial Monotonicity:** CAIN-42 `DENY` decision cannot be flipped to `ALLOW` by TALOS. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-16` | **Worker Process Isolation:** Untrusted tool execution cannot run unconfined in the gateway. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-17` | **TOCTOU Prevention:** Normalized parameter mutation between check and exec is rejected. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |
| `INV-18` | **Fail-Closed Worker Crash:** Worker abort or failure preserves crash state; no success receipt. | `UNSAT` | `SAT` | **PASS** |

---

### Scope & Modeling Assumptions
- Cryptographic primitives (Ed25519, SHA-256) are modeled as ideal black-box functions.
- Linux kernel primitives (`prctl`, Landlock LSM ABI 8) are assumed faithful to their syscall semantics.
- Formal proofs establish the absence of logical bypasses within the specified transition and state rules. They do not model physical side-channel attacks or kernel Ring 0 zero-day exploits.
